I've heard "Ginger or Mary Ann" asked before. But what about Jeannie, Samantha, and Elly May?

[CheerGirl38139]

Keep in mind that 1960's TV censors wouldn't even allow belly buttons to be shown. So let's not pick Jeannie solely because of the costume. Who wins "sexiest" woman overall in a "bargument" in YOUR opinion?

Tina Louise - Ginger on Gilligan's Island

Dawn Wells - Mary Ann on Gilligan's Island

Barbara Eden - Jeannie on I dream of Jeannie

Elizabeth Montgomery - Samantha on Bewitched

Donna Douglas - Elly May on The Beverly Hillbillies

Someone else from 1960's TV

Updates

+1 y

PEOPLE... Geezus Forking Cripes... I realize that these shows were WAY before most of us were born. That doesn't mean that we can't have an opinion... or even still watch some of these shows in reruns for that matter. I've heard guys in their 20's MANY times have the Ginger/MaryAnn/Jeannie debate.

[countrydude]

I grew up watching all the above. Loved Ginger the red head. And still like redeads. But Maryanne was my favorite.

definitely Gennie over Samantha. Yes clothing may have her clothing or lack there of. And the fantasies when I was 10 or so. Or maybe it was because I was always in trouble and figured a geuniewould be more helpful then a witch. Lol

[dolemite68]

i love marlo thomas in that girl and elizabeth montgomery in bewitched, they were hot. i dream of genie was overrated i didn't think she was that cute. Both ginger and maryann were hot, maryann was the cuter of the too tho for sure

[CheerGirl38139]

No love for Elly May. :(

[dolemite68]

lol nah she was a funny character i didn't think she was all that cute tho.

[dolemite68]

thank u kindly for mho :)

[Robbey]

They're all beautiful, but Elizabeth Montgomery was the most beautiful of them all.

[EmpatheticLady]

Ugh, that's a really hard choice honestly. I think I'll go with Barbara Eden.

[April10]

Love love love all those old shows! Old good fashioned and wholesome :)

[peachblossomluck]

I always wanted to be like Ginger when I grew up and I sort of am lol.

[OlderAndWiser]

This is the girl that had my attention when I was a young lad in the 1960's:

s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/.../...55bf611203.jpg

[CheerGirl38139]

HAhaha Marsha Marsha Marsha

That's kinda cheating tho, since the Brady Bunch didn't premier until late September 1969 (I Googled it, so it must be true). :)

[OlderAndWiser]

I also Googled it. 1969 counts as the 1960's.

Susan Dey on the Partidge Family didn't premier until 1970. She was the next goddess of my fantasies!

[CheerGirl38139]

LOL fair enough

[OlderAndWiser]

T minus how many days now? How is the job search going? Feel free to switch to PM.

[JimRSmith]

This question has made me thankful I'm around now, and not in the 60s.

Would they have appealed to me, if I'd have been living in the 60s? Probably, yes. But the hair, the clothes etc just look old-fashioned to me now...

The faces are nice, but the hair? That can stay in the 60s.

[CheerGirl38139]

I agree. but they were sexy for their time, especially given what the censors would not allow.

https://youtu.be/N0JsKW-Az1A

[JimRSmith]

Anyway, in ANSWER to your question, I've actually wasted a few mins that I'll never get back on Youtube, and have come to the conclusion that my answer is the Gilligan's girls OR Samantha.

I must have something that I never knew I had against sixties Big Hair...

[CheerGirl38139]

media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/.../...dd6eb8630825.jpg

[JimRSmith]

Actually, that's not anything like as bad, but that's what - 40s?

[CheerGirl38139]

no way. That was her head shot just before she was cast in The Beverly Hillbillies.

Elly May wasn't 45 years old on that show. LOLOL.

[IronPickle]

crap. u don't allow anons. haha. grrrr. But I always loved Samantha. :D Not sayin' the others aren't hot though. cuz they are. Maybe I liked her the best cuz she seemed more real. Like she wasn't TRYING so hard to be sexy all the time. I don't know.

[CheerGirl38139]

Cool.

And yeah. I almost never allow anonymous answers to my questions. :)

[MarkRet]

I'll go with Mary Ann, but Jeannie is a close second.

[CheerGirl38139]

I think that's about where I am too. I hate Elly May's (character's) hair, but Donna Douglas was so damn cute.

s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/.../...e836a9a4b5.jpg

[MarkRet]

Elle May's cute too. It's too bad Donna Douglas didn't do anything after The Beverly Hillbillies.

[docster]

It would be a tough choice between Barbara Eden from "Jeannie", Marlo Thomas from "That Girl", and Marta Kristen who played Judy Robinson on "Lost in space".

[spnsfi]

They all have the look in their eyes like they would kill you in your sleep, lmfao

I picked samantha

[Nadzzz]

I'll go with my babe logesh <3

[CheerGirl38139]

cool did he have a TV show?

"I'm out for blood" ?_?

[Nadzzz]

yeah exactly and he only used to invite girls on their first day of period there aw

[fauchelevent]

I had a huge crush on Elizabeth Montgomery <3

[Glen68]

the brunette from threes company

[CheerGirl38139]

good call, but not 1960's.

[Glen68]

oh darn! was that in the 70's? I knew it was back there but couldn't remember when. then I pick Samantha from bewitched

[CheerGirl38139]

Google says 76-84 actually. There's no way that a guy pretending to be gay so that he could live with 2 single girls would have flown by 1960's censors.

[Glen68]

that is so true. he was an amazing actor though

[ThisDudeHere]

The style is a bit too old for me.

[CheerGirl38139]

that's not the point LOL

[ThisDudeHere]

Then what is the point?

[CheerGirl38139]

the time was 1960's. The time could be 1920's. or 1940's.

Women were still sexy regardless of the decade or the fashion style at the time. Look at all the pinup girls from WWII.

[ThisDudeHere]

A bit too slutty.

[CheerGirl38139]

God, you're such an old woman. LOL.

[ThisDudeHere]

no u r

[Lithium65]

Elizabeth Montgomery ;j

[Decentguy]

Elizabeth Montgomery - Samantha on Bewitched

[WhereAmI]

They're old people.

[WhereAmI]

Unless you grew up fantasizing about them i dont see the point.

[CheerGirl38139]

for fuck's sake man.

So is Marilyn Monroe.

[WhereAmI]

We'll maybe they do it for some people, but not me. If i had to pick someone from years back it would probably be Christie Brinkley who's kept her appeal for decades.

[CheerGirl38139]

That's a good one. Cheryl Ladd would be too.

https://i.imgur.com/kEb8eAO.jpg