Long story short, this girl I know acted as if attracted to me for a while, then the moment I started caring for her she just kept leading me on because she was afraid of the "talk". She lived in this ambiguous state of maybe.
My guys, if this is happening to you my advice is the moment you see her acting attracted to you call her out and make it clear that you have noticed it. Do not think that it is implied because if the girl is shy and fears confrontation she will always allow for the ambiguous possibility that you two might be together for the sake of avoiding the imminent rejection.
I spent like five months in this dance, and although I did learn a lot from the experience and I loved the play. I must say, RUN while you can.