What do you think?
What are your thoughts on the fat acceptance movement? Or the normalization of fat people in America?
What do you think?
I've only been to the US a couple of times, but from movies and friends I've met over the years, it seems to me American people are actually very confident overall. I mean, fat or thin, most of them still wear the shorts they want and go out and about not really caring much about what other people may think.
At the same time, there's this obsession lately with looking sexy and caring about how you look which is kinda bizarre because basically everyone and even the biggest people still feel sexy. Again, amazing confidence levels overall, lol.
Anyone that goes to the US from anywhere in the world is shocked with the size of the portions at the restaurants and the amount of oil and cheese used. And the soda you can refill anywhere? It's probably pretty easy gaining weight unless you are very strict with yourself, were carefully brought up and really like going to the gym or have a great metabolism.
But anyway, at the same time, if people were more considerate about others feelings there probably wouldn't be a need for a fat acceptance movement. First, because there wouldn't be that many fat people occupying 2 seats everywhere (if there were equality, some people would actually pay for 2 seats on an airplane, no?) and the remaining fat people who can't avoid it for medical conditions or something else, wouldn't need to fight for dignity and respect.
Good points
On my other site we had a debate about this "Founded in 1969, NAAFA is a non-profit civil rights organization dedicated to ending size discrimination in all of its forms. NAAFA's goal is to help build a society in which people of every size are accepted with dignity and equality in all aspects of life. NAAFA will pursue this goal through advocacy, public education, and support."https://www.naafaonline.com/dev2/
There is absolutely nothing wrong with this movement.
There is a difference between ending size discrimination and misinformation like the fat-kini people put out there. The idea that looking at someone doesn't indicate health in the slightest is bullshit. The talking head of different fat acceptance movements LOVE to shame fit people too. Some notable fitness names have been in the news for this.
Also, I appreciate the link. I will admit that I am ignorant to specific cases/rulings on fat persons being discriminated against. Is there any out there? Not to say I am naive to the fact that this happens. But what are the forms of discrimination that they are used to seeing. Because the talking heads love to say that they want to be represented in pop culture, tv, ads, even fitness...
Yeah, I'll just post what I posted on my other site haha.
https://www.cswd.org/docs/faq.html
www.aarp.org/.../...scrimination-in-workplace.html
listverse.com/.../
www.universityherald.com/.../...erweight-obese.htm
business.time.com/.../
& I'll repost this also
About the whole not supporting it because it's "unhealthy"..
Should those who are overweight and unhealthy feel like they are the scum of the earth just because they aren't as healthy as you think they should be?
There are plenty of skinny and average sized people who aren't anywhere near as healthy as they should be, yet they don't get treated the same way as those who are fat AND unhealthy.
As previous posts have mentioned there are those who are overweight who have diseases.
Those who are discriminated against could already be living a healthy lifestyle or have recently just started, but a stranger walking down the street wouldn't know that and would proabbly still assume that, that person doesn't take care of themself. Even those who ARE fat AND have unhealthy eating habits, since they are fat and don't have good eating habits it's okay for people to treat them like crap?
There is nothing wrong with expecting to be treated like everybody else when your fat.
Whether it's because you have some disease, or just don't eat healthy.
No matter what the reason is for that person being fat it doesn't justify society treating them like shit.
^^ My whole feelings on the subject.
Good links. Definitely not right to discriminate like that. Just can't happen. Health is so important though and I hope that fitness and health doesn't get drowned out by any of these positive aimed movement.
Bitte schön
I live in the US but am not American and frequently visit my country. I've seen plenty of people being stressed out about their weight over there. And then they work it off and they look great and gain a good attitude. I'd rather people feel a little crappy over being obese if it makes them no longer be obese, than die young because everyone told them they were so beautiful, something that not many truly ever buy anyway.
@Alkan
www.universityherald.com/.../...erweight-obese.htm
"The data also revealed that participants who were criticized because of their weight 'were two and a half times more likely to have become obese' than those who were not weight discriminated.
Overweight people, who were poked fun at for their size, were three times likely to remain obese.
