Lord of the Rings. Should it be cancelled due its White Supremacy themes and negative depictions of minorities?

[Ivory_Princess]

Updates

+1 y

Sauron is the Dark Lord of Peace

Updates

+1 y

Orcs face discrimination in middle earth when it comes to
• Employment

• Getting bank loans

• Getting a mortgage

• Immigration to the west

• Getting Government housing

• College Admissions

• Dealing with Law Enforcement (Rangers, Rohirm)

• Dating outside their race

• Right to protest

• Speaking their language

• Being allowed to practice their culture and religion

• Eating kosher orcish food

• Representation of Orcs in the media

[bolverk]

More BS from the Intersectional/Identitarian Woke crowd who are more to blame for the rise in cross racial violence as they are breaking the populous into tribes, Black, Asian, White etc. This helps none but The I/I crowd, while limiting any cross group communication that would be able to resolve problems at a local level.

[RolandCuthbert]

Yeah cancel it.

[Bananaman177]

The things you say. . .

How would you like it if they cancelled some great African work of literature for being too afro-centric? Like Black Panther, that's kind of like African Lord of the Rings, I mean not really, but it's African. I mean, not really, but there were black people in it.

They had one black woman in the Hobbit movies, in Lake Town. Weren't you satisfied with that?

[RolandCuthbert]

@Bananaman177 Wow.

[Bananaman177]

How am I supposed to detect a joke when it isn't funny, Roland? That's the pass/fail test for that, buddy.

[RolandCuthbert]

@Bananaman177 Dude, I don't care what you detect. I don't care what you think. I don't care about your whining or your bitching. In fact, I don't even care if I care or not.

[Bananaman177]

You sound so demoralized. You don't exude the chill of a man who feels secure and in control. You exude the energy of a hunted man.

What's hunting you, lad? Tell Papa Bear.

[Aethereal]

Is this a joke? It sounds so absurd.

NO! NEVER! OMG! it's a fantasy movie, an awesome fantasy movie, and some snowflakes want to cancel it because it doesn't conform to their real world opinions?
If they don't like it, don't watch it! Let people who appreciate good movies enjoy good movies. I consider myself mature enough to not let my views on the real world prevent me from enjoying fiction. I'm so sick of seeing how hard modern movies today try to cater to immature people who can't put down their pitchforks for 2 hours. And now they want to attack old movies? Pathetic!

Does this mean that we can one day except a LOTR remake were the orcs take the place of the humans and elves? I wish them luck counting the imaginary money that will make them.

[Taylor_C]

LOTR is an allegory over the WWII atrocities, but also drawing on other eras in European history. you clearly need to educate yourself, not only on the background of the LOTR trilogy, but also on literature in general and how it's working. You should be more concerned over real life human rights issues, like women in the Middle East being jailed for decades for not wearing a hijab, and Saudi being a member of the UN Comission on the status of women.

[Ivory_Princess]

Done by non white eastern people?

[Taylor_C]

Yes, arabs

[BluishGaze]

Wow, I thought I've seen it all.

But if I recall correctly, there were some people out there that tried to make the wild connection that Tolkien---whether he meant to or not---depicted dark skinned people as "unclean" and "wicked," and that he personified them as Orcs and Uruk-Hai... while the light skinned race of Men, Elves, Dwarves, Hobbits were clean and pure.

It is because of this insane, over analyzing of a fantasy that I imagine led to the memes you see here. This is what happens when you try to find "racism" and "white supremacy" in everything. You leave yourself open to Trolls (no pun intended) that will capitalize on how easily some people get riled up.

[Anonymous]

I don't think Tolkien was racist, but I find annoying how most of the main characters are portrayed as blond or light brown haired and blue eyed. You can see the same pattern repeated in Troy, 300, Cleopatra and other historical fiction movies (Duh, I mean the ancient Greeks were Mediterranean people like modern Greeks, so obviously blondes were a minority)

[Opinion Owner]

I know this was probably a joke, but it had to be said

[Ivory_Princess]

Are you sure because there's been a lot of migration in the historical Greece area, Romans, slavs turks etc. Dont forget also that Greece was once part of the hellenic world the encompassed the black sea region, Egypt, scilly, Spain, France, the Middle East, Central asia and India. Thats quite the melting pot.
Italy itself when the Western Roman empire fell was largely depopulated of native Italian peoples and largely replaced by German barbarians. Same as modern day france, spain and England.
I doubt that in any place people are ethnically identical are even close to what they looked like a few thousand years ago.

[Opinion Owner]

Wow, you're so uneducated like most Americans.

