I think it depends more on you then guys. ie) are you fine with having less guys approach you, but the guys that do approach are generally more interesting and genuine. Also, some will assume you are gay (or at least question it).
I will tell you this, it is all about confidence, if you style it and rock it and walk proudly you will look great! If you have a low self-esteem view of the cut it will most likely not look good. This you have to have the right face shape crap is BS, it's all about confidence, it doesn't matter your face-shape or weight.
My general idea with it is that it looks good on some people, because they have the face to pull it off... But for the people who have the face to pull it off, chances are they could pull off most haircuts.
For me personally, while it does look alright on select people, it doesn't particularly help anyone. (It's like tattoos in that sense imo). I'm much more of a fan of longer hair. Medium hair is good too. Short hair like a pixie cut? Ehh not so much.
I've never seen girl who I look at and go "wow, they'd look a lot better with a pixie cut" or even "wow that is an awesome pixie cut." I have seen people and gone "wow they have some beautiful long hair" though.
TL;DR; I voted B. It doesn't look good on the vast majority of people in my opinion.
I don't really like it if i'm honest, its very masculine looking if i'm honest. I think it's a look that only a number of women can pull off but you could be one of them. Give it a try if it's what you want and if you don't like it then youlll know not to do it again 😕. It's hard to know if it'll suit you or not until you've actually tried it.
Pixie cut is one of the worst things a girl can do to her overall appearance in my opinion. If a girl wants to gurantee that I don't find her pretty a pixie cut is the way to go. It's just never the way a girl looks her best. Hope you reconsider!
My husband would approve. He LOVES short hair on women, and makes the (entirely valid) point that a beautiful face looks all that much more beautiful with less hair to get in the way of the side profile.
Also, short hair exposes the back of yr neck and shoulders, which is super erotic. A lot of boys LOVE this... and aren't even aware that they do, until they find themselves in a relationship (or other romantic entanglement) with a short-haired girl. Then they get used to coming up to that girl from behind and kissing the back of her neck... and it's ON. <3
* The ModiFace phone app can give you a VERY realistic idea of what certain haircuts will look like on you. One of my oldest son's (female) friends posted some ModiFace versions of herself to Instagram, and lots of people legitimately thought she'd gotten her hair chopped ahah
* You can also get a short-hair wig, and wear it for a few days, and see if the style "becomes" you.
Personally, I feel like very few women can pull off hair that short and most men I know prefer longer hair on women for a variety of reasons. That being said, I'm sure there are some men who either like it or would feel indifferent to it. Ultimately though, it's your hair and you should do what YOU want regardless of what anyone else says/thinks.
I don't particularly like it on girls who are able to grow their hair out. People with sweet faces or daring personalities may pull it off, but even then I prefer longer hair looks. I think black women and middle aged women are an exception when it comes to boy-short hair except pixy cuts.