Do most guys find the fake look attractive or unattractive?

Question

Is a glammed up fake looking girl more attractive or a average looking non fake woman better?
It doesn't have to be the girls in the two pictures you're voting for they're just a idea.. basically would you rather a girl fake boobs fake hair loads of make up or natural everything but not unattractive.

fabulouspancakes · Accepted Answer

Disclaimer, I'm a girl, but this is from my observations. Most men prefer a look that takes a lot of effort (almost as much as the first girl) but more toned-down and natural LOOKING. Men seem to like someone who is down-to-earth and doesn't seem high-maintenance, but who spends a lot of time working out, maintaining her appearance, and even getting subtle plastic surgery, in addition to being genetically blessed. Jennifer Aniston would be an example. She works out, she tans, her hair is meticulously highlighted, she's wearing makeup, and she has proportional breast implants. Yet she reads "natural" and "girl-next-door" to most guys.
This is all slightly annoying to girls since guys don't notice the effort we put in, and if they do, they say it's "too much." But that's just how it is. And by the way the first girl might look too fake to be IDEAL to most guys, but I can guarantee she gets more attention than the second.
But of course, feel free to tell me if I'm wrong since I don't like it when men tell women what they "actually" want.

Do most guys find the fake look attractive or unattractive?

taleets · Accepted Answer

in real life guys are going to go for the first type of girl. although it depends on the type of guy. if we are talking about a nerdy book worm type of guy he might choose the second girl. say you are talking about rich billionaire in dubai, the likelihood is that he will choose the first. notice how no rich guys are dating unattractive girls ( for the most part). there is a reason that girls use makeup, fake boobs etc, it's to be more attractive! i am approached more often when i am glammed up ( pics on my last question) and that goes against the guys who say natural. in my area the second girl is well below average. i kinda live in a snobby plastic area so i can't say it would be the same somewhere else. guys are very visual creatures so they want whichever girl looks the best. i would say a majority of the guys who chose the second girl said that because they are trying to make her feel better and also because they wouldn't have the confidence to approach the first girl in reality.

Goodwifie · Accepted Answer

A guy could go for fake easy because she does look sexy.
Just be prepared for the fact that she'll never have any money because she will always be paying for something to get done.
Her hair would cost around $200 a month alone.
She also has hair extensions.
Breast implants at least $10,000 they need to be replaced every 10 years
Eyelash extensions.
Wanting the latest fashion
I guess by the time you take all that away from her she could be pretty ordinary looking.

Wonderer89 · Accepted Answer

I think the poll/photos kind of bias it to give a skewed result when there is a fair bit of ground in between the two.
Average girl putting in some effort I imagine would be the front runner. So many guys say they don't like make up but when two photos are put in front of them of over the top and the bare minimum they nearly always say the "natural" beauty.

I just think effort doesn't have to equal fake 😊

Bananaman177 · Accepted Answer

In my opinion, MOST guys prefer a more human-looking girl, but I have to admit that there is a VERY VOCAL minority of guys who really can't get off to anything but the most degenerate, fake, plastic sluts.

And I really feel bad that so many girls hear those guys talk (Because they never shut up about it.) and assume that all guys must feel the same.

Most guys aren't very vocal about what they like, because it's annoying and rude to go on and on about it, and it can be hurtful to people who might not measure up to your particular standards. But the guys who like fake plastic sluts don't think about that and wouldn't care if they did.

So naturally, those guys get all the girls and all girls try to make themselves look desirable to those guys, and meanwhile, all the nice guys feel completely invisible to girls, so what do they do? They withdraw even further.

And then women say,
s2.quickmeme.com/.../...e92b58c4341a0615ff45e4.jpg

nanook12 · Accepted Answer

Most guys are going to say that they do not like fake girls; however, as soon as that fake looking girl makes a duck face at him with her roller paint on lipstick and bats her long plastic eye lashes, then logic, reason, and standards give way to boners and lust. It's a double standard just like many others.

Anonymous · Answer

Lol at women thinking any girl who takes care of herself, eats right, and doesn't look like a slob must be fake. It the same kind of insecure attitude where any girl with great tits, or ass must have implants.

