#FeelFreeToList #PermissionToPropose
Do you personally feel the parents should be asked for their blessing before proposing/proposed to?
#FeelFreeToList #PermissionToPropose
I've heard about this practice, but it's something that like no one in my family does on my father's side or mother's side. We just don't really care. Most of the time, people make it a surprise and someone will be wearing a ring at a party or something which will let people know.
In my case, I don't care to get the parents of my love interest's permission, mainly because, our love is between the two of us, and the decision of marriage will affect the two of us more than her parents. I hope that I'm on good terms with her family though. I would rather it be that our marriage isn't frowned upon. Though my family would always accept in whomever I marry with open arms. We're a family with a lot of love and romantic views.
Wow this was a great answer. And i laughed how you said “we just really dont care” 🤣
Same here man
Getting approval is traditional, old and outdated. You are choosing the person you spend your life with and who makes you happiest. Not your parents. Good parents will support your decision regardless of their opinion... unless of course your relationship jeopardizes your life and health. Then I understand why parents may want to intervene. That being said, if you know your parents are understanding and support you, it's nice to let them know what's going on.
Good points
Opinion
43Opinion
I too never had a relationship with my father and my mother has never been supportive of my decisions especially when it comes to personal relationships. Even if my S. O could track them down and ask, I am sure he wouldn't get a yes. More likely a "why are you bothering me?".
But I can understand why people do it. It is a sign of respect and it also shows that you want to be involved in your partner's life. However, I believe it is an outdated tradition as far as western culture goes. I think for the most part people would do what they wanted to regardless of the answer anyways, so it is kind of a waste of time.
Dang that would hurt if he respectfully asked and they responded that he was a bother
It was very important to me that my husband ask my dad for his blessing before proposing. Of course, I also have a healthy relationship with my father and he's always been very supportive and involved in my life. I imagine I'd feel differently about the subject if my relationship with my father were different.
From what I understand, my husband invited both my parents over to dinner one night and cooked them steak and mushroom risotto, showed them the ring, and said this was happening and it'd be great if they'd get on board lol
Even with a healthy relationship, i still didn't see the big deal but it sounds romantic what your guy did
Since when you turn 18, your decisions in life are going to be yours. Asking for advice from people who lived your years before you is generally a good idea, but the ultimate choice is yours.
Own up to your fuck ups if you happen to do some, but make your own bed as an adult would.
That includes choosing the companion of a lifetime.
Good point
I personally feel that parents blessing and opinions matter a lot. They always want the best for us. They never talk to us about it does not mean that they don't care for us. They want us to happy. They do so much for us when we are young so at least having their blessings or opinions is the least we can do.
Good point
Thanks
I think it depends on the relationship with u and ur family. I am very close to my family. Even dating, if my family didn’t like the guy i would ask y and depending on their reasons I break up with him. Now my decisions in a relationship is still my decision but love is blind and I’ve been head over heals with people that were not good for me and I was able to find out super early thanks to my family. I especially value my mom and my grand parents opinion. They have seen it all and they know me good and bad, they’ve been able to catch onto weather me and a person will even be able to work out based on observing my interactions with them.
Im close too but i just feel this should be a couples decision
I asked the parents for both the wives I've had.
Wife 1.0 had her father and mother separated. I asked her mom before marrying her, if she was OK with it. She was OK with that idea, yet she told me I didn't need her permission.
Wife 2.0 was already divorced from her ex and I still asked her parents if they were OK with marrying her. I realized she lived on her own with her 2 kids, but I still asked. Her father told me she was a big girl and could make up her own mind about that. That's pretty much the response I expected. At the same time, I think they were excited to know Daughter #6 was going to get married again and that I was soon to be their new son-in-law.
Well thats sweet
I was so, so happy when I discovered that my fiancé (now my husband) in time-honoured tradition had gone secretly to ask my father for his permission, and blessing in having his daughter's hand in marriage.
Yea tradition seems like a thing of the past these days
@DizzyDesii Well it totally surprised me beyond belief when I discovered that Jack ( my husband) had actually planned it all out without me ever suspecting anything untowards.
Along with both my family and his, all of which were in the know-how, he proposed to me on Christmas morning 2017... I do hope you can believe me when I say, I'm still smiling and as I type this.
