How much flubber is too much flubber?

[Anonymous]

I'm 5'8'' and weigh about 150 pounds (68kg) would you consider this fat or unattractive?

according to the BMI calculator I'm fine, and I know for a fact I am three times as fit and more healthy than most of my friends, I love excercise, I go hiking everyday...

Im just not a Waif, how much of a problem would this be to most guys? does a girl I have to be super svelt and skinny to be really attractive?

[christian2724]

You sound perfect. Remember, you're tall. All that matters is you're height and weight proportional. Based on pics I'm looking at (I actually found a site that shows comparable girls) You're f***ing hot. Like, why are you even questioning yourself? If any guy doesn't like you, he isn't committed to pussy.

[cjwright79]

How much is too much? If you keel over and die of a heart attack, it was too much, you know? Until then there is still hope of a recovery, unless I'm missing something.

[peace-love-couture]

If it's flubber, lose weight and tone up.

If you're as active as you say you are, then it should be muscle(lean) rather than fat and you're probably fine then.

And I think girls should stop thinking extreme as a way to justify their weight.

[mysteryyy]

absolutely right !

[mysteryyy]

Well I'm the same height as you 5'8 and 103 lbs...And I consider myself very healthy and in shape. I have trained many sports and worked as a professional dancer. So if you ask me, it's flubber. For me it's not good but I see some guys may like it.

[Asker]

Whoa I don't know whether to be impressed or worried for you, I have trouble believing you are healthy if you are really 45 kg (103 pounds) and 5'8" that's a bmi of 15.2 ...

[mysteryyy]

I'm actually 47kg/103lbs (check it) It's partly due to my body structure- thin bones and small frame, for some girls it may be really unhealthy to have my weight.

And yeah I'm perfectly healthy, full of energy, I have trained ballet and gymnastics for years, I doubt a girl with your weight can go through the exercises that I have gone.

[peace-love-couture]

If you got to her pictures, you'll see she doesn't look like sticks and bones. My friend Alee is 5'7 and 100 lbs. She has her period, eats constantly, doesn't work out, takes vitamins, her mom always takes her to the doctor and they say the same thing continuously, that's just how she is. It isn't for you to play doctor

[Asker]

was that supposed to be some kind of backhanded insult? because I wasn't trying to put you down, I know that some peoples gut reaction might be to yell at you "eat something bitch" but I was just genuinely surprised because I have been that skinny and it wasn't healthy for me, I didn't mensurate and you could see my ribs through my skin.

[Asker]

i know people who have been admitted into eating disorder clinics who are fatter than you. so I don't think my comment was out of line.

[Asker]

and for the record I have looked at your pics and you do look too skinny.

[peace-love-couture]

Why is someone who is asking about being too big making fun of another persons weight? pot calling the kettle black?

[mysteryyy]

Do not worry for me. I feel perfectly fine, work out every day, eat constantly, no diets, no eating disorders. I guess it's not only about how much you eat, it's about genetics, metabolism, bone structure. If you have slow metabolism and larger bones then it will be unhealthy for you to weigh 103 pounds. Nobody asks you to do so, your weight is healthy, some men like chubby, all I say it's not perfect, you could lose at least 10 pounds to feel better.

[Blobb]

too skinny is weird and unattractive. Toned is excellent though. Just don't get the "somalian kid posing for a charity photo" look and you'll be fine.

[Anonymous]

Consult Robin Williams, he has quite a good understanding of flubber.

[Shaun]

You have nothing to worry about.

[Anonymous]

you could lose a few lbs, but no, you'renot fat

[SnackG]

Sounds good to me.