Ben & Jerry's vs. Haagen-Dazs: Which is better & why?

Question

Out of these 2 brands which 1) do you prefer and why? 2) believe is the superior product objectively? 3) What is your favourite flavour? detailed answers are appreciated

BaileyisDarcy · Accepted Answer

Never even heard of the first. And the second is 5 times the price of ANY other icecream I've ever seen and a third of the size.

Not only is it horrifyingly expensive and lacking in size, its incredibly rich, too sweet, too thick, too creamy. Its horrible.

I think Ill stick with my Coles homebrand 2 dollar 2 litre bucket.

CHARismatic110 · Accepted Answer

I only eat either of them if I'm treating myself because they're both ridiculously expensive for ice cream. And if I want something caramel flavored, then I go Häagen-Dazs. I only do Ben and Jerry's if there's a specific kind I want to try. But lately I've been eating Talenti.

Fitness-Fanatic · Accepted Answer

Häagen-Dazs is a much better quality ice -cream, Ben & Jerry's ice-cream leaves an awful coating in the mouth

mooky06 · Accepted Answer

I've never had those ones before. I always buy

OlderAndWiser · Accepted Answer

I have not eaten ice cream in several years and I'm not sure that I have ever eaten Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream. My experience with premium brands like these is that the quality may be slightly better than good mid-priced brands, but the difference does not justify the price differential.

MrOracle · Accepted Answer

B&J started going on liberal crusades 20 years ago and I stopped buying their products. Not sure why people think they should inject their personal politics into their food brand, but, eh, their loss. And I'm not sure I've ever had Haagen-Dazs.

madhatters4 · Answer

definitely prefer haagen daz. i think it just generally tastes superior. more rich, more flavor and at least feels more natural to me

i love pretty much anything haagen daz makes but especially like their cookie dough, rocky road and mango ice creams

Topaz171 · Answer

I only had Ben and Jerrys and I love it! My favorite flavor is the strawberry cheesecake because of the frozen strawberry bits with the graham cracker swirls😛

Warmapplecrumble · Answer

Häagen Dazs, I never tried Ben and Jerries don't like the flavours.

I have only eaten commercial icecream 5 times in my life.

I make my own ice cream with my own flavours :-) ♥ I dislike shop icecreams

PoliceLivesMatter · Answer

I've never had either 😱😱😱.  I've been wanting to try them out though

Cosytoasty · Answer

I only really have ice cream from Amorino these days, but Haagen Dazs out of those two.

B&J I find not creamy at all, more like frozen milk

Fav flavour is either strawberries and cream OR mint and chocolate.

TheLuckyPizzaDog · Answer

No real flavor preference for either... Haagen dazs goes on sale more than b&j's, so i get that. The limoncello gelato i do like though, as well as the coconut pineapple.

BrittBratt2416 · Answer

Ice cream is ice cream, so i don't care which one it is.. as long as it has caramel or chocolate chip cookie then I'll eat it.

Phoenix98 · Answer

Haagen-Dazs is more of a elite ice cream you know like the gourmet of the ice creams kind of. So I think it's probably the better one

dragonfly6516 · Answer

Haagan-Dazs tastes better to me. Richer and more creamy.  But, they don't have the array of flavors that I prefer like Ben & Jerry's.

witherwing · Answer

They don't sell Häagen-Dazs in Finland and Ben & Jerry's is a bit too heavy for me. I prefer Finnish products made from Finnish milk.

MarkRet · Answer

I don't eat either one of them them that much, but I guess I'll go with Ben & Jerry's. I like their flip sales approach.

bondobilly · Answer

I prefer Ben and jerry's, but I can't stand their political stance.

Timodeum · Answer

Häagen-Dazs. Unlike Ben&Jerrys, it actually tastes like ice cream, not like frozen vomit.

Mishthefish · Answer

We don't have these brands in South Africa 😔 But both of them look yummy !

strangytie · Answer

I've never tried Ben and jerry's :( I really want to.

Alistayr · Answer

I will never understand how anyone can enjoy ice cream with hard objects in it. It should be ice cream with no extra bits.

Redstang88 · Answer

Both are way overpriced condsidering they're really not all that special. Don't think i've has either in a long time, though from what I remember I'd give Ben & Jerry's the edge.

anewgirl · Answer

I haven't had ice cream in years, but Ben and Jerry's cookie dough = perfection.

ThunderBasketball · Answer

I'm not allowed to eat ice cream. But since I have a cold today, I might just indulge.

Littlett25 · Answer

I've only had Ben & Jerry's once and I haven't heard of the other brand.

Phyllis91 · Answer

Neither. Too expensive for what little you get. I think only rich people eat them.

RedThread · Answer

I usually fuck with Häagen-Dazs because I love all their caramel flavors like the one you linked.

Anonymous · Answer

BJ's because they've so many flavours, the frozen yoghurt is bling aswell  But HaagenDazs pralines and cream is a fucking dream, love it

Walrus_au · Answer

Neither, it's never worth paying that much for a brand name.

Dme500 · Answer

ain't had either. We eat blue bell at my house. Cookies and cream for life!!

Iron_Man · Answer

Ben & Jerry's is the best but Haagen-Dazs chocolate chocolate chip beats them all

legalboxers · Answer

not a fan of either tbh. Haagen is too pricey. never tried ben and jerry

DonkeyRick69 · Answer

Both are too expensive

assley · Answer

Never had these brands.

zagor · Answer

Ben & Jerry's all the way. Haagen-Daz is putrid.

Wonderer89 · Answer

Häagen Dazs!

ThisDudeHere · Answer

Never heard of either.

LittleSally · Answer

Never heard or seen either of those.

ADFSDF1996 · Answer

I've only tasted Häagen dazs

Blonde401 · Answer

Hagen Dazs!

Prof_Don · Answer

Ben & Jerry's is the better choice here!

savalisk · Answer

Ben n Jerry's when I just can't even...

Browneye57 · Answer

Sorry, I'm a Dreyer's fan. :) Rocky Road!

WeirdoWerdo · Answer

Haven't eaten any of them...

CT_CD · Answer

never tried Haagen-Dazs

Hispanic-Cool-Guy · Answer

Have no idea.

Anonymous · Answer

neither

Joker_ · Answer

ben's

Ben & Jerry's vs. Haagen-Dazs: Which is better & why?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Which Ben and Jerry’s flavor would you prefer?

Ben & Jerry's vs. Haagen-Dazs: Which is better & why?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Which Ben and Jerry’s flavor would you prefer?

We're glad to see you liked this post.