Is there anything wrong with having a collection of nonfiring flintlock pistol replicas instead of ones that do fire?

[Skyros]

[Twalli]

A former college classmate (we were all history majors) brought in several guns that were used in World War II. Actual guns that had been used then. They were filled with wood, and had no firing pin, but they were actual real guns. He also brough in bullets that were used then too.

[abc3643]

Well, they might violate The Prime Directive.

https://www.youtube.com/embed/n1J0K1OxdSI

[alice55]

there's nothing wrong in that, my grandfather have actual real legit firearms that are loaded it's mostly old history stuff though, I fail to see the point of having fake one but there's nothing wrong with it

[purplepoppy]

But what are you going to do if you suddenly find yourself captain of a 17th century pirate ship and under attack? Do you think your motley crew will be happy with duds? I think not.

[OneViewpoint]

My crew will be thrilled that I spent the booty on cannon and cutlasses and rum.

[Skyros]

I’m with you on that lad 🏴‍☠️.

[AI Opinion]

There's absolutely nothing wrong with collecting nonfiring flintlock pistol replicas. Many people enjoy the historical and artistic aspects of such replicas. They can be quite detailed and beautiful, serving as great conversation pieces. Plus, they offer the added benefit of safety, as they can't be used as functioning firearms. It's a unique and interesting hobby that allows you to appreciate historical craftsmanship and design without the risks associated with live firearms. 😊🔫

[FreyaRed]

Ancient black powder firearms are in most countries legal. So it's wrong you don't want a real one.

[Skyros]

I want a real one, just don’t have the money.

[DryGermanGuy]

Not inherently, no, it’s a hobby. Your answers to people asking you about it could potentially make it weird.

[loveslongnails]

Why would it be wrong either way, if that's what you're into?

[Pohjolan]

Its a bit weird like collecting non-alcoholic wines.

What if you need to use one for home defense?

https://www.youtube.com/embed/V1fZWx8tS9Q

[NathanDavis]

just make sure to declare it as a collectible... just in case

[OneViewpoint]

Collect whatever you want.

[Skyros]

Thanks

[OneViewpoint]

Is it a historical interest for you or a cosplay thing? Something else? Whatever your reasons, you're not hurting anyone. Have fun with it.

[Skyros]

Just historical. I’m a historian and those are my favorite guns of all time.

[OneViewpoint]

That's cool. There's a tie to your career. Conversation pieces when you have people over. Seems pretty normal.

[OneViewpoint]

To be honest I don't see the point of owning real historical pieces. Expensive. Valuable. They belong in museums in the hands of curators. Also I'd be afraid to fire them for fear of destroying them or having them blow up in my hand or face.

[Skyros]

You are right. Even a reproduction cost about $550. I just got a high quality replica for $89 plus shipping.

[Dargil]

There was nothing wrong with having a collection of "Assault rifles."

[Anonymous]

Why not have the real thing so they have historical meaning and value?

[AngryCarl2]

Sounds a lot safer, if I'm honest.

#HalynaHutchins

[chickychickyparmparm]

whatever makes you happen.

[RavVid]

Nothing at all.

[exitseven]

No, but never take one to a gun fight.

[Anonymous]

No. I see nothing wrong with that.