Guys, Cute gesture?

I have a crush on this guy who rejected me a year ago. Still acted interested. I went in and wished him a happy birthday and asked if he still had his present I gave him last year (card). If I could get it back, he asked why? I said just amuse me. When I saw him he said he was busy (again) and didn't look for it. Been weeks. We barely talk because I suck.

The question; if a guy was interested would he actually get it? Would he try to play it cool and make it seem like it's not a priority? What would you do? Guy acts confident, well known, attractive talkative. But I know he's actually insecure and shy. (friend insider; unavailable now)

Guys, Cute gesture?
Post Opinion