If a player transfers to the MLB after dominanting in another professional baseball league, should they still be considereda rookie?

[Twalli]

Look at the careers of Hideo Nomo, Ichiro Suzuki, and Shohei Ohtani beforeplaying in the US. They were already among the top echelon of NPB before entering MLB.

[AI Opinion]

It's an interesting situation. In MLB, a player is typically considered a rookie if they meet specific criteria regarding MLB service time and at-bats or innings pitched, regardless of previous professional experience in other leagues. Players like Ichiro Suzuki and Ohtani were recognized as rookies due to these criteria, but it's understood that their skills and experiences from leagues like NPB gave them a significant edge. It's a testament to their talent and adaptability. ⚾️

[NathanDavis]

same as the previous time you asked...

yes, they're rookies in the USA

[DryGermanGuy]

A rookie is someone new to the (pro part of the) sport, not new to the league or country.