
Is science helpless before God/nature?


Ok so let's say your argument is then, God exists and is showing humanity his power.
If that's the case your god is a prick, in fact the biggest prick of all. Your god is an immature spoilt child playing with an ant farm and will throw the farm to the floor when the ants don't behave in the way he or she expects.
What kind of omnipotent all knowing being gives us the power to determine our own fates and at the same time gives us the ability to reproduce at will.
What kind of selfish childish being then gets upset when we don't do exactly as it expects even though it had never once told us in any definitive manner exactly how to behave, and while being upset sends a virus that had the potential to kill billions of us and not in any way that shows this being gives a crap but I'm a way that causes intense pain and suffering and fear.
At the same time making sure that those who worship this being and follow what they think is the teachings of this being are at just as much risk of pain and fear and death as everyone else, as though this being just really doesn't give a shit whether or not you follow it's words.
Sorry but if that's the god your asking about then two things are true, either your god is a cunt or your god doesn't exist and this is just a natural consequence of human behaviour like all mamal behaviour when any mamal population gets too large disease breaks out and thins the numbers a bit.
Science is knowledge. It can't make us all-powerful in the face of every force in the universe. We can use science to predict sea level rise due to global warming and melting glaciers, but scientific knowledge alone can't magically reverse global warming. Nor can it magically heal people who contract deadly diseases. Eventually we may develop a vaccine to protect against SARS-Cov-2 but currently we don't have a way to do this instantaneously. Our understanding of biochemistry has grown tremendously in the past 50 years, so it seems possible that in the future we will be able to take a viral sample and quickly produce a vaccine.
But science works better than anything else. Prayer and religious observance is no help at all. At least 45 people became infected at a church choir rehearsal on March 6th, and some have already died. That was before the general quarantine, but the danger of the virus was known. The choir director assumed that no one in the choir was infected since there were no known infections in the county, but someone was and the infection was transmitted to 3/4 of the people who attended.
The majority of the people who died were elders. Like Old fragile people. If that's God way of showing power, well I'd be nervous as a religious person. Just because that "would be attempt" is pathetic and will be overthrown by... science yet again lol. If we find a cure that is. Science still be fighting. And what if we do find the cure. We're going to say that God said enough is enough, here is the cure? No, it'll be made by mankind.
It's not that I hate people who believe. I don't dislike them either. Some of my friends are like religious. I'm just so curious on why people believe. so I want to ask you to please respond to me and all the others who don't seem to agree with your beliefs. Let me understand you through your arguments, experiences.
Because everytime I do call out for a discussion like this. They don't bite. No one seems to want to talk for God. I see them reply to other believers, give them that like, that little thumbs up. But to me and other doubters, nope. We seem rather divided. One person here wishes death upon us, and that doesn't seem right, yet it was liked and replied to by other believers. Aren't we all children of God?
To the last statement, no. Message me if you would like to talk. Most "religious" folk don't actually live by anything they say, the number who actually believe is even smaller. It's socially advantageous in some places to claim to be under a god.
I grew up atheist, rather that's what I had reasoned from a young age, and converted later in life. Again, you can message me if you would like to have that talk you asked for, I think I might be easier to handle than most.
@meesegoMoo FINALLY!!! <3
I am religious, I do believe in God but not in a way were I see him/her as a figure looking at us for far away. God live in us, making us divine. Science for me is not something apart from God, knowledge is God and God is knowledge. This is my thinking.
This pandemic has nothing to do with God, our life in this planet has a process.
My answer is that God is in us and with us in this pandemic situation. That we humans believers and not, have our responsibilities with our planet and with our society. We will find a vaccine by the amazing scientists we have. We will learn that we need to protect Earth more. We will learn that be compassionate has nothing to do if we are believer or not in God, that on us, is our choice.
I know the Bible, know some religions and I do not believe in a God that punish us. I think as him/her as all love. The same amount of love we give the same amount of love we receive. We humans have make some mistakes but if we do not let our self forget we can learn and make resolutions so this never happen again with people dying in this proportions.
I hope you find my answers useful.
