
Who do you think is the greatest American president in history?


- Unquestionably Abraham Lincoln. While the others you listed had defining accomplishments and are of undoubted historical importance, none was as decisive and significant as Lincoln, who not only saved the Union in its darkest hour, he defined its very nature.
Indeed, some years back a group of historians rated Lincoln and Churchill not just as great national leaders, but as the greatest leaders in all Western civilization. They earned the accolade - to be sure an accolade not without controversy - because they recurred to very wellsprings of Western civilization to define their statecraft and preserve their societies.
To some degree, this is an observation with a speculative cast. We can only imagine how the Western world would have looked had the United States not survived its civil war. (Ditto had Britain not stood alone and survived in 1940-41.) However, even in a contemporaneous context, Lincoln stands out.
At the time Lincoln became President, it was not just that the country was divided on the question of slavery - with all of its implications for how man viewed his fellow man. The country was, significantly, divided over its very nature. The question of whether or not it was single national community, or instead a confederation of separate and distinct communities, each with their own identity and, in extremis, sovereignty.
Lincoln answered the question not just through military victory - which by itself would not have been enduring - but by summoning the nation to the philosophical essentials of its birth. He defined the nation by common attachment to a specific creed - "a nation dedicated to a proposition" - and in the fullness of time defined the nation.
No President - not even Washington nor Jefferson - answered the question of what the United States was, and thus what it is now, as permanently and definitively. By summoning "the mystic chords of memory," i. e. to a keener sense of its animating principles, Lincoln turned the country into a nation. Something much more essential and elemental and thus enduring.
Not perfectly or completely to be sure. There is no perfection in this mortal veil of tears. However, it is undeniable that had their been no Lincoln, there would have been no America, and had there been no America, the history of Western civilization going forward - with all of its promise of human rights, democracy, and the rule of law - would have looked very different and likely would have taken a far darker turn.0|30|0Is this still revelant?the left hate Abraham Lincoln didn't you see how they were targeting him next? with C4 and everyrhing
@The_Sal Ah yes, who can forget that terrible day when John Wilkes "Antifa" Booth blew up Abraham Lincoln with a package of C4?
Most Helpful Guy
- I don't think any President deserves to be described as "greatest", since every one of them has done some pretty horrible stuff, especially by modern standards. If we're talking about which President did the least amount of evil, Jimmy Carter might be a good pick, since he at least tried to pursue a humanitarian foreign policy and seemed like an all-round decent guy. If we're talking about which President did the most good for the country (while ignoring all the bad stuff), I think that Washington and Lincoln would probably be at the top for, y'know, creating the country and keeping it united, respectively.
The problem with this question is that it pretty much immediately gets bogged down wth everyone's own political views. For instance, I think that FDR's New Deal did a whole lot of good for the average citizen, but others would argue that it was a step towards socialism or something along those lines. Likewise, I would say that Regan's economic policies, imperialist views, and refusal to do anything about the AIDS epidemic would put him near the bottom of the list of presidents, but others would praise him for pretty much the exact same things*.
*Maybe not the AIDS epidemic, although the more virulent homophobes might still be convinced that it was some sort of divine punishment and Reagan did nothing wrong.0|00|1Is this still revelant?
Most Helpful Girls
- I pretty never paid much attention to politics. I can't even name all of our presidents. I can't even tell you what number we’re on0|00|0Is this still revelant?
- Which Roosevelt? There have been two.
Jefferson and Reagan were both good.1|20|0Is this still revelant?Yes I don't doubt that he was a good president, and I like Jefferson because he was a Francophile lol, I'm talking about Franklin Roosevelt, he's the one who will impose American hegemony in the world which had been prepared by Wilson
Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions
What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!What Girls & Guys Said
1951- To which Roosevelt do you refer, Theodore or FDR?0|00|0
@Jamie05rhs I think WW I is what made the US a world superpower, so I immediately thought of Teddy. He was president from 1901-1909, expanded the US Navy and sent it around the world to demonstrate our greatly enhanced naval capability. This allowed the US to be a prominent player in WW I and this stake a claim to superpower status.
