If Every MLB Team Was a Movie...

If Every MLB Team Was a Movie...On March 29th, 2018, the 150th Major League Baseball season began here in North America! For the United States of America, it has been known as America's "greatest passtime."

Instead of making analytical predictions like I've been doing the past two years on here (that nobody on GAG seems to care about), I'm going to have a little bit of fun here.

From a historical standpoint, I'm going to compare a fairly well-known motion (from a United States perspective) to the current 30 MLB franchises (and how they were viewed in their history). This comparison will be based on the popularity between the movies, how well they did/do, and their most famous actors/actresses/athletes, and finally, their history. So, let's begin.

New York Yankees (Titanic-1997)

The Yankees are one the most popular teams in the league, have grossed more money than any other team in franchise history, and everyone seems to overrate them every year, and you're sick of it being rubbed in your face. Sound familiar?

If Every MLB Team Was a Movie...

Boston Red Sox (Forrest Gump-1994)

There are two people in the world: People who think Titanic was the best movie in the 1990's, and people who think Forrest Gump was the best 90's movie instead. This is the Red Sox/Yankees rivalry in a nutshell.

Toronto Blue Jays (Monty Python and the Holy Grail-1975)

Monty Python and the Holy Grail is one of those movies that every America wants to hate, just because it's foreign, but other than that, we have no legitimate reason to disdain the movie. The Blue Jays get the same treatment in the MLB. Poor Jays :(

Baltimore Orioles (Romeo and Juliet-1996)

Let me guess, you didn't know about this 1990's remake starring Leonardo DiCaprio? Or maybe you "barely" heard of it? Why is this? Because it came out in the wrong decade, since every other legendary movie came out in the nineties! This is unfortunately the same case with the Orioles. It's not that they're bad-they're just in the AL East.

Tampa Bay Rays (Wall-E-2008)

This is one of those Pixar movies that people really only cared about in 2008, when it was released. Similar to how people only cared about the Rays when they made the World Series, in 2008.

Cleveland Indians (Major League-1989)

Sorry Indians fans, but I couldn't resist. The movie is literally about how pathetic the Cleveland Indians' success has been in their franchise history, and how they will never win a World Series again. The sad thing is, this is alarmingly accurate in real life.

If Every MLB Team Was a Movie...

Minnesota Twins (Cool Runnings-1993)

The movie is about a Jamaican quartet who wants to race in a bobsled race, despite never seeing any snow. The Minnesota Twins are about an MLB team wanting to play in the Summer time, despite being located in Minnesota.

Chicago White Sox (Antz-1998)

Wouldn't you all agree that the movie Antz is completely overshadowed by the movie, A Bug's Life? Ask White Sox fans how they feel about the Cubs.

Kansas City Royals (The Poltergeist-1982)

After the peak success of this movie, most of the cast began dying off in unfortunate events. After the Royals won the World Series in 2015, they've had their atrocious luck as well, including an actual death from their former Ace Pitcher.

Detroit Tigers (8 Mile-2002)

A movie about how disgusting urban Detroit life is, from a rapper's point of view. The Tigers are a similar deal, minus the rapper.

Houston Astros (The Hangover-2009)

Many people don't know this, but The Hangover triology is one of the most surprising trilogies of all time. Nobody thought the movie would do as good as they did. How many people thought this about the Astros after 2014?

If Every MLB Team Was a Movie...

Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim (Man Trouble-1992)

This movie(which you've probably never heard of) is widely regarded as one of the worst romantic comedies of all time, yet, it starred one of the greatest actors of all time-Jack Nicholson. Please, Google Mike Trout, and the Angels.

Seattle Mariners (Grown Ups-2010)

Probably the biggest bust of the 2010's decade. The same way people need to quit hyping the Seattle Mariners every year this decade. They aren't going anywhere, and never will.

Texas Rangers (Once Upon a Time in America-1984)

You probably heard of it, you probably liked it, but would you believe it has never won an Oscar before? If this doesn't sound like the Rangers, I don't know what does.