Im smiling just reading this
Thank you so much @DizzyDesii ❤
I never asked the dads, I think that is one tradition that needs to die. I'm not marrying them, granted when you marry someone you marry into their family too.
My father in law did joke though about how he didn't care if I asked but he still wanted his sheep.
I'm very conflicted on this one.
On the one hand, I care a lot about families. I have a tremendous amount of respect for a girl's parents, and I want to do right by them.
On the other hand, I also strongly believe in the concept of generational autonomy, and I don't think any adult should need their parents' permission to marry. I don't want her to feel like a child. She's not their property.
So I honestly don't know what I would do. I guess I'd just have to read the situation when that time comes and try to act appropriately.
If the girls parents said no, would you propose anyway?
@DizzyDesii I don't know. That's a tough one.
I mean, I would still want to marry her if she wanted to marry me? But what if I didn't know?
I'm not sure if it's worth taking the risk of proposing when
1. I don't know if she's going to say yes or not.
2. I've already been told not to do it.
This one is more and more awkward as you get older, I guess I would ask but it would be super weird at my age. One of my parents is dead the other one is a senior citizen so I wouldn't expect it any input from the living one.
Oh i see
My husband didn't ask my parents to marry me. He told them he was going to propose and asked if they would support him as my husband. They said yes and everyone was happy. I think asking the parents for marriage is pretty archaic.
I like the way he did it
I don't feel it's necessary but out of respect for her parents I do plan to ask for their blessing. Not getting it won't stop me though
Sounds good
No. Kids do all kinds of shit without their parents blessing. An adult should not require the blessing of their parents. It's their life to live.
Right
No, I feel like I’m independent and there’s no need for all that especially since I wouldn’t marry someone I haven’t lived with for a while. So in my head, we’re living together, we have a shared budget and all that we basically function like family and if my family had something to say they would’ve 😁 I could say no and it would make it uncomfortable for the both of us if someone else other than us knew.
Yea i can't live with them until we’re already engaged
Yea im just not trying to shack up for long. If im engaged to someone for 3-6 months thats long enough for me to live with them to know if i can handle that style
No not personally I suppose it is nice in principle but it’s a very old fashioned idea women are largely independent nowadays and my parents disapproval wouldn’t stop me
Right on
If it was important to my partner that I get their parents' approval/permission before I propose, I would do it. Otherwise, I wouldn't even think of it. And if the guy I was dating asked my parents' permission before proposing to me, I'm not sure how I'd feel. Probably angry. Marriage is between me and my partner, I don't need my parents knowing a proposal is coming before I do, and I don't need their approval to marry someone
Yea family spoils stuff
I don't know, I'm kinda old-fashioned like that... If I liked and respected them, then I certainly would, particularly her father... But, it depends what kind of relationship she/we have/have had with them🤷♂️
I feel that even tho my dad is nice, he's not in the picture and shouldn't have a say so
In my culture, parents handle the propsal part. And I would not give that tradition away for anything. Even if the marriage is coming out of love and courtship of some sort, parents make it formal by taking the proposal to the girl's parents and then wait for their response in due course.
Marriage is a bond between two families. Not just an isolated fulfilment of desire between two individuals.
I think it's a nice thing to do. But if they don't give it, you don't always have to hold to that. You make your own choices and are simply allowing them the right to give a blessing. But the choice at the end of the day is still up to you
I agree
I think parents have put their heart and their soul into bringing up their children at least a lot of them do anyway and I think it's only proper and respectful if you do that
Lol you already answered my next post haha
I asked my wifes dad.. i see no issues with it as long as they understand that even without the blessing i would have married her. Thankfully he said yes.
Lol you answered my next post
well normally it would be the polite thing to do but not in my situation my parents ONLY THINK OF THERE OWN PERSONAL GAIN OR INTEREST cause they want me all to themselves for there own interest and purpose
Omg my moms like that!
I will ask, but it’s more of a courtesy, if they say no than I’ll still marry her, I’ll pay for the wedding in full if need be.
I planned to pay for it regardless of parental or spousal assistance
The only persons opinion I would care about is the person I'm about to wedd. The opinions of anyone's else is irrelevant.
I agree
It's not necessary really, but it is tradition. If you're an adult, then you don't have to ask for your parent's blessing.
I see
I did it because my ex wanted me to, otherwise I wouldn’t have done it. I don’t expect whoever marries my daughter to do it.