- Show All Show Less
@OlderAndWiser Good Point. There's definitely a valid argument to be made there.
But @Jonathanlama specified that it was Franklin in a response to @Elliegirl.@Jamie05rhs Well, he's wrong because FDR's response to the Depression created the entitlement mentality which has ruined or nation: if you have a problem, it is the obligation of the federal government to fix it for you. FDR is the source for most of what is wrong with the US today.
@OlderAndWiser I don't disagree with you there. (Though Johnson also bears a large part of the blame.)
- You must be referring to Theodore not his more famous cousin Franklin.
I find it difficult to to select one. Most did the best they could under the conditions which they served. Some were not up to the task. And a few worked to undermine the importance of the idea of the office and the document which created it. Which has already begun under the current administration.
I would have to select the idea of president and not any man. The office of The President of the United States of America which is still unique in the world. Those who served in that position were just men0|00|0 - I dont know an awful lot about the US presidents but i would go with JFK on the basis that he tried to stand up to the mob and other darkside forces etc and it cost him his life and he must have known that at the time.
Im sure there are skeletons in his closest too, there aren't any perfect people but it takes a lot of courage to put yourself on the line and try to do the right thing by other people.
https://vimeo.com/3388631570|10|0 - Donald T... LoL nah I’m kidding! I think George Washington by far has the greatest story and served the country the most.
“Washington turned down a crown... a lot of history books talk about how many powerful people and the military itself wanted to make him king after the war was over But he refused it. Then after serving as president twice he refused to run again because he believed it was to much power for a single person to have. Not many people that become better once you give them power”.0|10|0 - Washington or Lincoln. Washington, because he could easily have become a dictator, and instead, set America on the course to be a democratic republic, where the people chose their leader. And Lincoln, who brought us through slavery and the civil war, to become a better nation, and the prospect of freedom for all Americans.0|00|0
- Fuck Roosevelt, he is a traitor and a criminal for milions of lifes.
BEST PRESIDENT OF US WHAS:
1. Woodrow WilsonHe win the WW1
Create the Leag of Nation
He suport the idea of USA been a part of that league
He wanted to unificate Europ in a federal country whit no more diference
Didn't suport the sever punishment to germany.
And demand to Europ to accept this list:He wanted to educat thous brats and stop any future war forever and creat an aliat of USA of the same level of power.
0|00|1Franklin Roosevelt, he's the one who will impose American hegemony in the world which had been prepared by Wilson
Roosevelt and Churchil are 2 pice of shit.
They negociate the fate of the Eastern countrys at Ialta whidout caling any reprezentation from thous countrys. They damn dear to treet Stalin like a victim and Roosevelt whas a kity cat vs Stalin who force him to travel all the way from USA to Russia when he know whas in horiblemedical situation, later on he die before winig the war, Truman wan the WW2Woodrow Wilson and i like olso Linkon, but the first one had the oportunity to change the WORLD
- Show All Show Less
You forget that Roosevelt was ill, and anyway it was he who succeeded in being the great architect of American hegemony over the world. We don't care about kindness, all that matters is to impose our power
Your mistake is to read history through the eyes of the countries of the east, but you have to be honest the great world powers they care little about the countries of the east, if they were interested in their countries it is just to be able to break the Russian influence
That why moust of the historical people from West are traitors for Easterns. Napoleon is a hero for West, enemy for UK and Russia, nobady for Serbs and Greeks...
