Are all the Afghani's wanting to leave Afghanistan legitimate?

Question

Are all these people really at risk from the Taliban or do they just want to get out of Afghanistan and to the US like the rest of the world? And how many of them can be actually AlQuida or Taliban with dreams of Terrorism in the US? Are we opening ourselves up for another 9/11? We are already letting criminals, sex offenders/traffickers, gang members, and Cartel members into our country that are not vaccinated or tested for Covid. Seems to me we are shooting ourselves in the foot. Thoughts?

Avicenna · Accepted Answer

Well, we already know from the illegal migrant wave that Angela Merkel invited in back in 2015 that there are lots and lots of people from there who are not genuine refugees.

At any rate, other than the translators that directly worked with the US military, those Afghans who claim they are refugees would be best settled in Iran and other neighboring countries so they can be repatriated when conditions and while they are waiting they are in a neighboring country which is culturally similar and they'll have an easier time.

ChiTown33 · Accepted Answer

1. It doesn't matter. If they want to leave Afghanistan they should be allowed to leave. This is why the Taliban is bad news.
2. No Afghans should be allowed to come to the United States without applying for citizenship. I don't care what they did for us during the war. They weren't doing it for us. They were doing it for themselves and hopefully a future Afghanistan. If not? Well they learned a lesson didn't they. Maybe next time fight for the right reasons.

Coulis · Answer

You see your question is coming from an othered perspective that discounts the humanity of the group you are speaking about. The humanity of not every person being the same.

Did it ever occur to you that each individual may have a different reason?

Also, what is actually wrong with someone wanting to immigrate to the US or the UK? Is it that there are not from a desirable group that makes it so wrong? What would you do if you were in their shoes?

Now, I will say that given the chaos, absolutely there will be some bad apples slipping through.

I've already imagined the screenplay where someone murders his friend and his wife assumes his identity and takes the dead friend's infant child with him to the West.

Becomes an upstanding citizen and raises the child as his own. Then on his deathbed he confesses the truth to his "daughter" who then 25 years later goes back to Afghanistan to right wrongs and meet her real family.

I think I missed my calling...📽

Alexandrubaschet08 · Answer

Moust of the people who want to live are civilians who don't give a F about the Talibans lows and they know they will sufer very much if they stay.
I feel theyr pain, same did the USA afther WW2 whit my country, the abandon us to the communist and we suffer way much more then they ever can imaginate.
Same is happening whit people from afganistan, but at last ther are the eliberation army not the opresion army.
It's olso a risk to be in the crowd many bad people whit other intentions the just running from the Taliban regim.
I think is a very good idea to accept as many people posible and keep afther our eye very close on them when we bring them in Europ. Keep them izolate for a time, give them something to workd, inspect them and theyr program and activitis and if they seem to be clean and good people then lets integrate them even more.
I have a friend from Pakistan and when i ask him why all the countrys from Midle East are so crazy religios, he just tell me "i don't know, i never care about religion, i don't want to know nothing about thous countrys, now i'm here and that is the only thinkg that mather."

BCA6010 · Answer

The median age in Afghanistan is 20 or less. That means half the country wasn't even alive when the Taliban had control over the country before. Interpret that as you'd like.

The Taliban now is not really any ideologically different than it was 20 years ago, either. There's been a pretty ill-conceived attempt to paint them in a better picture in order to downplay the situation, but the reality is they are in fact going door to door kidnapping children and executing dissidents. It's probably true that they want "stability," except that's hand-in-hand with wanting subjugation. They're also openly backed by Pakistan and China now too, so between that and all the US and Russian hardware left behind, they will be much better supplied than before and as long as they don't step on China's toes, nobody will stop them.

jshm2 · Answer

Sheesh bucko, you need to quit flattering yourself, and thinking the world is only out to get you and yours!

You've been supporting the tomfoolery of the American empire for decades, but did you really think there would be no karma or kickback eventually?

Most of America's chickens are coming home to roost, from supporting dictators to cartels and gangs. The Afghans are probably the final straw as they broke up the Soviet Union and will probably break up the American empire as well.

By propping up the warlords and puppet government in Afghanistan the US overcommitted and it cost you over 1 trillion dollars. Now you've got all that kickback as all those traitors and informants aka "interpreters" (sic) will be expecting compensation and protection. Else they will be exposing exactly what the US got up to.
The real criminals were the US, not the Taliban in the affair.

genericname85 · Answer

if you live in a piss poor country with no perspective and no social security, of course another country looks better... why do you think those afganis don't flee to africa? yeah... that's right. now on the flipside, we went their and messed with their government. that is our fault. so we are guilty that they are messed up now. maybe they would have been as messed up if we had not been there. but we'll never know, cause we decided to go there, deconstruct their government, take their resources and build a half assed, instable government that won't hold for shit. so now we gotta help those people that wanna get out.

TonyMetal___86 · Answer

Misa daniels not the whole world wants to leave their countries to live in the USA, take me for example, my country can't be shittier than now and we are living in hell these days because our corrupted politicians but still i'd like to stay in my country cause i love it...

Before 2 years i was living like a king but after 2019 things have started going down and the country started suffering from an economy breakdown and now i'm considered very poor compared to what i was from 2 years, will i leave my country? NOPE i don't think so even though it would be a lot better than here but i find my indentity in my country...

I'd love to visit the U. S but not to reside there...

Pj1981 · Answer

I had the same question. How many terrorists are playing scared just to get in the country? America has already paid for the weapons that the taliban have control of so technically we armed our biggest enemy and I have no doubt we are bringing some in with the fleeing afghans.

Anonymous · Answer

I expect a lot of them to be like the people leaving Commie California in mass exodus. They're leaving because shitty leaders are putting their lives at risk and they recognize the danger, and want a better life, BUT the moment they get somewhere safe, they will go back to supporting the bad shit that made them fear for their lives in the first place.

Long story short, yes a lot of the people wanting out of Afghanistan will revert to supporting the harmful and dangerous Afghani way of life once they're out and safe. Guess it's kind of like battered woman syndrome. They escape from an abusive relationship, but have a high tendency to go right back to one.

Nik1hil · Answer

I am laughing at these Islamic Afghanistani people..
They praise Islam religion..
But when Islamic group take control of their nation and the country becomes truly Islamic.. 😂🤣 They start fleeing the nation..

If you cannot handle true form of your religion.. Then why do you support..

RolandCuthbert · Answer

I don't know what the word legitimate means in this case. But it is obvious that most want to leave over fear of being killed. But if you are talking about Afghans who believe in democracy, etc. I just don't see that.

Hypnos0929 · Answer

Most see the writing on the wall and want out before the shitstorm. Much like everyone else I think the people of Afghanistan fear the Taliban and are just victims of their government's roll over.
They may not have foreign vigor, hell they probably love their country, but they know they can't stand another regime.

_no_one_ · Answer

There are a few afgani students in my university and according to them majority of people don't wanna live there now. Their lives were getting better and stuff and they don't want to go back to a shitty system.

007kingifrit · Answer

no they can't be. some must be dangerous terrorists who don't share western values

rcljr · Answer

They want to flood America with their caveman religion and turn America into a shit hole, but I have news for them, the wetbacks beat them to it…

Wise4myage · Answer

Id be willing to bet some aren't. But then again, they can walk across our southern border.

karaspara · Answer

Sorry but no of course they aren't everyone knew what was coming so why wait until now? People who were directly at threat from the Taliban have been leaving for years

Likes2drive · Answer

Yeah they are if they let them in over here, I wonder how many could be taliban

Cozybcuz · Answer

Man, why do you think everyone wants to come to the US?

ThatNoUVAtYourEyes · Answer

I expect Taliban is grossly overrated. Bill Clinton and Tony Blair are small headed fools. Blair especially (Clinton's an alcoholic)

EnglishEuropean · Answer

This is why your people needed to be taken out before troops withdrew.

jimmy2 · Answer

You so right open borders who coming in everybody. He a joke he should of not ever been put on a ballot. The Democratic stole the election

Sam_The_Savage · Answer

Lol Taliban is Soros team... And Soros is the puppet master. USA is slave country. Everyone looting this stupid country 😂

Tomriss · Answer

Afghanistan will not make a lot of refugees in my opinion. But about the ones Usa should be responsible of them.

Massageman · Answer

Probably not. Why should they be any different from elsewhere?

anylolone · Answer

Nope, not even close. A lot, probably most. You know who's legitimate if they accept saudi arabia or turkey instead of Europe and the US.

888theGreat · Answer

our Gov't won't check them out. I am sure what ever happens from rape, or blown up , They will just blame Trump.

LeftHappy · Answer

More votes for the Democrats maybe, which is the reason the schools and media are there for under divide n conquer. What a great economy to bring them to huh?

Dantenera · Answer

Kenya is big and we have a lot of land and minimal population. Tell them to come kenya we'll assist them. Their life matter

OddBeMe · Answer

Actually immigrants are the least likely to commit crime.

IncognitoBandito · Answer

No some were born out of wedlock

blondfrog · Answer

Not but most of them.

he-takes-a-part · Answer

Nay its western media bias thats legitimate

aheisleycook · Answer

its that our history is our greatest enmey

Are all the Afghani's wanting to leave Afghanistan legitimate?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Thoughts On Afghanistan Basically Being Taken Over By The Terrorist Group Taliban? People Jumping Off Moving Planes Cause They Don’t Want To Be There?

Are all the Afghani's wanting to leave Afghanistan legitimate?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Thoughts On Afghanistan Basically Being Taken Over By The Terrorist Group Taliban? People Jumping Off Moving Planes Cause They Don’t Want To Be There?

We're glad to see you liked this post.