Females. Life on easy mode but still complaining about the small stuff you have to do to look good.

cf.girlsaskguys.com/.../...f-ac52-fc18e92519fb.gif

Peopleschamp · Answer

physically the glammed ones are attractive because that's the whole purpose of them glamming themselves up, the end result is they look more attractive. But often I notice the personalities is something they lack because of how over confident they get. So I guess overall I prefer the"average" looking woman

lacorine197 · Answer

I'm ready to get downvoted, but I like how girls here SWEAR they know what EVERY guy likes, I'm sorry, but I pick those things apart, I'm not attracted to girls with makeup, especially excessive makeup, Heck I am very uncomfortable with plastic surgery girls, and no I wouldn't take one in a heartbeat. It would be double standards to say that all girls like is a muscular white guy, with chiseled abs, a beard, blue eyes, can sing, can dance, can do everything, call everyone who doesn't have what he can do a loser and talks shit about anyone he sees. Also, treats the girl like shit. But okay keep assuming all guys like this. Keep thinking all those white knights know exactly what others are thinking. Can't wait to hear the double standards and downvotes I get.

TripleAce · Answer

Well that first girl is just more attractive whether she fakes up or not... so not sure if I can give an accurate opinion based on those two pictures...
Should of used an attractive non fake girl as the second chick though... if that is the case...

The non fake attractive chick... however you slice it, attraction is important

Elarra · Answer

What makes the woman in the first photo fake? Looks more like she just takes better care of herself than the girl in the second picture...

TheCunningLinguist · Answer

I believe in a woman that can do both Though I find the tone of your question To be very judgmental And it is obvious the answer that you're looking for. Some women just feel better Made up. Oftentimes I find those girls to be the most vulnerable and lacking in Self confidence. My advice Is for women to be supporting of each other and stop tearing each other down for your Differences. Each flower in the garden is beautiful, It just takes a skilled Gardener to see it.

Anonymous · Answer

I like the real look by far more than the fake one. With that said, I've never been attracted to girls with a pointy chin like that. So, I'm not attracted to either girl that you gave as an option but since the question is real or fake... I'll go with real

bgowd · Answer

I'd go for the average girl but the girl in this picture is not really average. she's fat and doesn't know how to do make-up. Her forehead looks brown but her cheeks are pink..😂

TheGoodGuy1337 · Answer

Depends on what you consider average, if we're talking by the pics, i'd go for fake

Anonymous · Answer

This question is a great example of why the particular girls in question matter. Generally if you say "real or fake" guys would pick real. But given those two girls, I'd say the first one wins hands down. WAY hotter than the second girl.

BBoy201 · Answer

"Fake glammed up girl" is such a tun off, most times I can't even give them an iota of attention. For me, very few of them are able to make the third leg stand, and when it does, it's only to disrespect them hah.

Anonymous · Answer

I think the fake can look better.
But the fake look costs her lots of money and time and realistically thats going to effect a relationship.
Not an issue if your rich but is an issue for most of us ie the are you ready yet where going to be late scenario or you being broke.

natrickk · Answer

natural look all the way. women are already crazy beautiful just the way they are.
also, how we present ourselves often reflects who we are. many girls with a fake look aren't just fake on the outside...

Prof_Don · Answer

Most guys prefer the more attractive girl, "fake" or not. Men care more about "good-looking" than "fake". :-P

normalice · Answer

you can't really 'fake' a shape. You can get surgically enhanced boobs or whatever, but it's not like they are detachable or something - they are just as much there as natural boobs.

robot9001 · Answer

Id say most want average, or rather not attractive real or not. But personally, I'm all for fake!

Anonymous · Answer

I can't stand the fake look. I'll take this any day...

HonestGirlAlways · Answer

They all say they prefer a natural looking woman but still go for the glammed up ones (which is fine by the way, they're not worse than anyone for wanting to look better).

CarpX · Answer

The choice of pics biases the results a bit. In general, I definitely prefer a more natural look to glammed up fake.

Pomegranate139 · Answer

Of course they want the fake girl. That look wouldn't be popular in the first place if it wasn't desired.

Do most guys find the fake look attractive or unattractive?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Do most guys find the fake look attractive or unattractive?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

We're glad to see you liked this post.