Except that the Greeks and the French were not at the same world level at that time. But I am an admirer of the Greeks. I am amazed at your respect for Napoleon when many compare him to Hitler
For fighting Russia he get the respect of Romania and Poland ;)
I'm admireing the history of ancient Greek whntile the Roman retreet from Dacia, afther that we didn't care any more about them and because of Ottomans they put some fnars leaders on my country whitch they whas greeks who just pay the tribut, so i can hate Greek for that as well. They didn't give military suport in WW1 and we depand on you France and UK to teach us to fight and give wapens because Greek didn't hold our back. (But here in the Balkan evrybody hate each other no mather what :) )So i will suport Woodrow Wilson because he wanted to make a world like mine :)
Olso Lincon for fighting for a noble idea and try to get to the people sould whit his words.You have a naive view of the world, in reality Roosevelt followed Wilson's plan, Wilson's goal was to create American hegemony, Roosevelt to achieve it. You resonate in terms of bad guy or good guy is more complex than that, it's all just a question of power and domination
All European nations, even my country, opposed the plans. The problem was that the senate refused US membership in the National League, and European countries did not consider his plans for the Peace of Versailles.
- Which Roosevelt?
Teddy Roosevelt was okay. Someone like him would never get anywhere in US politics today or in the last 20 years, but he gets a lot of credit solely for his own image, which is a pretty common theme in popular US presidents.
Franklin Roosevelt is probably the single most overrated president in US history. I would rank him in the bottom ten for sure, not so sure if I'd put him in bottom 5.0|31|0Franklin Roosevelt is the president who allowed American hegemony, that's not a bad result, right?
That's not necessarily a good thing for the US today. I would have agreed with that perhaps had the US brought back its troops from at least Europe in the early 1990s.
Despite having almost four full terms in office, FDR did very little that actually benefitted the country, and had it not been for World War 2, he likely would be remembered in a much more negative way. Both he and his wife were very big on backdoor dealings and keeping people all the way up to and including his own vice president completely in the dark. In regards to handling the great depression, his policies made recovery much slower than it should've been (similar to Obama's handling of the much more recent economic recovery, except substantially worse), and it was almost certainly intentional in order to justify massive expansions of government, which up to that point had been much less intrusive compared to today. His reaction and preparation leading into WW2 was nothing short of negligent (and would probably see him impeached by modern standards), though to his credit, he handled the actual wartime period reasonably well, and is frankly far better than the rest of his presidency. He also mentored a lot of the slimiest politicians of the 40s-70s, most notably LBJ, who in turn cheated to win his senate seat in 1948.
- Thomas Jefferson. But not just for what he did as President. I'm picking him based on his entire life.
(Yes, I know he cheated on his wife. I'm just ignoring that part for now. I'm sure over half the presidents did the same thing. Including Clinton, Trump, and probably Biden.)0|00|0 - Anonymous1 moI would say Lincoln, but the weird ass liberals are telling us that Lincoln didn't do enough to end slavery. So I'll just go with Trump. Biggest thing he did was expose the decades of hidden corruption in the political system. When the 2 party system decided to be each other's controlled opposition, rather than truly working to help the American people, Trump shattered the program and showed everyone what was going on behind the velvet curtains. And for all the foreigners who bitch about America messing around in other countries every day on here, Trump brokered historic peace deals and started NO wars for the first time in...60 years? Y'all should be thanking the man.0|30|1
- President Donald Trump was the best President in the last 150 years or so. He was a president that was elected by the people to clean up the corruption in Washington and that's what the left couldn't deal with. They fought with his ideas the whole 4 years he was President because he tried to stop the Bullshit, Lifetime Politicians. I love my Country, I just don't like the new Government. We are headed down a dark stretch in the history of this great country, The United States of America. God Bless America Again.0|01|2
- James Polk is my choice (not a name you'll normally hear), because he greatly increased the territory of the US and achieved all of his objectives in a single term.0|00|0
- Except for one big misstep, I agree - Teddy Roosevelt. A great leader, a badass, but also a very smart man.2|20|0
- Power doesn't make someone Great, doing the right thing makes them Great.
