
Is the Confederate Flag “southern pride”?

Girl's Behavior
Guy's Behavior
Flirting
Dating
Relationships
Fashion & Beauty
Health & Fitness
Marriage & Weddings
Shopping & Gifts
Technology & Internet
Break Up & Divorce
Education & Career
Entertainment & Arts
Family & Friends
Food & Beverage
Hobbies & Leisure
Other
Religion & Spirituality
Society & Politics
Sports
Travel
Trending & News 
Blunt truth, many who put it in everyone's face often aren't even actual southerners. I knew somebody who was Texan and for real, all the way up to being descended from confederate soldiers. I remember her as actually quite humble and open minded. Not one to wave that flag around.
Look into backgrounds of people who wave that flag like a maniac or go as far as wearing it as a dress in 2013.
1. Do they ACTUALLY have any real confederate heritage? Likely no, as that's quite rare.
2. Many who obsess over this kind of thing up the line likely just come from Europe like most or anywhere besides the former Confederate area. Facts.
3. Many do so only for attention or just to be anti PC without actually caring for real confederate or southern heritage. I'd compare them to weebs. Or drama queens. Not much besides that.
4. If you walk into a small town, let's say in the middle of Mississippi, go into a bar/diner and see a confederate flag on the wall, but not much confederate stuff besides it, (maybe a bit of a rustic southern theme here and there) then, perhaps there's legitimacy to actual relation to it, but I can nearly guarantee most at the bar/diner barely even think much of it more than general decor, not much else and are too busy with their life to give it much thought.
5. The issue is the people who obsess with it. Both sides. On one hand, to many degrees, it's a flag of betrayal to America, kind of like putting up a North Korean flag, so flack for it may be expected in modern times. If you can't understand that, well, it's on you if a brick gets thrown through the diner window, as same would hold true for a diner with a North Korean flag.
On the other hand, I am not advocating to go out and attack those with those kinds of flags, as freedom of expression must be held for all, even if we don't agree. The minute it's not available for one, it's ALL in danger. In addition, many argue the confederates came into being because of high taxes. I'm not a historical expert, so I'm not going to get into that, but instead say I am unsure. Fact of the matter is a large amount of people see the flag as representing slavery and/or betrayal to America, so anyone who likes the flag has to be ready for it, just like with the Nazi or North Korean flag.
In conclusion, this. If one really is interested in the history of confederates and such, that's fine, and usually it'll show in that there is little to no obsession, but instead fascination. If one LITERALLY has the flag EVERYWHERE and is basically a weeb, but for it, then I understand retaliation. But I would say the proper way to retaliate to it is more subtle such as wearing a dress to the same prom, but with a union jack or American flag. Maybe even send that sorta person a holiday greetings card with a picture of Ulsseys S. Grant on it so that way they can't be as mad, since it'd obviously for the lulz and very subtle. If they do get mad, that's their problem, as it's a greeting card in the end, what could they say?
If somebody posts like crazy about the right for the flag and goes nutso online for it, troll em. Put in a photoshopped pic of a the Confederate and Chinese flag together with the caption, "south shall rise again." Whoever spreads that, you'll know is a fake. And you can call them out and start some nice epic chaos. :D Clever tricks like that often work when executed right. If you want people to rethink the whole confederate flag thing or really any issue, trolling is the key. :D
How is it a flag of betrayal if the South fought for American ideals enshrined in the Constitution?
The founding fathers supported the right of states to secede.
Its anti-democratic to tell states they must remain part of the Union even if people want to leave
What she's wearing in that photo isn't even the Confederate flag. The flag looked like these over the course of the US Civil War:
https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fqph.fs.quoracdn.net%2Fmain-qimg-5aab86949098e8e850566bf7b9541118&f=1&nofb=1
Good, bad or otherwise the fact is that this flag is and will always be a part of American history as are the statues of confederate generals etc and the thinking that removing them from sight is also WRONG! IT IS HISTORY AND NOTHING CAN EVER CHANGE THAT. Would be better to leave these thing to show how a country can grow and mature.
YA LETS KEEP RACISM AS PART OF HISTORY RIGHT?
@MacLove999 Yes, history. You know, in the past. What once was, but is no more.
So you just agreed to being a Racist.
@MacLove999 What the hell is going on in that weird mind of yours? Are you familiar with the expression, "Those who forget their history are condemned to repeat it"? Studying history is important, and it shouldn't be destroyed, because that would put you in league with those who (for example) burn books and smash statues. It would make you a barbarian.
@MacLove999 And don't give me that shit about being "racist", you little crybaby! "You're waycist, waaaaaa!" Only retards and children make that "argument".
If Stone Wall Jackson lives through the war , South might have won.
@888theGreat Actually, for once we agree. If he had not died, the war would almost certainly have dragged on for longer, and perhaps ended in 1866 or early 67.
@888theGreat actually economics disagrees with you. The north had 21 million people vs 11 million in the south, of which 4 million were slaves.
And yet as it is the South held out for five years on its own with no international support from Britain or France or anybody.
@MacLove999 IT IS PART OF OUR HISTORY FOREVER AND NOTHING CAN EVER CHANGE WHAT HAPPENED, only change the future!
@MacLove999 Are you this stupid or just being a troll
Learn history then act like human being instead of pig acting like a human.
@MacLove999 I know history very well, it was actually one of my favorite subjects! I listen to people like you spew shit and wonder how did you ever become so ignorant!
Wow you ain't learn anything if you think confederate flag wasn't racist. I guess you never been to a museum in your life.
@MacLove999 Dude. You really need to calm down. You’re talking to a woman who’s married to a literal BLACK MAN.
Get that in your feeble brain. Ok?
Ugly isn't history its why hitler was removed from Germany. You want keep monsters who raped women, killed kids and burnt slaves as hero's be my guest.
@MacLove999 Your the only one using the words "HERO" the actual words to be using would be "Actual Facts of What the Past Was" which is what has got us to where we are today by slowly correcting what we now see as wrong. I know I want all three of my biracial children to know how it was like for both my husbands past and my past. Nothing that happened in the USA could never be compared to what Adolf Hitler was doing, and speaking that you don't see the Jewish population trying to hide those days, you actually see them making museums so the future generations can see and learn what it was all about.
@katiesmuff taking millions of slaves for hundreds of years is not worse then 10 years of hitler rule? you're kidding right?
Wow am glad you didn't write history. Ooh i guess because you find what only happens to white people only is considered history. Not the Chinese or natives or slaved being blown to smitherines by bombs in mining coles. That was just fun for the millions of chinese labors who came to build roads and train tracks, right? Obama at least recognized it as massacre. Gave china an apology. Why would he do that if he knew they didn't do wrong?
Looks more like X marks the spot.
Referring to the dress
She has a point though. And knows where the point goes XD
Opinion
22Opinion
They can make up any nonsensical history they wish.
That isn't my concern.
But they won't control my reaction to it.
I mean the lady could have at least given the guy a chance.
She was respectful but the guy didn’t mean them any harm by it.
@WhiteBoyChill Why should anyone give the confederacy a chance?
Because the guy didn’t mean her harm. She didn’t even try to hold a conversation with him and he even apologized for it later
@WhiteBoyChill Wow. . . this comes from a guy who is intolerant of folks on the basis of his narrowly defined politics.
But somehow, doesn't understand someone who is intolerant of the confederate flag.
Do you understand the term cognitive dissonance?
I think the backwards southerners do consider it that way, yeah. But others prefer to take pride in the peaches, cooking, countryside, hospitality, Civil Rights history, and landmarks.
Nothing wrong with a flag. It doesn't shoot people. It is Northern Liberals making it mean something it doesn't . Hysterical liberals. It was the flag of Democrats , but I don't have a problem with it.
Does that make patriotic Germans nazis?
@WhiteBoyChill no... but confederate Americans aren't patriotic either. So its a good comparison
Nope. It's the losers flag.
Wearing it "with pride" is kind of a red flag to being trash, and a red neck.
You cannot "celebrate" a loss, unless you're a loser.
It can be, but it shouldn't be.
And Lincoln was Republican. Democrats were for slavery.
History is complicated
I think it's just a little bit of pride it has no value to any one out side the us other that a war and the south lost the sooner they take the loss and get on with helping the USA being great again the better to us outside,
No its just racists who still can’t reconcile with the fact that THEY LOST.
I just find it comical that self proclaimed “patriots” claim that a flag that represents treason against the country that they say they love is their “heritage”
Lincoln was the the treasonous rat. Ever heard of habias corpus?
Or even starting a war that killed 600k people over a constitutional right the founding fathers supported? (Yes they supported the rights of states to leave, and also slavery for that matter)
Yeah I’m not surprised you don’t like Lincoln
@SmokinAces2000 Exactly. I like George Washington. And he treated his slaves well
no, it's a flag meant to celebrate bigotry by traitors.
Yes it is. And don’t use the whole Swastika argument. Because no other flag exists to represent the American South, which is a culturally unique and distinct region.
It isn’t. As a matter of fact I hate our country based on how its currently set up
Exactly. The country doesn’t lean conservative enough
Im not racist
texas was not part of the 13 colonies so you shouldn't feel any affiliation
You guys threw propaganda around for centuries on how it was all about southern pride, don't bitch when you ex-electors buy it.
Do you understand a single thing about economy?
At the bottom line what matters is goods and services, money are just numbers on papers.
So I'm in favor of what people consent to, and makes sense to avoid overworking in order to maximize productivity. (specially since, the more complex the work, the more it depends on complex tools that wear out or could otherwise be better used.)
But do you understand that essentially people are paid for "productivity" through other people's "productivity"? Nobody in "paid vacations" is being paid to be on vacation, they just weren't paid it all before such vacations and/or won't receive it all latter.
Wanna know who paid for those vacations? Slave owners. Wanna know what was the product they were buying? An indoctrinated electorate.
No, depending on the job, mandatory guilds. Seriously, did you study any of this?
And actually, if I'm not mistaken, the US already started with anti-child labor laws, inherited from britain.
One of the funniest shit is how those laws came to be. Long story short, karens.
Which shows anything can have it's use.
It should only be regarded as a part of our history but not actually represent us because it makes no sense to as the confederate states are done.
For some people yea it can but that depends on where in the south
It is. And leave that girl alone. She has a right to wear whatever dress she wants.
I’m not a Southerner, but it certainly sounds like it to me.
I heard they ain't too keen on you livin there neither.
likely the cops doing the meth
you know cops, after all
It’s literally the confederate flags and the south was confederate so yea
Its racist flag
Racist pride, sure!
Its just a flag
The only opinion from girls was selected the Most Helpful Opinion, but you can still contribute by sharing an opinion!
You can also add your opinion below!