'There is a difference between fighting obesity and discriminating against individuals who are obese. It is counterproductive if the campaign is aimed at shaming and blaming the individual. It is possible to promote a healthy lifestyle without being stigmatising,'"
I think the movement is important, because of our level of ignorance. We are now finding even the level of bacteria in the body can cause obesity. So the idea that fat people are horrible people is really one based on ignorance. The truth is people are fat for a number of different reasons, and simply blaming it on sloth and gluttony isn't fair.
Obesity wasn't a major issue until the government started telling people how to eat. Clearly people's bodies aren't reacting the same way to the foods, and chemicals that we are all exposed to. I think healthy lifestyles should be encouraged, but lately there has been a movement to make it acceptable to discriminate against fat people that I don't agree with.
Incorrect sir.
All of that, not correct. I am sorry but the government telling people what to eat? Really? Which presidency? When did this start? Specific programs... Roosevelt's? He had one? Although, children had almost ZERO diabetes back then.
Come on man. Have you seen what the food industry is like. Do you see kids playing in the street like you did when you were a child? Everything around us promotes a sedentary lifestyle from the youngest of ages. From reality TV to couch jockeys...
You are at a disconnect with a lot of what causes this problem.
By the way 2/3 of the population in the united states is fat. They are the majority not minority. Yeah... maybe at fucking USC with all that hottness you won't fit in... let's be real here man. Have you been to a sporting event? Have you walked around the mall? How is it possible they feel discriminated against.
The government came out with the food pyramid and preached the dangers of healthy fats to the entire country. America actually did change their eating habits closer to what the government had recommended, and we got fatter.
I would agree that the government is of course behind this in some way shape or form. They are in bed with companies like Coca cola, monsanto, etc... but people got fat because of the difference in serving sizes (perpetuated by major food chains) fast food chains, and lack of active lifestyles.
Speak with anyone over 50. They will tell you have life was different for everyone when it came to activity and gluttony. People ate less sugar and processed foods. People cared about being fit... Gym was a requirement (and they actually worked out)
People actually aren't eating that many more calories from larger serving sizes. It has more to do with all the snacking they do in between meals. As for children playing outside, people are too overprotective of kids. In many places it is actually illegal for the children to even walk home. Again the government gets in the way. Once a person develops an eating disorder they have it for life. A child raised where food is shoved in their face to keep them from talking, will most likely end up with an eating disorder for the rest of their lives. My point is that there are MANY reasons that a person can be fat that have nothing to do with them being a bad person.
Yeah, I wouldn't say they are bad persons. All of what you said is true. Although, the fat movements are NOT speaking on them. Only the concerned and seemingly fit. There is a lot of misinformation out there about health and the causes of obesity. Like the fact that food addiction can be turned around.
By what little I have seen they just don't want to be made fun of. I am sure like any group there are extremists in the group, but I don't think they will gain enough steam to cause harm.
What we really need is better science and for the government to stop going out of its way to support unhealthy living. They could stop subsidizing high fructose corn syrup for a start, which keeps sugary foods cheaper than they should be.
So-called fat acceptance is a manifestation of the absurdist thinking of the looney left.
People are fat because they lack self disciple and are lazy. Nobody forces the food into their mouth and nobody prevents them going for a walk, or doing whatever else is necessary to maintain a reasonable level of fitness.
I have fought all my life to maintain a healthy weight, so to the delusional morons who bleat about fat acceptance I say: you are a delusional, lazy, stupid, pig who needs to get off their cellulite-ridden arse and do something about it.
Fat acceptance involves: diabetes acceptance (with the attendant kidney failure, liver failure, blindness and amputations) and heart disease acceptance.
It takes constant hard work and dedication for 95% of fit healthy people. I would agree that many fat people are just too lazy, scared, and lack self discipline
Opinion
13Opinion
I think that people shouldn't quantify their self worth based on their weight. Or anything else appearance related. Which is kinda the idea behind fat acceptance.
However at the same time we don't need to pretend, as a country, that obesity is okay, normal, nothing to worry about. while a person shouldn't hate themselves because they've gotten heavy, they also shouldn't say "who cares! because I'm still awesome regardless and everyone should just accept my weight!" and then not do anything about it.
It's not just about looks. That's the general consensus among Americans is that the only downside to obesity is that it is physically unappealing. It's about health as well, and considering that heart disease is a huge problem in the US, as well as childhood diabetes and obesity... we're going downhill.