Lincoln is the Greatest President because he did the right thing regarding ending slavery.1|30|0 - George Washington or Abraham Lincoln, without George Washington there would be no America, and one could easily argue that Abraham Lincoln was the first BLM supporter.1|20|0
- None of them. Each had their hand in doing really fucked up stuff, from native genocide, war crimes, manipulation of other countries that came back to bite us in the ass causing another war, causing a war for money, breaking a peace treaty with Hawaii and genociding the people for a tourist spot, continuously opressing and attacking the African-American people, manipulation of the government for financial gain, putting drugs in poor neighborhoods and in native reservations,.. etc.0|20|1
- George Washington because he voluntarily left office, something unheard of at that time.
Abraham Lincoln because he fought to preserve the nation, and worked to free fellow human beings living in bondage.2|20|0 - I think Ronald Reagan and jimmy carter. Jimmy carter is still helping people to this day and he’s like 90 something. I only know what they did post presidency since I was too young to know what they did in office.1|00|1
Jimmy Carter is the one who ruined our social security system. He was certainly a wonderful man, but an ignorant president.
Reagan had wonderful and terrible qualities as president, that's for certain. I believe he was, like Carter, also a wonderful person.
- Tomáš Garrigue Masaryk0|00|0
- Anonymous1 moProbably FDR, helped us out of the great depression with the new deal, helped us win against the Nazis.. what more do you want?2|10|1
- From "ancient" history: George Washington, Abraham Lincoln & Theodore Roosevelt.
From "not-so-ancient" (or modern) history: Franklin Roosevelt, Ronald Reagan & Bill Clinton.0|10|0 - JFK i don't think i need to really explain why for him.2|10|0
well many many multiple reasons, but mainly his hard stance on poverty, reducing taxes, and standing up ageist Nixon in his running, then his equal rights role but that can be said about quite a few presidents, then he stopped the Cuba getting nukes. Plus he's a democrat that even republicans look back on fondly at least i get the impression they do. Never heard anyone kinda on boths sides complaining about him.
- Washington was offered King of America. He turned it down and created the presidency.3|50|0
@Noémieclara of course that’s what I meant. Because I’m not capable of intricate, complex thoughts.
@OddBeMe What is complicated? for you, America's greatest president is a man who owns slaves. You have the right no problem.
- Show All Show Less
@Noémieclara and Obama didn’t support lgbt rights until his second term. No ones perfect. I can appreciate the act of a president without accepting all the evil shit. Dumbass.
I thought you were a person who supported movements like Black Lives Matter, you can't on the one hand support movements like that, or by the way they unbolt statues representing slavery, and you, you dare to put a man like George Washington as the best president in American history. Dumbass. Besides, where is the French girl @Jonathanlama, I'm sure she would agree with you
@Noémieclara I can actually. If Robert E Lee spent the rest of his life fighting for civil rights, a statue might be warranted. This is why liberals are hated.
- Abraham Lincoln and FDR. I only really put FDR because his wife was the SINGLEMOST greatest first lady america has ever had.0|10|0
- The one who ended slavery and made a rule presidents can’t serve more than 2 terms - not sure the name cause I’m not American0|10|0
Those were two different presidents.
I don't know who did the term limits, but Abraham Lincoln was the man from Illinois who ended slavery.The two-term limit was put into place when Harry Truman was president, I’m pretty sure, although it had been a unofficial rule since Washington.
- Anonymous1 moYou'd have to go back pretty close to our nations founding to find a truly great and God-worshipping president.0|00|0
- Franklin D Roosevelt by helping end the Great Depression0|41|0
I would argue that the fact that all the factories in Europe being leveled during WWII was the major contributing factor in that.
- FDR and Lincoln, then Washington.