Oakland Athletics (Space Jam-1996)

This one needs some 'splaining to do. The movie showcases Michael Jordan's basketball skills, and makes a mockery of his baseball skills in an exciting cartoon/real life blend. In real life(with no cartoons), the Golden State Warriors in the NBA seem to be making a mockery of their MLB counterparts, which is the Athletics(who can barely draw fans anyway). Do you see the connection now?

Washington Nationals (The Thing-1982)

This is known was one of the greatest movie remakes of all time, as it improved on almost everything from the original movie. The Washington Nationals are the same franchise as the Montreal Expos-And they are a big improvement of their original product.

Atlanta Braves (The Natural-1984)

The movie focuses on a guy who is naturally great at baseball, despite not having much experience. I think that will be the tall tale of the Atlanta Braves in 2018!

New York Mets (Ghosts of the Abyss-2003)

It's not that the movie is particularly bad...it's just seen as a generic version of Titanic. Guess where I'm going with here?

Philadelphia Phillies (The Waterboy-2001)

The Adam Sandler classic showcases a team who finally wins a title, and then we have the classic tagline by Rob Schneider, "Oh no, we suck again!" We hear you Phillies fans...

Miami Marlins (Scavenger Hunt-1979)

The movie has some of the most famous actors of all time, and was even critically acclaimed. It doesn't matter, because nobody cares about the movie, nobody watches it anymore, and barely anyone even knows about it anymore. For the record, the Marlins are lucky to sell out on their Home Opener.

Chicago Cubs (Back to the Future-1985)

In the movie, the main character traveled to the future to find out the Cubs finally broke their "curse", and won the World Series in 2015. They were so damn close! The Cubs won in 2016. And that is my sole reason for choosing this movie to represent the Cubbies!

If Every MLB Team Was a Movie...

St. Louis Cardinals (The Longest Yard. Either version: 1974, or 2005)

The movie forces you to hate the law abiding guards because they're arrogant, and they're elite as a football team. I'm a Reds fan, so don't even try to refute this one.

Milwaukee Brewers (The Shawshank Redemption-1994)

Can you believe this movie never won an Oscar award? Brewers fans can't believe it either. Trust them.

Pittsburgh Pirates (Black Sheep-1996)

The movie stars as a man who is a complete black sheep in his own family. The Pirates star as a professional sports team who are a complete black sheep in their own family.

Cincinnati Reds (Roundhay Garden Scene-1888)

That's not a typo by the way. Even as a Reds fan, this isn't going to be too fun for me anyway. The Reds were the first professional sports team in North American history, and Roundhay Garden Scene is the oldest surviving film of all time.

If Every MLB Team Was a Movie...

Los Angeles Dodgers (E.T. The Extra Terrestrial-1982)

This movie might have been the greatest 1980's movie, and makes you nostalgic for the 80's, but attention Dodgers fans: It's not the 1980's anymore. Get over it.

If Every MLB Team Was a Movie...

Arizona Diamondbacks (Stars Wars: The Force Awakens-2015)

Fun fact: This movie was the fastest grossing movie to 50 million dollars in cinema history. Similarly, out of every North American team in professional sports history, the Diamondbacks were the fastest team to a championship title, in only four seasons.

San Francisco Giants (Dazed and Confused-1993)

You know that movie that did very well, and everybody likes, but you can' seem to figure out why? Well, get ready MLB fans, because the Giants are playing in an even-numbered year again.

Colorado Rockies (Miracle-2004)

A movie about a hockey team, which is the premier sport for Colorado! I just need to remind Rockies fans that they waste their time every year.

San Diego Padres (Sharknado-2013)

This movie is so bad, it's actually enjoyable, and even it's fans make fun of it. Really, the entire history of the movie series is the same way.

EnglishArtsteacher is a GirlsAskGuys Editor
Who are Editors?

Most Helpful Girl

  • ❤️⚾️❤️


Most Helpful Guy

  • I've had full season tickets for the New York Yankees since 1998. In the last 20 years, I've seen a lot of winning... and too many heartbreaking moments... all in person. However, this Titanic comparison is totally inaccurate. Since becoming a MLB franchise in 1903, the Yankees won it all 27 times, been in the World Series 40 times, and just last year, were totally underrated as they wound up just one win away from playing in yet another World Series. This season (year 116) should be awesome... if they stay healthy. Not bad for 115 years of baseball.