💖💖💖💖💖💖💓💓💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
Opinion
51Opinion
What do you mean by saying “science is helpless before” COVID-19? Science has been developing tests and vaccines to deal with this “invisible enemy”. I will grant you that human error has permitted this virus—which is genetically programmed in such a way as to make it really hard to stop—to run rampant: the virus is easily spread even before the infected individual has the symptoms to know they should avoid others; many of our elected leaders have been both obstructive of the processes in place to confront this crisis and dismissive of its seriousness; some segments of our population are still unwilling to accept that this virus is something that should be taken deadly seriously.
That does not mean that science is helpless. Nor does it mean that the virus is a manifestation of divine wrath (for that matter, what kind of “loving, merciful god” would afflict their “children” with this kind of death and horror?). It does mean that science must wait for those who wield the tools and power of science to do so. The longer they wait to act, the bigger the threat becomes.
If God wants to show he is greater than science, “he” is going to have to do more. Also, why should the deity who supposedly created humanity with the cognitive capacity to develop science should object to humanity making good use of that mental prowess? Would a loving parent coach their child to be a great soccer player... and then berate their child for making it onto the World Cup team? Does that make sense to you?
“... now nature is overruling human...” I think you should take a little more time to think about this. If nature is overruling human[ity], that would imply that humanity was being wiped out. What more likely appears to be happening is that humanity is thinking too much of itself and not enough about the nature around it. Nature is not being spiteful or actively attacking humanity.
Idiots that deny nature is a thing are helpless before nature. As in the example of morons who think men can turn into women and race is a "social construct" . Science is the study of nature and depends on natural laws for it's existence. What ever science learns is part of nature and caries natures authority if it is correctly learned that is. It's just that nature is the biggest thickest book imaginable with pages that go on forever and we learn slowly. We were helpless before smallpox once too till we learned natures laws regarding it.
I am always amazed how people want god to exist (yes I believe he does)
But they way they try to prove his existence is when something horrible happens to people.
It's got to make god feel horrible to know his followers think so little of him that they think he is so petty that he would kill thousands of people to win an argument
Lick my asshole
Why not? He killed the wives of his most devoted follower and gave him disease and deformity just to win a bet with Satan. He wiped out all life on earth exept for the occupants of Noah's ark. So if this Yahweh is real, he cares little for his creation. Good thing he's an invention of man
@Tien who said he did that? The bible? 😂
Biblically, God handed over the keys to the car that is earth to Us to handle, maintain, and take care of while remaining in direct contact to Himself for any outside help. We decided we wanted to work our own agenda and end up losing the favor of the literal source of goodness and joy. As a result everything slowly becomes more and more corrupt and Godless, more genetically deluted and less healthy. Until towards the end days human genetics are so weak cancer, alzheimers, heart disease, and mutation run rampent through the populis and God weeps on the sidelines saying "Why did you abandon me?"
Your question is just a ridiculous misunderstanding of science, and I have to laugh!!!
Thank you for that, and amusing me with this post!!
Science is about hypothesis, and testing, analysis, and evaluation! It takes time! It isn't Harry Potter's wand, and a Latin phrase to cure all, much like God, has not just waved His Great Hand, and saved the thousands of beloved Grandmothers and Grandfathers, that have succumbed to this virus.
If God was all-loving, why would there be viruses like this, that kill children's beloved, ADORED grandparents?
Focus your statement/argument, and don't wander off with a lot of other nonsense, like animals, and pollution, and so on, confusing the issue, when your argument, at it's simplest, is not valid and ready to stand logical debate.
U know I have this theory... i may have not been the first to think of it but anyways... what if God was real (doesn't have to be God in paticular just a higher higher power)... and we humans are all just lab rats part of an experiment... and every 'bad thing' that happens is just another variable or test. Our deaths are equivalent to that of an ant in his eyes... insignificant (๑°⌓°๑) God is honestly what we want him to be, An all powerful, loving, righteous being (and all that could just be part of a variable) We can't really know hez true nature... maybe he is cruel... maybe hez not a very shiny old dude as hez often depicted... maybe hez name isn't God its Steve... maybe he intentionally nuked the lizards so that we may question who came first as part of a variable who knows ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Science is far from helpless, but science doesn't mean instant answers and instant solutions to every problem.
Science is learning faster than ever, but the amount of information to learn is effectively infinite, so we prioritize what is most important to us. But we will never have every answer.
