Should trans men compete with women in sport?

[marish01]

Yes because trans women are still women

No. A person born with a penis is always a man

Updates

2 mo

Transwoman***

[McLlovin]

Women this is your fight, if you lose you will be marginalized out of sports. In the olympics you win money for winning gold… so imagine if me being a man wanted to get easy money and get gold medal for a certain sport. Essentially go and win easy cash. After that others will see it and do it too then it will turn into men vs men in women sports rarely ever seeing an actual woman winning women sport.


This will spill into more critical money grabbing situations like college sport grants or free ride to college for your athletic ability, stolen by a man. Then you will really start feeling the disadvantage and by that time it will be too late.

[McLlovin]

We as men can advocate but if you don’t complain the process will be that much slower and less important

[Soldieronmission1]

Soooo true and sad that not enough women are fighting to keep the status they are properly due. Too many people want to appease rather then say no.

[chrissykerdock]

its; a aa man regardless

[NaultD]

Let the sports committee figure out their own sport. This is why leagues exist. If it's extra ordinary stats, they can figure it out.

What are we even talking about, under 1000 trans athletes out of 10,000,000? With just probability, one may be possible notable outside of being trans. If it's a solo sport , even less being a team.

I kinda want what chess has been cooking. While it's been male dominant for hundreds of years it got stale. So it created a women's league that uped women active players to 15%. This movement alone rejuvenated chess as a whole made it better push more people and we can see fun stuff again.

Imagine if it was 50/50 male female and everything inbetween with a billion active players nothing could be assumed and it be a whole new game with nothing changing of the rules.

Same can be said with every sport.

[Jessica405]

I have said this before. If a man has a leg amputated, ne is still a man. If a man loses his penis because of penile cancer, he is still a man. So how can a man that volunteers to have his penis removed change into a woman? He may think he is, but that is just delusion.

[MsBell2018]

Respectfully, a man is always a man no matter how you change his appearance. Men are at least 1/3 bigger & stronger than women. If allowed to compete in women's sports, naturally, they'll do better.

[Create21]

Men are born with larger muscle fiber and that will always give them a competitive advantage when it comes to athletics. Someone born a man is just able to build up that much more muscle mass and quicker - that is science. It isn’t to say women can’t compete, but there is still a competitive advantage. If you want any type of measuring stick on this, just look at the women who competed for East Germany in the Olympics prior to 1990. Those women were so pumped full hormones and steroids that they looked like men, but it wasn’t natural.

[Drew-1990]

No they should not. I personally believe there are only two genders you are either male or female. But even then it's still wrong and unfair. A trans woman has all the male body advantages when it comes to speed and strength. You are making it impossible for an actual woman to win.

[loveslongnails]

You can personally believe anything you like, but science and data tell us that 1 in 1,000 births in the USA alone are intersexed people, and some studies put that number at 1 in 500 worldwide. Roughly 3,745,000 births occurred in the USA in 2023. That means 3,745 kids were NOT born strictly either male or female in the USA.

[Drew-1990]

@loveslongnails those instances are rare. In that case, they're physically born with both or neither parts. That is a completely different topic. That is not someone who says that they female, non-binary, or something else when they're born with male parts or vice versa.

[loveslongnails]

My comment about the sport competition is in my post. What I'm referring to is your comment about there being "only two genders". Rare or not, it invalidates that theory, and you have to deal with 3,785 folks born like that annually. (I'm not even getting into the whole "gender is a social construct issue! That's an entirely different subject! LOL)

Look at it this way; if the worldwide incidence is indeed 2%, then it's equally as rare as natural blondes or natural redheads. As to the whole binary discussion, 1 in 400 births occur where there's an extra or missing chromosome. I'm simply pointing out the science - you can do what you want with that part. I understand what you're talking about on the sports part.

[Drew-1990]

@loveslongnails I get what you're saying, I kind of agree and disagree with you on this. I'll give you this at least you're being respectful and not a complete jerk saying it's my way or the highway attitude. I still believe there's only two genders, I don't know how to word it to explain it. Cuz to be born with both chromosomes or an extra, I don't see it as a third gender per say. I agree this is not a social construct issue. And generally speaking when you're born with both chromosomes or some sort of extra, they usually, not always, have a surgery to remove the extra. These people obviously exist I am not in denial of that but I don't see that as a third gender, again I'm not quite sure how to word it to describe it

[loveslongnails]

Well thanks, and there is nothing to be gained by being a jerk about it, especially if one can just look at the science. At least you acknowledge there are the anomalies, and whether we call them a third gender, or however we name them, it's clear there's more than just "one or the other". You may or may not be surprised how many people refuse to recognize or accept that. For the time being they're called intersexed, but you could make an argument for that being a general term for a third, or more genders, dependent on each genetic anomaly. Fascinating stuff if you ask me.

