Is a dark mythical setting less scary when magic is common?

more_than_a_guy

Help me settle a debate I have with my friend. In my opinion it is less scary, harder to write horror this way. Wouldn't be much of an unknown, which is beneficial for horror, and even if there is unknown, the characters with magic are more capable to deal with it. Yes, you can have more powerful dark enemies, but the element of actual horror fades away.

My friend says otherwise, you can do horror in every setting. I responded that the horror might be there at first, but it won't last long, especially if you want to continue the dark horror setting.

Yes, it's less scary
No, it's scary
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Is a dark mythical setting less scary when magic is common?
1 Opinion