Gods were created by men to provide answers to questions that otherwise had no hope of being answered, due to a lack of scientific knowledge, and to give hope and comfort to people in a brutal, cruel world. And while we're far from being experts of the universe, we've at least moved on from "kindergarten" into grade school from a scientific perspective. We've mostly gotten past monsters under the bed and the man in the sky throwing lightning bolts.
If god exists, then he's the one that created it and its infinite workings
This God vs Science bullshit needs to stop
Having science means you like to find answers to complicated questions
Having faith means never questioning anything
Why dont you all meet in the middle and stop focusing on the differences.
Science will never find god no matter how weve advanced, even if he does exist, and god will never go against his creations, science included.
Find something a little better to find solutions to maybe?
Like racism or world hunger
Science is not helpless against Corona, thanks to science we know it exists, we know how to protect ourselves, we research it and look for cure/vaccine. What does God can do about it, doesn't matter how much you pray, you won't be healed, if anything your immune system will fight it off, and how do we know we even have immune system? Science. Ofc some people will say "god made you and gave you your immune system" did he tho' ? It baffles me doctors work hard and thanks to science and knowledge and skill save lives but cuz of religious beliefs people will credit god, god does everything and if a person did it, "god let him, he guided his hand" like for real. I don't hate god but hate zealous believers and religion in general.
We see many liberals/communists that have the mindset that they are more intelligent than everybody else put their faith in the system, technology, and the support infrastructure now finding themselves in a “foxhole” or the trenches with this COVID-19 as the scientists can’t reliably predict the outcome yet and feeling a need for hope. Their response it appears is panic and/or only seeing the worse. They fold quickly. However, I don’t think this is even close to being bad enough to convince yet. Yes, “God/nature” will quickly put all in their place when wrath befalls upon it all.
To my friends in the land of the lost…
I think your, probably, islamic or Christian faith make you unable to think rationally. Science is a method, not a way of life. And we've had way worse than Covid19, and scientists found curee through the use of science. And since you think god wants to show he is greater than science by creating Covid19, doesn't that mean your god is a murderer who choses to kill hundred of thousands people just because he's insecure? Your thinking is all over the place mate, get a grip, we'll talk about god when there will be a proof that god exists.
science has no power. people have. science is just the best way of "knowing things" that humanity currently has. and well for example if a huge meteorite hits earth, humans will just die. there's no way around it, cause our capacity to do shit about that is too insignificant. that doesn't mean science failed. we do not have the capacity to do certain things. science isn't magic...
god however doesn't exist so i don't know how something that doesn't exist would even wanna oppose or "overpower" anything.
so tl;dr: no, science isn't "helpless". humans are. the reason for that isn't god but the limited resources that we have access to.
What do you think is going on in the medical industry is doing right now? Medicinal research is currently working on a vaccine and pathologists have been devising methods to best inhibit the spread of the disease. Heck, one of the biggest things that spreads it currently is social gatherings which includes church services. Those that have been compiling with the recommendations from the medical experts (The scientists) have been the least likely to catch COVID-19. It seems odd that something supposedly caused by god seems to be 'created' to cause so much conflict with those that worship it.
If there were a vaccine for Covid tomorrow, theists would just say it was their gods will that there would be a vaccine and that Covid being defeated was therefore religion defeating science - This argument is easily spun whatever way you want to. Because there is no clear battle line on where a virus or its vaccine falls with regards to a science vs religion dichotomy.
😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😆
It's the other way around: god is helpless before science (especially since science is factual and god is an invention for pathetic idiots who love being decieved out of their logic and money). As for nature - well it goes hand in hand with science. And asking how come science is allegedly helpless in dealing with Covid-19 - well that just shows an accute lack of ability to understand the definitions of science, research and scientific progress.
By all means, you oxygen wasting insects, pray to your "god", but it will be the scientists who find a cure. Feel free to refuse a vaccine and die.
A virus kills some people and you're just like "hang it up doc and bow before the almighty, you're useless, no sense even trying." Well fuck you and anyone who thinks like you. how good are prayers are at stopping viruses? Does holy water cure cancer? Who works in hospitals shithead? Not priests and faith healers, Joel Osteen dont prescribe your medications, people with PHDs in medical SCIENCE do.