[Opinion Owner]

According to studies, ancient Greeks consisted mostly of Neolithic farmers from the Near East (haplogroups E and J2). Slavic Europeans belonged to haplogroups R1A. As you can see in this map, R1A is a minority in modern-day Greece. The majority is J2 and E3B. Also, Q, is absent from Greece. This means very little to no Central Asian DNA. The original Turks were of Mongolian/Central Asian ancestry. Modern day Turks are just Turkified/convert Ed Armenians, Kurds, Jews and Greeks.

[Opinion Owner]

Also, Greece has always been a Mediterranean country with excessive sun exposure, so it makes no sense that its inhabitants would be Nordic like Brad Pitt or Jennifer Lawrence. Most ancient Greek paintings depict people with dark hair

[Ivory_Princess]

commons.m.wikimedia.org/.../File:Sofi_Tzadka.jpg
This is a samartian, her people have lived in the middle east since her people left Egypt with moses. They have rarely ever intermarried with other ethnicities.
There was never historically a greek country until recently just hellenic cities and kingdoms.
Most barbarians were Germanics came from the near East pushed by the huns, Celtic peoples at one time lived in the near East as did sythians.
Minonans probably weren't ethnically Greek, more likely closer to semitic or North africa you would think but genetic studies show them closer to northern Europeans which may make sense as the minonoans were major traders of bronze, a major producer of copper and tin was in England Cornwall and then you consider that they'd be trading as far as the black sea up those rivers.
You also got to take in climate change, supposedly the Sahara desert for instance is 2000-4000 years old if true Egypt would have been a different land than today.

[Opinion Owner]

The ancient Greeks were not Nordic you Nazi scum

[Opinion Owner]

Blue eyes have always been and still are in the minority in the Middle East. This woman most likely has ancestors outside the Middle East.
The ancient Athenians, the founders of democracy were Pelasgians. The Pelasgians were of West Asian (Neolithic Farmer ancestry) and the majority of them had brown hair and brown eyes, as is depicted in their paintings.

The idea of the blond ancient Greeks seems to be nothing but a racist fantasy based solely on a handful of references to specific Greeks with blond hair in certain works of Greek poetry. I’m sure a few Greeks probably had blond hair, but the idea that all or even most of them had blond hair is clearly misguided. Blond hair in general has never been particularly common in Greece or the Peloponnesos and the evidence to support the idea that the ancient Greeks were all blond is remarkably scant. Only Neonazis and white supremacists like to claim otherwise

[Opinion Owner]

This what Aristotle wrote about both White and Black skin tones... "Too black a hue marks the coward, as witness Egyptians and Ethiopians, and so does also too white a complexion, as you may see from women. So the hue that makes for courage must be intermediate between these extremes. A tawny colour indicates a bold spirit, as in lions; but too ruddy a hue marks a rogue, as in the case of the fox. A pale mottled hue signifies cowardice, for that is the colour one turns in terror. The honey-pale are cold, and coldness means immobility, and an immobile body means slowness. A red hue indicates hastiness, for all parts of the body on being heated by movement turn red. A flaming skin, however, indicates madness, for it results from an overheated body, and extreme bodily heat is likely to mean madness."

[Opinion Owner]

In ancient Greece women were praised because they were "white-handed", but men never.

To call someone a Greek "white" was like he means to call him gay. On the contrary, when the poets say that Ulysses, for example, had black skin, this could well be associated with the tough life of Ithaca.

Color terms are not intended to categorize people racially but to contribute to their characterization.

A study published in 2018 in Nature magazine analyzed the DNA of 19 people from mainland Greece and Crete. Because of the conclusions, we can almost certainly say that the ancient Greeks had a similar genotype and phenotype to that of modern Greeks. There are, however, some questions. Bronze Age Greeks are likely to have darker skin, eyes and hair. They were also significantly shorter than modern ones.

[Opinion Owner]

Also, the actress you linked is Israeli, not Middle-Eastern. Israel is comprised of people all over the world and includes lots of converts to Judaism. Wikipedia says "she formally converted to Judaism along with her sisters at the age of 18." this doesn't mean her ancestors have always lived in the Middle East. No one can tell that for sure. So the Samaritans have always lived in the Middle East and never mixed with anyone but the ancient Greeks were replaced by lots of other ethnicities? Lol
How do you explain that they still speak the same language with some changes of course? Modern Greek is derived from Koine, a common dialect of Ancient Greek that was understood throughout the Greek-speaking world at that time. If that's the case, modern Greeks would speak Turkish or Slavic, or Latin

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sofi_Tsedaka

[Ivory_Princess]

I never said they were Nordic but its ridiculous trying to fix boarders at a time when most people were nomadic. Proto Europeans were migrating from the caucasian mountains in every direction about 7000-5000 years BC around the same time crraten civilisation and a lot of civilisations began. DNA testing has shown this

Bronze age myceneans and anatolians like minoans share most of their DNA from the caucasian migrations coming from the caucasus regions and share most common dna with North Europeans, Iranians, celts and slavs.