Bottom line though-I understand the motivation behind fat acceptance but I think it is having some unwanted side effects
Yes, in terms of helping people feel confident I totally understand. Being confident is actually one of the first steps to becoming healthy and fit. With 2/3 of people in this country being overweight and with the epidemic not slowing even slightly, this is hurting more than helping. This idea of you can't tell if I am healthy or not just by my weight and appearance is total bullshit.
yep I hear that a lot. "I may be fat but I bet I can run longer than you!"
I understand you can be reasonably fit and fat but let's be honest, most Americans are not fit and fat. Secondly, the presence of excess fat itself is pretty detrimental to the body over time.
Put perfectly. I actually saw a 1/100 example today at the rock gym. They guy was a little overweight but did surprisingly well for his size. But like you said, super rare.
yep. I've noticed with a lot of athletic guys though, they may be super muscular under some fat, and also really athletic. So yeah they're probably healthier than me but this isn't common like you said :P
And another thing young guys should keep in mind is carry an extra 30lbs is a lot different when you are 20 years old compared to when you are 40
very true.
One major reason people are fat is because restaurants, diners, grocery stores are now selling processed food that makes people fat, culture is advocating over eating, people are deprived of information on how to eat and cook healthy meals, poor people cannot afford to buy healthy meals, living costs are a lot higher than they were 50 years ago, and children grow up eating junk food and don't realize these foods are not NORMAL parts of a staple die. What we need are laws about food, taxes for companies that don't sell healthy food, education on what to eat and where and this fat epidemic will slowly subside.
Fat acceptance won't help lower our country's obesity epidemic (while shaming probably has a similar effect). Denial that you are overweight and need to trim off a few extra pounds can be a sign of or lead to deeper mental health problems. Accepting a heroin addict's lifestyle is called enabling and fat acceptance enables our country to be an unhealthy one.
I'm not a fitness freak and refuse to go to a gym, but I take care of myself nonetheless.
I would agree. Why do you refuse going to a gym?
I dislike the atmosphere of gyms such as cockiness, people who focus too much on self image, the pop music, and the sweat because I find sweat and BO repulsive. I would much rather do my pilates and yoga at home where I don't have to feel uncomfortable and can listen to my heavy metal.
Ah, @theperfectdater apparently did not watch the documentary called "Fed Up". The problem is not just lack of exercise, it is sugar addiction. Processed food in the west always contains 4 different types of sugar merely to support its lack of fat. It is a health epidemic, a concern.
So I voted A). People shouldn't be accepted for being fat just because they are fat... (Although quite obviously, bullying them solves nothing as well). But more importantly, they shouldn't accept being fat either - they need a better diet, without the sodas and without the sugary shit.
Actually mentioned this on the tread. I have seen the documentary and I never stated once that is was just lack of exercise. Furthermore, what I have stated as contributing factors are all correct.
Ah, okay. Reading through all the things on a phone during the mornkng transport makes me skip through some things sometimes, sorry about that :P yeah, I stand by A) because obesity is a health risk.
It's a double-edged sword as far as I'm concerned.
One the one hand, body positivity and the escalation of the American female teenager's already fragile self-esteem can be great, wonderful things. We need more of that, the idea that beauty can be found in a myriad of different body types.
On the other hand, teaching people that obesity is ok and that good health is not something worth striving for is very dangerous. The greatest threat to America's national security is the epidemic of obesity, hands down.
So yeah, we absolutely need to teach people and children body positivity, and we need to eradicate the notion that only certain looks and body measurements are capable of being attractive. We also need to work on promoting good health and nutrition too, though.
I think people should be cool to the individuals, but we shouldn't embrace obesity on a societal level. From the mood issues bad diet causes to higher medical costs to premature deaths - it's just not good for anyone.
The problem is that the food industry today is like cigarettes in the 60s. Deadly, sneaky and addictive.
Yes...
Honestly, I like it a hell of a lot better than the old way of thinking in America which was "shame everyone to do what you want them to do"
The fat acceptance movement has nothing to do with fat acceptance. It's tied to a much larger accepting people for what they want to do movement.
This is why divorce has become acceptable and choosing to work as a woman has become acceptable and yeah fatness too.