[Drew-1990]

@loveslongnails I still wouldn't call it a third gender, as you put it they are anomalies, they are not the norm. The way I see it is they are both not something different because they have both "parts" or chromosomes. They are the only people in my opinion who have the right to choose one or the other one day when they are older and can choose for themselves. And many do end up picking one or the other and have a surgery to remove the other part that they choose not to be.

[loveslongnails]

That's an entirely different can of worms, and I'm not in a fishin' mood today. LOL

[Drew-1990]

@loveslongnails lol that is fine, I'm not here to argue. I'm just going to state my opinions. If we disagree we disagree.

[Summeroflove]

I think most people agree. Keep men out of women's sports. The same liberals love to talk about how your rights end where another’s begin. This is exactly right.


They are free to live how they want. But they aren’t entitled to force everyone else to go along witn it. Allowing men into womens sports and women’s bathrooms or vice versa.

[IceCreamSandwich]

Let the sports people who actually know how to make the rules make the rules. Like with that hormone test thing they do, or the chromosome test (although neither of those perfectly separates trans women from cis women).

It would be stupid to separate athletes by whether they're trans or not when you could way easier separate them by something actually measurable and relevant to the sport that everyone else is already measured on too.

[AlphaGhost]

LOL DNA does tell us everything about a person and that, Its CORRUPTION or error of the Meiosis and by the words of "EVOLUTION" annihilated from the gene pool, and hence that's why they are in-fertile and can't pass on their genes.
I support every right Trans people have and even go as far as to say, the very concept of their difference should be removed from workplace, education and all those important aspects of life BUT recently they have gone over board with their demands. Trans people should have their team and if their numbers are few, we can even join multiple countries in single team like African, Eu, Asian, American and Oceania team.
" you could way easier separate them by something actually measurable and relevant to the sport that everyone else is already measured on too."
for this to happen, you have to define term "Woman" and "Man" and then use scientific data, which states Men are stronger than woman in every physical attribute and FEMINAZI's will never let it slide.

[IceCreamSandwich]

@AlphaGhost what? Trans people aren't infertile. Who told you that? And they aready have been competing in sports, and trans women haven't "dominated" women's sports, and trans men haven't been "dominated" in men's sports. I know that depending on how and when a person transitions there will be physical differences that can give an advantage in sports, but just being trans by itself isn't an advantage. Just being a man or a woman by itself isn't an advantage. It's just the physical differences between the average man and woman that can be an advantage. That's why you don't have to define gender for sports, you just have to use something measurable that's usually different for men and women and actually effects sports performance, like hormone levels.

[AlphaGhost]

Trans man are dominating woman sports bro wake up.

[IceCreamSandwich]

@AlphaGhost trans men wouldn't even be in women's sports if it wasn't for people like you making the rules. You obviously don't know what you're talking about.

[AlphaGhost]

Yeah me the M-Phil Doc don't know what I am talking about, when I say that "men are stronger than woman according to Medical science and every other known science known to mankind" and genders are defined by DNA and birth.
I would listen to online idiot like you... really !
Grow the F up, Leftist trash like you is responsible for current trash, any grown biological man can sexually identify as woman and participate in their sports. I even know 2 pedophiles, who sexually identified as teenager girls and the MFO authorities put him in teenage female jail. Rapist even identify as woman and they put them with other woman. You guys have made mockery of Medical science and fight for woman rights, when you can't even define woman/womanhood !
No intersex person should ever be allowed to participate in either man or woman sports, we can make their own special trans category. If we place them in woman sports, it puts woman at disadvantage and if we put them in man category, its unfair to them cuz apart from current muscle mass, testosterone is a growth hormone... which gives benefits like higher cardio during the sport.
So the fairest deal for every party is to make new category, Male sports, female sports and intersex sports... I bet they will have higher viewership than woman sports.

[IceCreamSandwich]

@AlphaGhost okay. Have a nice day.

[Berethor]

Should not write so fast, no transmen, anyway transwomen are men, not women.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgender_people_in_sports#Testosterone,_athletic_ability_and_injury_risks

[abc3643]

I think you mean "trans woman" as in M2F.

Well, I think South Park has the answer for this...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=URz-RYEOaig

[RavVid]

Back with the USSR it was called cheating and girls had to be XX's. Whats changed?

What's the point of Lia ranking #1 in women's if she can't compete.

She should the proud possessor of Double X's to compete in women's swimming.

We have the nonsense that girls can outfight men and men can transition into women.

The US should not inflict this nonsense on the rest of the world.

[JacobJordan]

Women should compete in women's sports. Men should compete in men's sports. Trans people can either compete in the correct sport for their gender (trans women in men's sports, trans men in women's sports) or they can compete in zero sports. I have 2 daughters and a son and I would not allow or be okay with a trans perv being in the same bathroom, locker room, sports team etc. They are welcome to be trans somewhere where it doesn't effect my children or my family.