Damn kudos to you! Smartest statement I've ever seen by a minor from this site ! Wolf in the heard. Keep at that in this world 😎
What do mean by coincidence? I dont understand that.
Also how is science helpless, we have already created test, and ard already testing vaccines so i dont see how its helpless against it. Plus if god really is behind the covid 19 virus he's lost his game back in the old days he flooded the entire world but now he's reduced to this?
What actually caused this was evolution, what I believe you have done is the "god of the gaps" argument you've seen a gap and filled it with you're perception of god.
I mean he's god if he wanted to heal the world why use a temporary ineffective solution. It may have slightly improved things but it's not some big restoration of the world.
Our immune system will adapt as they have countless
times through history. Science will simply reduce the death toll necessary for that to take place. As for God I think the fact huge numbers of people are helping others during this crisis shows we don't need god and his evil schemes.
I want you to unblock me
Science isn't some sort of "entity", nor it is a group of educated people studying certain fields.
Science is just a method. A way to gather information and gain knowledge.
If God really wanted to show how we're helpless against him, then wouldn't he make us suffer from something that would be literally impossible to solve without his help? Since you mentioned that we will eventually be able to develop a vaccine, then doesn't that kinda disprove your entire view on this?
If you study hindus old books you will get all things
Like take example of corona
In Hindu whenever we come back home first of all we clean hand foot face or some take bath
Second we do namaste
Third whenever someone died we don't touch that person family for 13 day and we burn that body so no one get infected and coming back from burning we use a tree Wich is natural antygerm and take bath
When ever you chant mantras you made a secret frequency
If you want more then go on YouTube and search for sadhguru
Science takes time. 🤷. But will never best nature.
If God exists he's a shit one. Promising those who follow him this and that, then letting them suffer. 🤷 Letting Innocents get killed.
Nature is healing itself as best as it can, but idiots preaching it as gods will aren't helping it.
Nature is a part of the universe. And the universe doesn't win in particular matters, the universe IS winning because it isn't fighting; here the continuation of the action relates to eternity as (not explicitly) specified (but to see as such mentally by reading) time period.
Science allowed me to predict this way back when China was reporting a little over a hundred cases. I had enough confidence in my education and skills to say for certain that it would reach my country very soon and it would be a serious threat, thus I should prepare and educate my family in advance. So far none of us have been infected. So it empower me just fine to protect myself and my family.
"Science" is not some all-encompassing entity. There are many strands of both 'applied' science and 'theoretical' science. And we probably have those scientific disciplines to thank for the virus not being 10 times worse than at present. Besides, if what the bible says about God is true, then God would be more likely to GIVE us coronavirus than to protect us from it. So I'll stick with the people who are actually trying to fix the situation.
I believe that peopledidn't just appear, we evolved from fish, to lizards, anything in between, and then too apes and here we are. The reason we haven't found a reason to solve corona virus is because it's a complex virus and can't just be solved with a simple vaccine.
We are all helpless to God. He is Lord over everything and everyone.
As far as Him causing "death by virus", man caused "death by anything" through original sin. God loves us: He gave us a means of redemption through Salvation via Jesus Christ. When we turn to Him, He is gracious, covers us with His mercy and grace.
If you listen to some whos theories are very relevant the would say a God that made every 1 gave us the ability to fix our problems we make an usnt punishing us maybe the punishments innlife are the mean an evil peoples things they do even when the virus is cured an people just forget to realise we should be helping all work together an fix this
This is not the first pandemic or even apocalypse if you will. The black plague during the Dark Ages wiped out more than half the population. It's not always that easy to find a cure for a disease all the time. Did people already forget how long it took for there to to be a cure for the Polio virus? You and everybody just feels that way because the Corona is effecting everybody and at a fast rate.
Lol you idiot. Science takes time, study, testing, peer review. There are no true limits to science, only the limitations of our life-spans and capabilities. Prayer is useless no matter how much time and effort you put into it. If science was nothing compared to nature, we wouldn't be causing the apocalypse for countless living creatures yet here we are
@Regmorus its not about being proud. We shouldn't be proud of nuclear weaponry, directed energy weaponry, rail guns, or our ability to create new diseases, but IS impressive. Can God allow you to communicate to someone on the moon? Can he GET you there? Can he regrow limbs? Once we can regrow limbs with science the sheep will still attribute it to God's magical powers. The bigger science gets, the smaller the Gods get
Science doesn't happen overnight. No doubt a vaccine will be developed in due course. But you seem confused, let me tell you that nature doesn't see science as a competitor. Science is how nature is understood. Nature is an open book for scientists to read.
Humans have never over taken nature, nor will they ever. Not even an atom bomb compares to the destructive force of a hurricane.
That said, the god I assume you refer to couldn’t stand before it either. He’s weak and pathetic
Science isn't helpless, we already have drugs that can treat coronavirus that are just going through end stage testing now and in about 12months we will have a vaccine and the coronavirus will be pretty much eradicated.
Science proves much. However, the more it proves, the more we discover what remains to be proved.
And questions of morality, ethics, spirit, etc? Those are beyond science.
The way I see it, humans are the dominant species now. But same as we get a fever to kill viruses, the earth will do the same, and wipe us out. And a new dominant species will rise up
There's no such thing as God. And science is not a mumbo jumbo which works on the spot. It takes time to research, experiment and implementation. That's how science work. But yeah, in the end, everything is helpless against nature.
Sorry that you feel that because scientists aren't gods that you need to believe in god to justify natures existance. They need time and resources to solve their goals like any profession.
Faith and reason are compatible. Always had been. Many of the scientist from the early modern period and into the 19th century were also clergymen.
Science explains how things work. Reconciliation of religious beliefs and science is not unusual, or at least shouldn't be (Isaac Newton comes to mind).
It has a 98% survival rate. Nature is not taking over humans. Those who have passed were already vulnerable elders
to those people who is still not believe in God should die. god let them be but they are becoming more bad, arrogant, violent. now it's time for Him to show that he's exist to punish them.
Wishing ill will on those who do not believe go against God and his acceptance of all of his creations
@MaidenMandy30 yes
That's what terrorists do, right?
@Succubus_On_Lockdown exactly. Foreign and domestic
@MaidenMandy30 not territories but those kind people are just trash
They go by that motto though "those who do not believe in God should die"
@Succubus_On_Lockdown you're definitely atheist
Most likely
I don't see why God would just spectate and watch his children kill eachother. Why would someone with the mentality of "every non believer should die" go to heaven?
@Succubus_On_Lockdown die to go to hell. rot in hell
I shall save you the best seat. I got you like that
@MaidenMandy30 it's for you two
I know. And i said i will save you a seat.
I love how theists always pretend like science is a monolith.
Science is more reliable then a pretent God that never existed so no the non existent god isn't showing that he is greater then science
and yet, god is why we exist. the universe was said to have been empty-so things like the big bang is impossible-just as it would be impossible for everything to to magically fall into place without a guiding hand. even scientists believe and know that science has its limits.
@Sabretooth I don't like sounding like a dick, but that's an argument from ignorance fallacy "I don't know how this could happen so I'm inserting an explanation that I think is possible with no substantial evidence behind it instead of just stating that I don't know"
@Sabretooth What I'm saying is that argument for gods existence doesn't hold up logically.
I think your right! Impressed by your way of thinking!
In many things God and science are in tune.. As far as the virus, the evidence shows it's man that has caused the problem, not some tussle between zGod and science...
God will always be greater than anything on this Earth, in the universe no matter what happens.
i'll let a few scientists chime in: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2003/sep/04/science.research
Yes absolutely. I need proof, or at the very least reason to think something is true.
what an ignorant, oblivious and self delusional outlook.
If that god you describe actually exists, it's a fucking evil monster.
I dont understand what nature has to do with a celestial being.
God isn't real, Xenu of Scientology created the universe.
It'd be really nice if you could grow a brain. Or at least two brain cells. Anything, just not what you are now.
Seeing how every step science takes, god gets smaller- I’d say the opposite.
there is literally a dome over the earth
no need to prove GOD
he proved himself
the firmament declares the glory of GOD
Well seeing as how science is a form of proving what is real, i think god loses this one.
Which god? By the way nature is science, it's called biology
None can't disprove each other. And science can't prevent every single disaster. Maybe it's a sign
Nope, science can't be helpless before something that doesn't exist (god)
No clue. Man has figured out everything there is to know about science and medicine. Very good question.
I don't think you understand how science works...
Depends on the particular situation
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions