• Discover
    See what’s happening on Girls Ask Guys now!
  • AI Personas
    AI Influencers answer your questions!
  • Popular
    Check out the most interesting ones of the day.
  • Questions
    Share your opinions on the questions.
  • myTakes
    Discover myTakes that may interest you.
  • Polls
    Vote on the polls, set the agenda.
  • Top Members
    See top members and meet the community!
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Age Policy
  • Guidelines
  • Tags
  • All Questions
Google Play Apple Store
Topics (22) All
  • Girl's BehaviorGirl's Behavior
  • Guy's BehaviorGuy's Behavior
  • FlirtingFlirting
  • DatingDating
  • RelationshipsRelationships
  • Fashion & BeautyFashion & Beauty
  • Health & FitnessHealth & Fitness
  • Marriage & WeddingsMarriage & Weddings
  • Shopping & GiftsShopping & Gifts
  • Technology & InternetTechnology & Internet
  • Break Up & DivorceBreak Up & Divorce
  • Education & CareerEducation & Career
  • Entertainment & ArtsEntertainment & Arts
  • Family & FriendsFamily & Friends
  • Food & BeverageFood & Beverage
  • Hobbies & LeisureHobbies & Leisure
  • OtherOther
  • Religion & SpiritualityReligion & Spirituality
  • Society & PoliticsSociety & Politics
  • SportsSports
  • Travel Travel
  • Trending & NewsTrending & News
Discover
Community of trusted and anonymous friends where girls and guys help each other.
A good descriptive title will get more attention. Min 15, Max 150 characters.
Add Details Detail the problem, add images or a poll, or become anonymous.
Get title support
Let AI help you write the title.
0 / 150
Log In / Sign Up
Topics(22)
All
  • Girl's Behavior Girl's Behavior
  • Guy's Behavior Guy's Behavior
  • Flirting Flirting
  • Dating Dating
  • Relationships Relationships
  • Fashion & Beauty Fashion & Beauty
  • Health & Fitness Health & Fitness
  • Marriage & Weddings Marriage & Weddings
  • Shopping & Gifts Shopping & Gifts
  • Technology & Internet Technology & Internet
  • Break Up & Divorce Break Up & Divorce
  • Education & Career Education & Career
  • Entertainment & Arts Entertainment & Arts
  • Family & Friends Family & Friends
  • Food & Beverage Food & Beverage
  • Hobbies & Leisure Hobbies & Leisure
  • Other Other
  • Religion & Spirituality Religion & Spirituality
  • Society & Politics Society & Politics
  • Sports Sports
  • Travel Travel
  • Trending & News Trending & News
Health & Fitness Marriage & Weddings Shopping & Gifts Technology & Internet Break Up & Divorce +16
Family & Friends

The Stigma Of Having No Maternal Instinct (Page 2)

Hannah591
Hannah591 Follow
Guru Age: 31
Follow
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
60
The Stigma Of Having No Maternal Instinct
Post Opinion
Like
Share
Follow
6 likes
What is your opinion?
What is your opinion?
Add Opinion
Ask to an AI Persona
All
Love Doctor Brad
Love Doctor Brad
Welcome to the heart of understanding and transformation. I am your guide on this journey to...
Travel Buddy
Travel Buddy
I'm your go-to travel companion, passionate about exploring new destinations and experiencing...
Laura
Laura
Have questions about GirlsAskGuys? I'm here to help!
Fashionista Amy
Fashionista Amy
I'm here to inspire and guide you with a touch of latest trends or advice on personal style.💅👒
Cinematic Lily
Cinematic Lily
With my rich background and passion for the arts, I share insights on films, TV shows, and...
Gamer Bella
Gamer Bella
With my passion and experience in hobbies and leisure activities, I'm here to offer personalized...
Athletic Chloe
Athletic Chloe
Whether you need tips on improving your game, insights on fitness and nutrition, or just want to...
James The Foodie
James The Foodie
From savoring Italian classics to discovering the bold flavors of Japanese cuisine, I explore...
Advisor Smith
Advisor Smith
With years of experience guiding individuals in their education and career paths, I'm here to...

What Girls & Guys Said

26

Opinion

18

Opinion

Show Popular Opinions(20)
  • Nathalyy
    Nathalyy Follow
    Xper 5 Age: 31
    +1 y

    Only read like half of it, honestly. I love kids, don't have any yet but I completely understand what you mean since my sister has no maternity instinct whatsoever. It's understandable because we do go through all this stages and just the thought I like damn, we all know they will grow up and not all of us like that idea but I'd want to see a little mini mi, lol I'm going out of topic and I don't know what was your point nor my point but do and keep what makes you happy! :)

    0
    1 Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      That's okay, when I wrote it, I thought no-one would read it, haha. Thanks, you too!

      Reply
  • PiuBelloAmante
    PiuBelloAmante Follow
    Yoda Age: 30
    +1 y

    beautifully written and well thought. I really enjoyed this and completely agree

    2
    2 Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      Thankyou! :)

      Reply
    • PiuBelloAmante
      PiuBelloAmante
      +1 y

      yeah not everyone has the instinct to become a great parent, and i think now its something people should have a choice over, screw societies pressure to procreate!

      Reply
  • The_Eternal_Emperor
    The_Eternal_Emperor Follow
    Xper 6 Age: 30
    +1 y

    While I agree that is tasteless for society to constantly insult and be presumptuous to women who refuse to have kids, it will never be socially accepted to not want children. That's the way society has always been, and it will continue this way until the Apocalypse.

    Great article, I enjoyed reading it.

    1
    1 Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      Thankyou.

      Reply
  • Anonymous
    Anonymous
    (36-45)
    +1 y

    I have a strong maternal instinct, but life has not been kind to me, so I have changed my mind about wanting to have children. Between several injuries, I just would not feel safe carrying a child, and do not believe I would be able to provide well caring for that child. In a way, it makes me sad, but I know it's for the best.

    0
    2 Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      It's good of you to have made that decision. However, others may see your decision ridiculous and encourage you to still have children which I feel isn't right.

      Reply
    • Anonymous
      Opinion Owner
      +1 y

      Nobody knows someone else's circumstances, what they've been through, or what's best for them. I feel like we're on the same page. Good for you, no matter what your choice, as long as it's right for you.

      Reply
  • Mesonfielde
    Mesonfielde Follow
    Master Age: 34
    +1 y

    Conceptually speaking, it is still somewhat disappointing that some people just don't feel like they are important enough that they ought to preserve a part of themselves via passing down their genetics.

    0
    1 Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      I often think about the genetics part, it would be nice to see what my child would look like (though I assume it'd look a lot like me as I did when I was younger. But I have numerous health conditions which I wouldn't want to pass on tbh.

      Reply
  • Anonymous
    Anonymous
    (45 Plus)
    +1 y

    I think the problem is that people that don't want kids constantly go on rants, about how people that do want kids are selfish for bringing a child into this world. Which is sorta what you ended up doing. You may have not meant to but basically told everyone that wants a family they are the enemy of the earth. This can be offensive to a lot of people.

    The only time I have ever witnessed anyone calling someone selfish for not wanting children, is after that person went on a rant about how having children is selfish. It may have more to do with how defensive you are acting, that is offending others, than them having a problem with your not wanting kids.

    0
    4 Reply
    • AvaMarina
      AvaMarina
      +1 y

      That's a problem sometimes, but I think you'd be surprised how often it only takes a simple statement ("I don't think kids are for me.") to prompt all the condescension and lecturing. I've never been in an actual argument about my lack of desire for children, never raised my voice about it or anything, so anyone who wasn't involved in the conversation would have no idea it happened. One of my friends deals with it too, but she's also quiet about it, so I wouldn't have even known if she didn't tell me.

      Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      That's not what I was getting across at all. I support anyone who has children, though not everyone SHOULD have children for a variety of reasons. This isn't a rant, it's more to get the message to people that it's rude to insult/alienate someone over their choice to not have children. I would expect to be insulted if I insulted someone for the opposite of my decision but I've never called anyone selfish for having children. Most people who have commented so far have said only positive things, I don't believe anyone could get offended by this take.

      Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      @AvaMarina is on the right lines. We shouldn't have to be quiet about our decision to avoid lectures (which I get all the time from my friends). It's frustrating having someone dictate your life and your decisions when you've been so confident in your decision since you were little.

      Reply
    • Anonymous
      Opinion Owner
      +1 y

      I agree you shouldn't have to pretend. If however you start talking about how you don't understand bringing a child into this world, you start to sound a lot like the people that are looking down on people that want kids. There are many such people. So without meaning to you may cause people to get defensive. Maybe that doesn't apply to you, but it is something you may want to be mindful of.

      Reply
  • ButtHearth
    ButtHearth Follow
    Xper 5 Age: 37
    +1 y

    I have one sister with no maternal instinct, and another one with a very strong maternal instinct. Guess which one I like better? XD

    3
    0 Reply
  • gypsybee
    gypsybee Follow
    Yoda Age: 41
    +1 y

    What a great post!!! Well as long as those who have no maternal instinct don't have children all is well.

    1
    0 Reply
  • Anonymous
    Anonymous
    (25-29)
    +1 y

    I guess its a product of humans becoming more and more self centered. And its also the reason why socially developed countries like japan and most of Europe will suffer from a huge population decline unless they go for mass immigration in the future.

    0
    5 Reply
    • Aquenne
      Aquenne
      +1 y

      You mean benefit from a huge population decline don't you?

      Reply
    • been_waiting
      been_waiting
      +1 y

      A decrease in population size isn't detrimental to society in todays world.

      Reply
    • Anonymous
      Opinion Owner
      +1 y

      Our economic growth and our ability to maintain it is based on that we can keep up with the manpower needed. Its one of the reasons that rome fell and its also why Europe and japan are taking in so many immigrants. Because in our cultures less children are made so we need to get them from other people.

      Reply
    • springocelot
      springocelot
      +1 y

      You have a point, but it's still people's choice whether they want children or not. The only problem with mass immigration to fill that void, especially with mass immigration in Europe , is that most of them are not productive citizens and don't want to integrate into the existing culture.

      Reply
    • Anonymous
      Opinion Owner
      +1 y

      I'm not saying that mass immigration is a good substitute. But it is the only avalible solution when The current society doesn't do it themselves. Thats also why countries dont want the immigrants to get culturaly integrated as their children then wouldn't have the will to make 5 kids.

      Reply
  • Freakingthefout
    Freakingthefout Follow
    Xper 5 Age: 32
    +1 y

    Tl;dr

    No one needs to have kids if they don't want them. People pushing others to have kids are making a disastrous choice and encouraging people towards a huge responsibility that they don't want.

    1
    0 Reply
  • MaskedSanity
    MaskedSanity Follow
    Yoda Age: 37
    +1 y

    Superb article. I thoroughly enjoyed it, thank you.

    2
    1 Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      Thankyou! :) I'm glad you did!

      Reply
  • Anonymous
    Anonymous
    (30-35)
    +1 y

    I don't need an excuse as to why I do not want children. I just do not. I'm not focused on my career. I know plenty of mothers who have good careers. Their lives have nothing to do with the reason why I do not want kids

    2
    0 Reply
  • BiffWebster
    BiffWebster Follow
    Xper 7 Age: 34
    +1 y

    well studies have been done, even with a guy called Robert Spalosky that have come to the conclusion that women do have (more so than men) in most cases a befriend and tend reaction,

    0
    0 Reply
  • Anonymous
    Anonymous
    (45 Plus)
    +1 y

    as a lesbian in her late thirties this is a touchy subject for me. I'm struggling with a lot of money I just don't know what to think. Sometimes I wonder if God just wants me to be alone. But other times I just want to have a family and be happy.

    0
    2 Reply
    • singlebee
      singlebee
      +1 y

      oh dont worry... there will be a girl for you...

      Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      You will find someone and you can adopt or even get a dog. Things will work out.

      Reply
  • Findesemana
    Findesemana Follow
    Xper 6 Age: 44
    +1 y

    i agree totally. do whatever, provided it doesn't hurt others.

    2
    0 Reply
  • been_waiting
    been_waiting Follow
    Yoda Age: 29
    +1 y

    Good Take. Do you, fuck what others say.

    1
    1 Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      Thankyou.

      Reply
  • kep79
    kep79 Follow
    Xper 7 Age: 46
    +1 y

    what would you do if contraceptives had not been invented?

    2
    5 Reply
    • Starfishlover
      Starfishlover
      +1 y

      I would probably rip out my uterus

      Reply
    • cphiecekslee
      cphiecekslee
      +1 y

      Definitely get my tubes tied, unless you're counting that. Otherwise, I would just eat quit tons of vitamin c every time I was supposed to get my period just in case.

      Reply
    • kep79
      kep79
      +1 y

      that's not what nature wants for you...

      Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      I would most likely become celibate.

      Reply
    • kep79
      kep79
      +1 y

      that's what i fear the most

      Reply
  • Anonymous
    Anonymous
    (45 Plus)
    +1 y

    I seem to date women with none even if they end up having them or not. I don't see it being too much of a stigma these days though.

    1
    2 Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      As a woman who doesn't want children, there is definitely a stigma. I often receive lectures about my decision which women who do want children don't get. As I stated, that one blogger received numerous insults about her decision. People assume you're selfish/weird/incapable/don't want the responsibility or they give you this sad look or worse, they say "you'll change your mind. Kids are lovely".

      Reply
    • Anonymous
      Opinion Owner
      +1 y

      Online I think is different and the US versus the UK is a little different as well.

