I only wear mascara and sometimes eyeliner because I think I'm fine without foundation and stuff like that. Do guys find that more attractive than a girl wearing makeup that makes them look "flawless"?
This is one question you are likely to get horrible advice about from men. If a woman puts on makeup and she looks good, most men won't notice that she is even wearing makeup, much less how much she is wearing. Guys only notice makeup if the makeup is done poorly and makes the woman look bad. Which is why guys say they prefer women that don't wear makeup, or only wears a little, but run straight to the women that are covered in makeup. These guys are only noticing makeup when it is done poorly, and not when it is done well.
OMG yes. Been trying to tell this to people. A bit of black eyeliner is all a girl needs to make her get a few more points on the rating scale. Anything else is just useless I mean, MAYBE foundation/concealer if you have bad skin or something. But have you ever had guys ask if you're sick or tired when you forget to put on makeup? That's because of your lack of eyeliner. Eyeshadow and mascara is not usually necessary and won't make you look much better.
The guy who got MHO is wrong. I can tell when a girl has makeup or not and I can tell how much of a different it makes, because quite a few girls these days skip the makeup every once in a while.