    • Did you even read the explanation for I picked them as a "Titanic" comparison?

    • Show All
    • I never said the Titanic sinking in the movie was an accurate representation of the Yankees. I also never said that there were only two good movies in the 1990's (as a matter of fact, that decade had some of the best movies of all time released).

      This list isn't meant to be taken 100 percent literal. Not every aspect of the movies on this list accurately represent every aspect for every single team's list.

    • Okay fair enough. Good luck with the Reds this season.

Recommended myTakes


Join the discussion

What Girls Said 11

What Guys Said 20

  • Hey hey hey bruh. Were we not just in the World Series last year?

  • This is gold. I'm new to the US, so I now feel I've caught up on a few years of baseball history. Thanks!

  • Upvote for your reasoning behind what you picked for the Cincinnati Reds.

  • That always amazed me how close Back To Future was at predicting the Cubbies winning a World Series

    • Yes!

      They also predicted the Florida Marlins World Series win in 1997-And that was before Florida even had an MLB team.

    • Show All
    • They said "Look, Florida won the World Series in 1997", and I guess they were baffled (since no Florida team existed back then).

      It's so eerie how accurate their predictions are.

    • Yeah true, I’ll have to watch out for it next time I watch it

  • There are two people in the world: People who think Titanic was the best movie in the 1990's, and people who think Forrest Gump was the best 90's movie instead. This is the Red Sox/Yankees rivalry in a nutshell.
    Just what?
    Neither are anywhere close to the besr movie of the 90s,
    You got saving private ryan, pulp fiction, Jurassic park,

    • I actually think "Forrest Gump" is the best 1990's movie, but of course, it's entirely opinion. However, even if you don't think either one of those movies are the best 90's movie (for the record, I think "Titanic" is the most overrated movie of all time), they were both widely regarded as the best in that decade, and had some form of a "rivalry" going on.

      Some people are taking this Mytake too literal.

    • Show All
    • Then you NEED to,

  • As a Yankees fan, I really don't any comparison to the Titanic, but this was an entertaining Take-thanks!

    • Already, allow me to elaborate on this more.

      Again, as I already said, "Titanic" was not only the highest grossing movie in the 1990's, but one of the highest grossing films of all time. It's also thrown in people's faces, as in some sort of arrogance.

      It's basically the fact people get so sick of hearing about the Yankees every year.

    • Understood, I just was poking fun at the idea of a "sinking ship".

  • Baseball is so lame and boring, even Futurama had problem making it fun

  • That is a cool perspective. I still remember that epic 2016 class as it was Rookie of the Year versus Major League, 1908 vs 1948, the 2 longest droughts at the time in baseball. It had to go 7 games. It had to end with each team scoring exactly 27 runs. It had to be tied up in the bottom of the 8th inning by Rajai Davis hitting a homerun. It had to go extra innings and it had to be a 17 minute rain delay to regroup the Cubs,. It had to be the Cubs winning on the 108th year after 1908 because there were no more stitches to attach as a baseball has 108 stitches. Amazing, isn't it.

    It almost feels like it was destined and determined and couldn't be avoided and rewritten another way.

    • Dude, I thought the same thing. I literally felt like I was watching a movie. I personally think that's the best World Series I can remember in my life-as a matter of fact, it's possibly the best World Series of ALL TIME.

      I'm a Cincinnati Reds fan, and even though the Cubs are in our division, I was so happy to see the Cubs break the epic drought.

    • Show All
    • Trailed by 2 runs twice and both ti9mes 1 out from elimination and 1 time was 1 strike from elimination when trailing by 2.

    • Yes, I'm aware of that. And then the Cardinals go ahead, and trade David Freese later on... lol.

      Also, remember the 2012 National League Division Series against the Nationals? Besides the fact the Cardinals were trailing the entire time in Game Five-AGAIN-the Cardinals were down to their LAST Strike trailing two Runs, and that bizarre Double happened, and then a surprise rally.

      In a two season span, the Cardinals were down to their last STRIKE THREE times (almost eliminated from the postseason), and came back, and won.

  • Nice take.

  • Intriguing myTake.

  • Show more from Guys

Recommended Questions