[Dutchgirl97]

The best way to solve this “dilemma” (which is complete nonsense that it even IS one) is to have a trans specific sport group. Trans go up against trans.

[Billlewis]

Yes, ma'am, I just started following you and I'd like to invite you to follow me as well if you want. Thank you very much.

[MrOracle]

That's not what they want - they would quit and the league would dissolve. It's the same reason why "transmen" don't compete in male sports - AT ALL, EVER, even though they could.

The only reason "transwomen" want to compete in female sports is because they have a huge unfair advantage and can dominate the sport - at the expense of the female athletes that already have a hard time as it is.

[Dutchgirl97]

@MrOracle sometimes I feel like they just want to be validated and boost their egos to play in a league they know they will genetically have an advantage on.

[Anonymous]

Yes! Absolutely. This is all being done by the Marxist woke. Let the women with dicks show up for the swimming event. Let the world watch while all of the real women turn and leave the building. This retarded shit would end tomorrow if women stop showing up at the pool.

[DARKCLOUD1945X]

That is the best idea yet!!! That should happen at every event in every sport. A DN test should be given before each meet or event in front of witness. If you test male DNA no matter if you look female, you compete against male and vice versa. and chimeras and other anomalies need to be classified also as to what they can compete in

[Opinion Owner]

@DARKCLOUD1945X
Thanks for the reply. I see that the owner of the question couldn't be bothered by replying to the people who responded to the question.

This site is home to the most dysfunctional people on the planet.

[DARKCLOUD1945X]

Did you notice that big bulge at the bottom of the trans bathing suit? I GUESS THAT IS WHERE HE KEEPS HIS DRY SOX LMFAO!!!

[Wraith_Cemetery]

It's women's fault this has been happening in the first place. They're the main ones that support this nonsense.

Fortunately, many have finally stood up against it and are quitting participating if there's a transgender competing.

[Opinion Owner]

@Wraith_Cemetery
I think it was Germany that had a swimming event, and they created a special class for the trannies.

Not ONE tranny would compete against other trannies.

[HawkPerception]

This is a very obvious "NO". Clearly it's not obvious for a lot of people with mental illnesses though. There's a reason sports are divided into weight classes, age groups, and sexes. Because there's a significant difference between each to create an unfair advantage.

[DARKCLOUD1945X]

Transman is still a male no matter how many Breasts he grows no matter how many Vulvas he has put on his body no matter how many shots he has to alter his body UNTIL YOU CHANGE EVERY BIT OF DNA TO FEMALE, HE IS STILL A MALE. Bigger and stronger and should never ever compete against real woman for any perceived reason.

[NobodyXox]

Maybe learn the correct terms first before judging? 😂 Because you are now a accidental ally while I know this question is trying to be transphobic.
Transwomen are women ans transmen are men 🏳️‍🌈 Good job 👏

[marish01]

If I were an ally I would know the right term.
So don't dream about me being an ally

[tiajoka]

You're right, *men is what OP should've said.

[loveslongnails]

In my opinion, if you're trans in either direction, you should have to be on a certain level of hormones for at least 3 - 5 years, not 1 year, like the current requirements for international competition. When you're on hormones for that long, your body definitely changes.

[Smashingdoozy]

Yeah everyone should be allowed to take physical enhancements to level out the playing field. That way it would actually be fair. Because as is even on 100% Biologically male or female sports there is already genetic unfairness.

[Shgshshdg]

It seems like you were suppose to write trans woman in the question title.

Trans women are male by birth.
Trans men are born female.

[Shgshshdg]

but anyway no. Many people including me don’t believe people born male and trans women should be in women’s sports

[godfatherfan]

NO. Never under any circumstances. A man has a different muscle structure. It will never be the same or equal. That doesn't mean women can't beat men in whatever it might be. But the guy is going to have the edge.

[OlderAndWiser]

Only a cult follower/useful idiot/devotee of woke culture would think that having boys compete with girls is a good idea.

[NobodyXox]

You have it the other way around my dude.
Should transmen (born with a vagina, now on testosterone) compete with biological women. That is the question.
Does the testosterone they take change the rules while they are born as women.

[OlderAndWiser]

@NobodyXox Is testosterone considered to be a performance-enhancing drug?

[OlderAndWiser]

@NobodyXox You read the question incorrectly. It was ambiguous and the Asker clarified that with an update.

[soulOnDisplay]

@nobodyxoxx Probably, since transmen, or should I say NOT-men, could very well be on HRT.

[stark04]

Big fat fucking NO.

Let us all Bring back president Trump and he'll take care of these mentally ill people who thinks they're failure as male so change your gender and become successful as female.

[EmyyWolf]

ABSOLUTELY NOT!

THATS CHEATING!
🤬🤬🤬🤬