Girls, what is more attractive in a man: The strong, silent type - or - the loud boisterous type?

[Xzero77]

Assume both are physically similar (imagine identical twins if necessary), confident, educated, and have similar incomes. Both also have interests in various outdoor activities, and social events, with a similar number of friends. Which is more attractive? Strong and silent, or Boisterous.

Updates

+1 y

Thank you for your answers.

[Freetobe007]

The loud, boisterous type can still be strong. I'd prefer something in between. Too silent would be boring for me and I don't think they could bring the energy and excitement I thrive off of when I'm hanging out or somewhere really fun like at an amusement park or something. I don't want someone who is too loud all of the time because that might just annoy me. But I like loud people.

[madmisskelly]

Im a talkative, enthusiastic, energetic person, and I need someone who is just as amped as I am.

I dated someone who was much more introverted than me, and he made me feel like I was too hyper for him. So I was the one cracking all the jokes, being silly and whatnot, and he wasnt.

[tazitori]

silent type. boisterous is OK at times if your at a party I guess but its not attractive. silent guys (I think) tend to be more laid back and all and boisterous comes off as erogant

[PHLove]

Strong and silent, I feel like those guys are more down to earth and the ones who always need to be the center of attention can be exhausting

[aqua000]

ouuu laaa.. I like this question...I would have to say the STRONG SILENT TYPE. because it just make them more so interesting/ interestED!

[Anonymous]

I don't like loud people, they are some times annoying.

I'm with someone who is the quiet, smart (geeky/nerdy I guess) type.

[Chrissy1986]

strong and silent no dobt about it

[Nicefuture]

Silent and strong,i hate loud people

[bel42]

the strong silent type.

[Anonymous]

The strong and silent. I love mysterious guys :D

[Anonymous]

silent.