Am I ungrateful or are we just not compatible?

My boyfriend (34M) and I (29F) have been in a relationship for 2 years now. I put a lot of value on fine-dining and dressing up to go out to romantic, upscale restaurants (what my ex and I used to do a lot) and love trying new foods while my current boyfriend doesn't place much value on these things and will just look up whatever restaurant has decent reviews on Google. Valentine's Day is in two weeks and my boyfriend just told me the restaurant he picked out for the occasion and it is a restaurant I've never heard of and looks like a family restaurant that I can't dress up in a nice dress and heels at (Sofi Restaurant in Chicago if you want to take a look), and overall, not my vibe. I was hoping for something more like Tre Dita in Chicago (feel free to look up and compare). I'm extremely disappointed but have kept quiet. This is not the first time this has happened and we have argued about this issue in the past. The only way I'm able to eat at restaurants I like is when I take the initiative to treat my boyfriend out and book nicer restaurants and pay for all of it. Am I ungrateful or are him and I just not a good match?
Am I ungrateful or are we just not compatible?
Post Opinion