Who should I take on my first date?

So I’ve matched with 2 different girls on a dating app, and kind of got into a situation where I may be double booked for next weekend. I have absolutely no dating experience but I’m trying to finally just be bold and go on my first date ever. However, I don’t want to hurt the feelings of either one of them, and I don't know how I should approach this. What should I do? I am leaning towards girl 1, but I might want to give girl 2 a chance.

Girl 1: Have matched on at least 3 different apps, lives close by, has a lot in common with me, seems quite attractive in pictures, seems like a really nice person and smart as well.

Girl 2: Moving to a town 45 minutes away on Monday from the opposite side of the US, originally from foreign country, different religion than me, very different from me in general, super sweet, looks absolutely gorgeous in pics.
Just go out with girl 1
Just go out with girl 2
Go out with girl 1 on Friday and Girl 2 on Saturday or vice versa
Call girl 1 and have a conversation with her and then decide
Call girl 2 and have a conversation with her and then decide
Ghost both of them and stay eternally single forever
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Who should I take on my first date?
Post Opinion