What makes a guy with a "player" reputation want to settle down? What makes one girl stand out from the rest?

Anonymous
When I became interested in my now boyfriend of 1 year (we're both in our mid 20's), all the girls I talked to told me not to waste my time. They said he was a player, would never actually care about me, and that I would end up getting hurt. He's had a reputation, and I knew about it, but I went for it anyway because I really liked him- and found him EXTREMELY attractive.

It took some time and patience, but he eventually opened up to me and one day he finally called me his girlfriend. We've been happily living together for a few months now, and he talks about our future together. I keep thinking about what my friends told me about him, and I just can't wrap my head around why he chose me (a pretty average looking girl with a bit of an attitude), over all the other beauties out there. He's been single for a few years and never got serious with anyone until me.

So what I'm curious to know is, in your guys's opinions, what qualities make a girl worth settling down for?
What makes a guy with a "player" reputation want to settle down? What makes one girl stand out from the rest?
12 Opinion