      Reply
  • kamper
    kamper Follow
    Xper 4 Age: 50
    +1 y

    I feel sorry for you. You will never know the joys that will melt your heart and make you cry with joy, the pride of seeing your children achieving their own goals and dreams, and yes, sometimes the pains as well... whether they be physical or emotional.

    0
    7 Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      No need to feel sorry for me. You've obviously not read my take, otherwise you'd realise that the whole take is about people saying patronizing comments like you just have, so maybe you should comment when you have read it or maybe never comment again.

      Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      I've cried with joy before, I don't need a dribbling, selfish baby to do it and I very much doubt it could ever do that because I'd be so depressed with one. I prefer the pride of exploring the world or doing something amazing with my life.

      Reply
    • UnknownXYZ
      UnknownXYZ
      +1 y

      What's with all the hostility? "... saying patronizing comments like you just have?" Oh really? There was nothing patronizing about what he just said. He just really feels you will be missing out. There was nothing bad about what he said.

      Reply
    • lovely_girl
      lovely_girl
      +1 y

      @UnknownXYZ Uh no he literally told her, "I feel sorry for you. You will never know the joys that will melt your heart..." She's saying yeah you're right, If I have children that's exactly what will happen because she sees no happiness in that. The joys she will know and melt her heart are the ones in the things that she wants and knows she will be able to achieve.

      Reply
    • UnknownXYZ
      UnknownXYZ
      +1 y

      www.court-records.net/.../bratworth-shrug(e).gif

      @lovely_girl Hence, he wasn't patronizing. If she sees no happiness in having children then that's fine also.

      Reply
    • lovely_girl
      lovely_girl
      +1 y

      @UnknownXYZ haha forget the patronizing subject. I think it just really irks a person when they get pity when there is no need for it anyways. She doesn't want children ---> there's no joy in that for her ---> therefore there's no need to feel sorry.

      Reply
    • UnknownXYZ
      UnknownXYZ
      +1 y

      www.court-records.net/.../bratworth-aha(d).gif

      @lovely_girl I would but that was what I am focusing on.

      Reply
  • Victoria_xoxo
    Victoria_xoxo Follow
    Xper 6 Age: 34
    +1 y

    I love this article. I feel the same

    1
    1 Reply
    • Hannah591
      Hannah591
      +1 y

      Thankyou!

      Reply
  • Show More (4)
Click "Show More" for your mentions
Home > Family & Friends > myTakes > The Stigma Of Having No Maternal Instinct
Add your reply For "{0}"
Most Helpful Opinion(mho) Rate.
Learn more

We're glad to see you liked this post.

You can also add your opinion below!

Related myTakes

On Antinatalism 6 answered
The downplay of motherhood- and how it is bound to hurt women 8 answered
More than Motherhood 9 answered
The Maternal Jealousy part one 6 answered
7 Myths About Infertility 2 answered
Popular Questions
  • Girls, What are the Ways for Men to Say They Care About You?
  • My boyfriend follows random girls on Instagram, should I be worried?
  • Girls what does the 😌 emoji mean?
  • How do I ask for a girl's Instagram?
  • "How Do You Feel About Me?" Best Answers to This Situation!
  • Do guys really like girls with thick thighs?
  • Girls, What Makes a Man Fall Deeply in Love With a Woman?
  • What does the date under "Hey there I am using Whatsapp" Status mean?
  • What's a good comeback when someone jokingly calls you old?
  • When a girls says "I'll let you know" what does it mean?
Recent Questions
  • Does this outfit look cute and what vibe does it give off?
  • Do you believe an ugly personality destroys a pretty face?
  • Why dont people want to be healthy and lose weight?
  • Why do I feel a dislike whenever I hear Tucker Carlson speak?
  • How many times have you truly loved someone and been loved back?
  • What does Lot choosing the better land over Abraham really teach us?
  • Is my extrapolation from the Harvard longevity study to gratitude valid?
  • Anybody going anyplace interesting this summer?
  • Are many Christians today failing to address spiritual desolation?
  • Why do highly articulate, top‑tier communicators keep being drawn to me?
  • Help
  • Contact
  • Terms Of Use
  • Guidelines
  • Privacy Policy
  • Age Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Featured Questions
  • Topics
Popular Topics
Dating Education & Career Entertainment & Arts Flirting Food & Beverage Girl's Behavior Guy's Behavior Health & Fitness Relationships Technology & Internet
Girls Ask Guys
©2026 GirlsAskGuys ™
Apple Store Google Play
Join with {0}
Loading...
Loading...
The question is being reviewed...
Compliance with site rules is being checked...
Final touches are being made, it's almost ready ✨