[Ivory_Princess]

Again that woman is a samartian. They don't intermix, they never have. They are a very ancient people that go all the way back to exodus and left Egypt with moses.

[Opinion Owner]

First of all, it's Samaritan and not "Samartian". So you claim that the Middle East and the Mediterranean was a melting pot, but somehow only the Samaritans remained the same?
I'm sorry but the typical Jewish look is brown curly hair and eyes, not blonde

What's ridiculous is trying to rewrite history the way it suits you to fit your agenda and Aryan fantasies.
You haven't answered my question; why don't modern Greeks speak Slavic or Turkish, if they're imposters that replaced the ancient Greeks, this would be logical

[Opinion Owner]

According to a study by Harvard, modern Greeks have the same DNA with the Minoans and Mycenaeans.
Suck it up

www.sciscape.org/.../

[Ivory_Princess]

Sorry *Samaritans* are not Jewish, they are Hebrew. And yes they have never mixed since the time of Daniel when the kingdom of Israel was split. Not mixing with others is part of their culture.
Not just the middle east or Mediterranean. There were mass migrations of nomadic people often during extreme climate change and natural disasters settled people moved on.
If it was an aryan fantasy slavs would not be included now would they. Turks over time have become more like the peoples they conquered. Which is why turks in Turkey look more western.
Your Harford study confirms what I said about caucasians settling Greece and anatolia from the caucasus, even Iranians hail from the region and are very close to germanic peoples

[Oigit]

Ha, this is both funny and sad. It's a great joke, but I half expect some people to honestly Save the Orc campaign at some point. If I had the means I'd create Orc's and do my best to start a Hug a Orc campaign on social media. Just to watch shit hit the fan.

[MAC1983]

Short answer: Why? What do you think is better for society?

A thoughtful, even if polarizing work of art? An abstract picture? A still life? A intervention song or a classic symphony?

There is not one this-size-fits-all answer... People can make great suggestions for you if they know you, but only you are able to figure out what is more important, and will have a more positive effect of you next.

What do you think?

[Anonymous]

What the actual fuck is wrong with some people? Someone is seriously trying to tell me that Lord of the Rings is offensive! For fuck sake, seek some help already! There's just no hope for some, honestly!

[Opinion Owner]

Do these morons realise when it was written, do they understand any culture outside of their own? Its actually pathetic now!

[Opinion Owner]

Since when has maturity become so rare? Grow the fuck up little bitches lol.

[Opinion Owner]

I say this because no doubt there really are some out there who would write this tosh.

[Ivory_Princess]

Written during a period where people of color were enslaved

[Opinion Owner]

Yet it wasn't about that in any shape or form. Go figure!

[Jmmmfi4]

MHO this person

[Ivory_Princess]

@Jmmmfi4 why? She clearly is otchaphobic and prejudiced against those that follow the dark Lord of peace Sauron.

[Opinion Owner]

Lmao

[yucychan]

How one can relate LORT to white supremacy is beyond me.
I guess if you really want to look at everything with such intensity, everything can be seen as offensive.
It's pretty sad.

[VanillaSalt]

It’s a joke

[Kiss_Me]

You are reaching to find racism in Anything. The more you do, the less people will listen to you. When they stop listening to you, the real racism out there will continue.

[IAMNathanael]

Can we enjoy nothing? It's a fantasy series and has no connection to the real world. I say let it be.

[DavidFox]

Nope, I’d rather not cancel most art. Art is a form of expression and if people are offended they are not required to consume it. Let’s stop canceling things.

[Virgo31]

I seriously hope you’re joking because are you really trying to connect racism with made up characters?

[Levin]

I don't know what's funnier. The memes, or the majority of Americans failing to spot the blatant irony of it.

[jshm2]

No. The people who think it should be taken as anything other than fiction, are the ones who need to be cancelled.

[humanearth]

I never saw any of the Lord of the rings movies. So I can't comment on this question

[coolhandroo]

People sure do have more feelings that I have sensitivity for or care to cater to. I feel like most people should pop a couple tryactin ( as in try-actin like a man) and not take everything so personal or assume that everyone should like them

[Twalli]

Orcs were elves. Uruks were a cross between orcs and goblins. Urukhai added humans to the mix.

[Ivory_Princess]

Yet orcs dace racial discrimination on a daily basis

[Richardceorl1]

Orcs are wild beasts that eat human flesh, destroy nature, feminist

[bigmit25]

Definitely not, it's all fictional, if we took all negativety out of entertainment it'd make everything boring

[VanillaSalt]

Joke

[Fromdusktilldawn]

I hope you're trolling. Else you belong in a mental institute

[SavageGirl101]

It’s a FICTIONAL MOVIE😁 stop being so fucking sensitive y’all stay tryna cancel everything