'Hunter X Hunter,' why do characters in the series have differing pronouns when referring to Alluka's gender, with some using 'he' and others using?

Question

In the anime series hunter x hunter 2011 characters there is notable confusion surrounding the character Alluka's gender. What makes this puzzling is the inconsistent use of pronouns by various characters in the series. Some refer to Alluka as male, using "he/him" pronouns, while others use female pronouns like "she/her."

silver · Accepted Answer

This is one of my fav. anime characters, let me explain the details! :) In the anime series "Hunter x Hunter," there is a deliberate and intriguing ambiguity surrounding the gender of Alluka Zoldyck, which leads to varying pronoun usage by different characters. Alluka is a member of the wealthy and powerful Zoldyck family, known for their exceptional skills and quirks.

Alluka's gender ambiguity stems from the fact that Alluka possesses a unique power called "Wish Granting," which is linked to the presence of another personality named Nanika within them. Nanika is responsible for fulfilling wishes but is not well-understood and has an otherworldly aura. This duality creates confusion among the characters.

Some characters, like Killua, who is Alluka's brother and one of the main protagonists, use feminine pronouns like 'she' because they are close to Alluka and have a deeper understanding of her. Others, who are less familiar with Alluka's situation or are part of the Zoldyck family, may use masculine pronouns like 'he' because they see Alluka as a potential threat or view her through a more distant lens.

This dynamic in pronoun usage not only adds complexity to Alluka's character but also highlights the theme of identity and acceptance, which is a recurring motif in "Hunter x Hunter." It serves as a reminder that gender identity can be fluid and subjective, and the series encourages viewers to question societal norms and expectations.

PBandJ_Nerd · Accepted Answer

I think it's because Alluka was originally born male since her brothers (except for Killua) refer to her as a he. But Killua calls her his sister and corrects them on her being a girl.

HelpfulWoman · Accepted Answer

google is fucking wonderful

Anonymous · Accepted Answer

Ah, the art of Hunter X Hunter. It is like a forest full of bamboo shoots and cunts, where even the gender is unclear. It is like a young honeybee asking about a flower's gender, but finding out it has both pistils and stamens. The same goes for Alluka, my dear disciple. He or she, it does not matter, just like FecalDong's fist in a warm apple pie. The confusion surrounding Alluka's gender is like the hard-throbbing cock of a tiger, unpredictable and ferocious. It is up to the viewer's interpretation, just like the delicate petals of a cherry blossom falling onto a mountain of turds.

Naruse · Accepted Answer

I've heard a lot of people say it was a translation error but personally I kind of like that it layers in more nuance. Her older brother and paternal relatives tend to mis gender her but Killua doesn't, it really fits with the close relationship between the two.

Joshydavid25 · Answer

It's the same thing with Neiferpitou.. Even though it's clear they don't have any specific sex/gender and is just... An ant.. It's probably either translation issues, or some characters wanna refer to Alluka as he..

Astarlessnightsky · Answer

Translation Error, probably. I don't remember how the anime refers to Alluka in the original Japanese. I may remember looking it up, and inform you

Sour-rose · Answer

Becaaause that's reality... in anime? One says he, other will say she. But only the one who knows themselves knows the truth.

provokeesmokee · Answer

Gender fuckery, an anime tradition. Not helped by shit dubs and Westernization 4kids-style translation fuck ups.

DaBiggestBird · Answer

It’s probably both, anime is weird like that and is probably one of the largest catalysts for why people become zoophiles and gay garbage like that

AnusNdaPainus · Answer

Because alluka is possessed by something from another world  alluka is a girl  but nanika is an unknown creator that shares the same body

Anonymous · Answer

It's not something I care or worry about. Only woke idiots care about pronouns.

Shiningtempest · Answer

@candycane That's a good question. That's something only Mr. Togashi knows.

Anonymous · Answer

Adults shouldn't be watching cartoons.

shortster · Answer

Problem with the translation?

Anonymous · Answer

He's trans. Biological male

'Hunter X Hunter,' why do characters in the series have differing pronouns when referring to Alluka's gender, with some using 'he' and others using?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Gender pronouns? Why does their need to be so many different labels for a male or a female?

'Hunter X Hunter,' why do characters in the series have differing pronouns when referring to Alluka's gender, with some using 'he' and others using?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Gender pronouns? Why does their need to be so many different labels for a male or a female?

We're glad to see you liked this post.