Ahh okayy
For me he should ask my mom, because it's just about respect, understanding, and a blessing since I'm conservative
I’m more conservative then not but this was just one tradition i didn't care to follow
It's not necessary to ask for the parents blessing, but it does give a good impression for your partner and for the parents.
If I was a father, I would be proud of my daughters fiance if he were to ask for the blessing from both my wife and I.
I don't think their blessing is necessary, unless my partner comes from a super traditional family and they would feel it's important. It's not that important for me.
I agree
I don’t have that family dynamic necessary for that kind of thing so... no😂
I bet most of us dont lol
We were in our twenties and living on our own. Besides everyone already knew we were going to get married.
So they indirectly blessed it lol
Lmao damn that fam was slick
I would certainly ask for her father’s blessing to marry my girlfriend (if I was dating and about to marry) out of respect to him.
Respect to him or respect for yourself
I am trying to remember if I asked her father or not. I don't think that I did. Society has changed a lot and that seems to be one of the things that is not as important as it used to be
Yep tradition is having a meltdown
Indeed
People should be asked. Who ever matters most to who ever. Parents should ask adult kids 25 or any age. That does not guarantee respect or mutual respect though. I wish it guarantees some respect. To the spouse from the blesser.
Ahh I see your point
I dont feel a parents blessing is necessary for them to propose to me.
Right. Like they’ll find out when i find out 😂 I better be first to find out 🤣
Ikr.. Plus, what if they accidentally hint to/tell you. It wouldn't be much of a surprise anymore.
My mom would definitely hint
Because at the time I, was very traditional. I asked both my ex's parent's. But I, don't think it's necessary. Just like I, don't think being married os necessary.
Yea at this point if i want to have kids with someone certain, i prefer we be married before conceiving. But if i were to go off and have kids by in vitro or something, i dont really see marriage as necessary. I’d prob just date the guy forever
While Inknow my girlfriend's father loves and cares about her, he doesn't seem that invested in her love life. I would probably ask for her mother's blessing.
Well thats nice of you
I don't think she'll be surprised. Before I propose, we need to make sure that our relationship will actually be possible with our mental health issues and government aid programs. So unless her mother is completely dead to the world around her, she'll know it's coming for months before it does.
Nope, ask for their opinion sure but not permission
As a father I would appreciate it. But it's not necessary
Did you ask for permission too?
Yes I'm old school. If my parents aren't around he can ask my brothers
Definitely the brothers to avoid gettin beat up lol
It's the traditional thing to do and something I will do.
I see
I feel like it's the right thing to do since the guy is asking to marry their daughter and and become part of the family in doing so.
True
I don't give a fuck about a blessing, to be honest. I ask the woman, not the entire family, to spend her entire life with me.
Lmao
I always felt it's the right thing to do. That's how I was brought up
I hear ya
I could, also, care less. Unless it's my child in question. 🤣😂
Oh so you want ask for permission but they gotta ask for yours lol
Not what I meant. I don't care if I have to ask. If I have to, I will. If I don't, I won't
But, when I have a kid, and the proposal is about to happen, they better ask me first.
Depends on my partner's feelings and how I/she get along with her parents. If she would want me to ask, I'll ask
asking for blessing is honoring our parents and we should
I see
Not really; I'm marrying the partner, not the parents.
I agree
Nope never made sense. Raise your kids to know how to find the right one
Right
Definitely i couldn't propose to someone without doing that tbh
Oh i see
My parents have always supported me in all my decisions till date so yea i would ask them
No you’d ask the girls parents not yours
Parents blessings is important but not their decision.
Oh i see
I asked her dad he said yes but twenty six years later we still aren’t married lol
Oh lawd
It’s fine we have no pre nip or don’t need lawyers for a divorce just walk away with what we want. But I think we might be together for twenty six more years
Nope unless its gonna be like back in the days and there gonna pay for it
😂😂😂
Not a chance in hell.
Lmao i take it you chose C?
Id think its super cute if he did ask
Yea kinda
Yes absolutely! It’s the respectful thing to do.
I hear ya
Yes, It is a tradition in my family.
Oh i see
I didn't ask, but they gave it anyway. 🤷🏻♂️
How without you asking lol? Rhey just had a hunch?
No, they gave it after the fact 😂
Yes you should get blessings
Alrighty
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions