Who would you rather have a hour long ideological discussion with?

[Agape93]

3 vegans

2 jehovahs witnesses

A total of 43 votes were cast: 8 girls and 35 guys. See detailed results

[zeitgeist057]

I chose the vegans. I've already had multiple discussions with representatives from both of these ideologies. About half a dozen times I've invited the JW into my house when they knocked or chatted with them on the porch, for anywhere from 5 to 45 minutes. I know plenty of vegans and other variants (my mother was a lacto-ovo pescatarian), and even tried to go vegan once that lasted almost a week.

Some people think all vegans are judgmental asshats who treat carni/omnivores like cannibals, but that hasn't been my experience. I would say less than 10% of vegans are like that. Some might even start off like that, then realize after some feedback that's not going to fly if they want to get along in society. It's the same for pro-life advocates; some treat prochoice like babykillers, others learn to get along and have their views without being dicks about it.

[abc3643]

The vegans, of course! For two reasons:

1. I owned a 1972 Chevrolet Vega. It belonged to my uncle and he sold it to me for $400 when I was 18.
It looked like this:

2. Once you talk to Jehovah's Witnesses, they keep coming back to talk more. False religions are one of Satan's tools, you know.

[DarkCarousel]

For me, it’s not about either of us being right or wrong or arguing. I just want to know about the lives of others. We don’t always need to be right or force our beliefs on others, we can exist in hearing one another’s stories.

[DarkCarousel]

As soon as I finished writing that, I felt some regret. It can be painful when other peoples beliefs infringe upon or cast judgement to our own lifestyle. I fight that feeling often.

[zeitgeist057]

@DarkCarousel I feel you, and empathize. One thing that helps me is to remember that other people's perspectives come with a whole life of different experiences. The gangbanger vs. the CEO vs. the trailer park housewife vs. the indigenous tribesperson. The gangbanger for example is in a culture where machismo and violence are revered to establish hierarchy, the CEO from a different culture where the machismo and violence is more subtle and calculated.

When being "judged" by anyone, I just remember that they've had a totally different life, and so haven't likely come to the same conclusions and values I have.

I think you have a very healthy attitude, though. Gathering more information will only strengthen your ability to understand and encompass a broader spectrum of ideas. Open minded vs. close minded.

[SaartjieJane]

If it’s not an argument then vegans.
I’ve spoken with JW’s and they’re more often than not, pushing and don’t care what you say

[WindAtMyBack]

Jehovah's witnesses. I've never had a problem with them. They have always been polite, and when I told them I wasn't interested they didn't pursue it.

Vegans on the other hand tend to be fanatics. A lot of them treat meat eaters like murderers.

[Anpu23]

Depending on how snarky Im feeling it could go either way. I've been a vegetarian for 30 years so vegans wouldn't be too bad, but I've studied religion for many years and if Im in the mood JVH witnesses are themselves entertainmening. ("So your telling me you know the unpronounceable and secret name of God?")

[Waldoe]

Jehovah's witnesses are fun to talk to, vegans are Idiots... God created all, meat eaters are also hunters, their eyes are always facing Forward (Lions, Tiger, Men, Bears...) herbivores have eyes on the Side of their heads (Horses, deer, cows) they eat grasses and plants, they can look sideways to watch for Lions, men, and bears... Gods Plan... Get over it... you are NOT God

[FriendlyDrugDealer]

2 Jehovah witnesses because they are fun to troll. I used to switch languages in midst conversations and say something offensive but I knew they didn’t know and would still try to convert me week after week

[Effably]

While I might sooner support vegans than jehovas I'd rather discuss with the latter. They tend to be less militant and theology is more fun than dietary ethics to me.

[FilmGuy93]

The Jehovah's Witnesses. I don't know anything about their beliefs, so I would love to find out what they feel the tenants of their beliefs are.

[jshm2]

Your traumatised single parent and her sperm donor.

[TallAnon]

What an I gonna tell a vegan? I like meat and don't give a fuck. What happens the next 59.5 minutes? 😂

[zeitgeist057]

There's no discussion without listening and thinking, so if you're not into those two things, then there's no point.

[Varanus]

Don't worry, the vegans will fill the time, lol. I have never met more preachy, self-righteous, intolerant individuals than hardcore vegans, and that includes religious folk. The only thing close is crossfit enthusiasts.

[Pink2000]

3 vegans. I’m already a vegetarian and I have had enough with the Jehovahs witnesses..

[Deathraider]

I mean there are some chill vegans. I don’t think I’ve met Jehovah witnesses that were open to the possibility they could be wrong.

[Cubus]

I would actually discuss with Jehovas. I believe it would be interesting

[Jamie05rhs]

Omg- ideological? Neither!!

But I would love to discuss cooking with the vegans!

[Jamie05rhs]

Let me clarify: I don't mind discussing OTHER issues with the vegans, as long as it isn't "you shouldn't eat meat."

[zeitgeist057]

What if it wasn't a "what you should and shouldn't do" discussion, but rather a more respectful and civil discussion of their perspective, experiences, worldview, knowledge, motivations, and values? Where you were free to share your own in kind and discuss commonalities and divergences?

[Jamie05rhs]

@zeitgeist057 Nothing wrong with that.

[EnglishEuropean]

I'd rather Vegans. Vegans are just mistaken; Jehovah's Witnesses are delusional.

[Fineold22]

I'll say the two proselytizers because I'd rather argue with just two people than with three.

[Guy13]

Add an ANON and let’s call it a Panel Discussion…

[Smoke-n-Growls]

Can I put all five in a room and induce a debate?

[Massageman]

4 Great American Bagel bakers

[EmmaMary]

Phew Bloody Hell! 🤔

[GoodGuyBreakingBad]

3 vegans

[fonduegirl]

I'm kinda vegan so

[CubaPirate]

Non of the above

[Talkingtotheone]

nonn