I think Eisenhower shouldn't be underrated.0|00|1>Liberals love FDR
>FDR forcibly interned thousands of American citizens just because of their heritage
Oh but his new deal stopped the great depression. No it actually extended the depression and gave America a taste of what socialism was like. And we can also thank FDR for basically supplying China and Russia with the starter packs to become the socialist scourges they would later become.FDR is why you still have a country that gives you the freedom to bitch about FDR... and to do so in English.
Stop being an idiot.
It's very unbecoming.
- It's not trump thats for sure5|62|5
- Not American but I'd say Abe Lincoln is the obvipus answer. Followed probably by Franklin D. Roosevelt.0|20|0
- FDR gets my vote. He pulled America out of the Depression.1|00|1
did he tho? did he really? or did he happen to preside over the natural growth out of a recession and his policies actually slowed it down?
- In history. George Washington. Recent times, Ronald Reagan was love by most. Economic growth was huge and he was very popular with both parties.0|10|0
yeah you're severely brain damaged.
only the left could post something so backwards ands retarded- Show All Show Less
Economic growth for a few, stagnation or worse for most. A trend that has continued ever since.
@CapitalismFailed there’s been a consistent growth of 2% each year. Under Reagan it was around 6%. But it can be argued that economic growth has very little to do with presidents.
- Roosevent, possibly Carter.0|00|0
- My top 3 (in no particular order) are John F Kennedy, Abraham Lincoln, and Barack Obama.0|10|1
- Donald Trump. One man against the entire system.2|44|4
- Anonymous1 moAbe or roose, America isn't the first world power tho2|00|0
@Jamie05rhs Roma, had problem whit the germanic tribs. Declar Dacia the moust strongast country even afther they incorporate in theyr empire.
Greek olso whas a huge power.
China.
But USA is the first WORL POWER.- Show All Show Less
You're speaking of Romania, right? Aren't you from there? (I believe we spoke before.)
@Jamie05rhs maby, yes i'm from Romania. The dacians people are the only "barbarian whit statues in Roma. Not other region get so much respect from the Romans
- Undoubtedly Abraham Lincoln.0|00|0
- Best: Theodore Roosevelt
Worst: Woodrow Wilson0|11|0- Show All Show Less
I hope you are American because that will give your voice more credit than mine lol. More seriously, Wilson wanted the American hegemony, Roosevelt to realized it. Alexandru resonates in terms of good or bad, which does not make sense to me because the greatest world powers even if they dress their power in democratic discourse the reality is that there is just power and domination that counts
I agree to a point. I'm actually not opposed to a strong degree of hegemony. Not because I'm opposed to other cultures as a moral, but because I believe democracies are sensitive. I understand that without power, there will always be another power to overrule yours. Is that what you mean?
You guys are starting to bullshiting to much. Winson wanted an United Europ that will be enought strong to not depand on other nation to make peace and end all the war by unificating all the country and give more freedome to all of them
i don't care who whas wilson before, i care about what he reallty wanted to do for my country and others. If Roosveld whas good for USA and bad for my country then he is a shit hole
I understand what he wanted and I agree with that specific sentiment. That alone does not make a great president. Watch the video I posted in this comments section.
I don't care what someone wanted to do, I care about what they did. He attacked American rights and stated policies that lead to many of the nutty left wing philosophies America has today.
@Hogwheels Yes, I will give a concrete example, when France decides to help the United States for their war of independence, France says that she will help the Americans to defend freedom and the cause of an oppressed people, the reality is that France just wants revenge on the English in relation to the Seven Years' War which caused the loss of hegemony of France. I think we have to stop having a naive view of the world, everyone is fighting for their own interests and they are right
I think you're absolutely right that many french bureaucrats just wanted revenge. I think Lafeyette actually believed in freedom.
You two speak from the posts of countries, leaders and partisans.
The USA was not treated as a slave and France was not enslaved since Roman times.
A figure like Napoleon and Wilson who wanted to change something and failed, because there were circumstances outside their power are worth much more than others who did but only at lower levels.
The great powers should not talk about the world as they wish.
Small nations are not your toys, we are not slaves to anyone and we do not accept to be ruled by anyone. If Wilson proposed and took action for the 14 points then it is clear from what he himself presented that he was and will be the best president for the whole WORLD.@Hogwheels You are right, Lafayette was really sincere. But Lafayette, whom I respect enormously, was a naive man, he thought that freedom was what guide peoples, Napoleon in this sentence about Lafayette, "La Fayette is an eternal political idiot, duped by men and things"
Any great nation that wants to impose itself in front of any other nation will pay the necessary price in blood.
@Jonathanlama, I'm a libertarian. I think big government always, let me repeat, ALWAYS, becomes corrupt. High taxes always leads to kickbacks. More government officials always leads to corrupt lobbying.
Freedom means being able to choose from a multitude of options. Wilson wanted to offer the widest variety of options.
Completely wrong, more people represent a harder majority to control and corrupt. It is said by a person who lived in the country of the last European communist dictator.
Sorry, I misspoke. Yes there are branches of government where more is good. I meant fewer people executing law and policy, and more accountability against those people.
As for legislators, more of them and higher standards for passing law. It should be more than 50%. The filibuster is the only thing holding this country together and the filibuster means nothing if there's no accountability to our president and his executive orders.What keeps the country united is the will of the people. Because there is a larger group of politicians in a democracy than a dictatorship, this allows information to flow from outside that group. Thus, the people have indirect access to information from offices.
The people decide what needs to be done. The French girl should agree here. Didn't the French Revolution teach you anything?I agree with you on one point, small nations deserve respect, but Wilson like Roosevelt didn't care about freedom or democracy, he just wanted to impose American power, which is why the Americans stepped in in the world war, the American leaders did not care about the freedom of Europe, but it was the perfect opportunity for Americans to impose themselves in the world
I know the US had hidden interests. But they only imposed the kind of government. They were adapting our continent to a democratic and united system, what will not suit you from those 14 points?
I don't think America's primary goal was spreading democracy. I think Vietnam was about French Corn and Iraq was about oil. I actually see the merits of the Iraq war though. Oil was and probably still is the most valuable currency in the world and who ever controls it has a lot of sway in the world. It would not be good to let the middle east have that sway.
the oil teory from Midle East is just conspiratory teory, USA have the second lages production of oil in the world and the biggest reserv in the world afther Russia, so live me alone whit that one.
But the middle east has more access to trade with Europe and Russia was trying to take rights to the oil, specifically in Syria.
It's imposible to take the Oil from Midle East whidout making conflict whit EU and Russia in the same move. Olso USA have Venezuela more close whith have more oil the Midle East. Is a war for extending the democracy, get a new aliat in the future by suporting a pro USA governament and manage a culture that is persecuted whit medieval rouls
The EU are pansies who would never do anything in retaliation. They'd just have morality meetings where they'd condemn Russia as if that'll get Russia to stop.
@Hogwheels i am 100 percent agree with you, it is precisely the problem european union, the problem is that the countries of the european union have decided to get out of history and just trade and human rights as new religion
- I would FDR for ending the Great Depression.0|21|0
- Anonymous1 moMy favorite would probably be Thomas Jefferson.
My least favorite would have to be Woodrow Wilson, Lincoln, Lyndon B. Johnson, or Truman.0|01|1 - Obviously Donald Trump1|52|2
- Sure the fuck wasn't the orange cheeto guy.0|00|0
- FDR is the best by far.1|00|1
- Trump. Stood against evil when nobody else would.1|42|6
- Anonymous1 moI agree with you, and maybe Reagan or Clinton0|00|0
- That dude on the hundred dollar bill.0|00|1
- Show All Show Less
- Those can't exist. They're all dog shit0|00|2
- I think Lincoln was our greatest president1|00|0
- Show More (10)
Related myTakes
Learn more
AI Bot Choice
Superb Opinion