I feel like Americans (and British.. Westerners in general I think) are moving towards a much more acceptable society as a whole and I think that's a really good thing.
No. I would disagree. Especially with the child obesity rates skyrocketing. We have parents like you, who are honestly abusing their children by forcing them to eat total shit and have inactive lifestyles. Back in the day when people had this 'old way of thinking' kids DID NOT have diabetes. Do some research on that.
This is really getting out of hand. Look at this objectively. The only think positive about the movement is instilling confidence in fat people. Which they should have.
Who the hell is "honestly abusing their children by forcing them to eat total shit and have inactive lifestyles" did I say my KIDS could do what the hell they want? No, but other people can.
I think that you should be able to control your own kids and put them in your own place, but I don't think people should go around judging other people for no reason. Your kids are YOUR KIDS not other people's kids.
Do you see what I'm getting at? You worry about your life and controlling your life NOT other people's lives. Let other people diet of obesity shit I don't care that's their fault they knew what the risks were it's not your job to control them.
My whole philosophy is stay in your lane lol
MY KIDS are going to be put in capoeira and gymnastics classes the second they're old enough and I want them to live active and healthy lives. I don't want them to drink any soda or have too many sweets either. I never want them to get out of shape in the first place. I want them to start weight lifting when they turn 15 years old so it becomes a healthy lifestyle choice and not some hobby they picked up.
Does that give me the right to tell other people they need to do the same thing? Nope, they can raise their kids however they feel like raising their kids it's none of my damn business and I like it that way. I don't want anyone telling me that I can't let my little girl weightlift because she's a girl and my little boy can't be in gymnastics because he's a boy so I'm not going to go and tell them that they shouldn't let their kids eat Taco Bell for dinner every single night. As a good parent they should know the pros and cons of their parenting skills
So are you saying there is no possible way someone should be called a child abuser ever... or only if it applies to destroying their kids health and activity?
My question is when does it become child abuse in your view? Ever?
Child abuse is when a case is severe THEN you can intervene. Say a 7 year old girl weighs 150lbs THAT'S child abuse Honey Boo Boo is fat, but that's not child abuse.
Same with other laws. You can spank your child that's not child abuse, but if you're putting bruises on your child that is.
There's a point where you need to intervene in other people's lives, but that point is not where you think it is. It's all about the severity of it. If nobody is putting their children's lives in immediate danger then it's none of my business.
You're acting like these parents are strapping these kids down and forcing them to eat Burger King nope these kids are asking for it and the dumbass parents are spoiling them and giving them everything they want. By your logic parents shouldn't be allowed to buy their kids expensive cars either because it's bad parenting, but there's a difference between bad parenting and child abuse.
So say your kid has clogged arteries THAT is abuse. If your kid has sleep apnea because of their weight: abuse, if your kid has diabetes before age 12 because of their obesity you should probably be monitored for child abuse.
If it's actually presenting itself as an immediate danger to their health I see it as abuse, but if it's going to kill them when they're 50 then I don't care because that means that the kid had a whole 30 years to turn their life around and they chose not to
Good then we agree then. I recommend you do some research on child obesity and diabetes. A LOT of abusers need to be flagged.
I've actually only ever met one kid with diabetes before in my life and he wasn't really that fat I'd say he was about this size https://i55.tinypic.com/264iefd.png maybe a little smaller (note when I said "kid" I met him when he was 17 lol so I'm not talking about a fat ass 6 year old) and his sister was skinny (I'd say 5'1 about 90 lbs) and they seemed like a relatively healthy family.. they were weird as hell (I mean like The Duggars weird lol) but healthy.
So I don't think diabetes is always necessarily tied to terrible eating habits and a bad lifestyle, BUT if you know diabetes run in your family you should be taking precautions to prevent it.
Everyone should learn to love their bodies no matter what shape or size they are. It's important for people to have self-esteem and not feel insecure about their bodies, but we should never normalize overweight or obese people and tell them that it's okay to be fat. It's unhealthy and costs our government billions in medical care for diseases that could have been prevented with a proper diet and some exercise. If you really love your body, then that means feeding it the right food and exercising in order to give your body exactly what it needs to live a long healthy life.
Fat people are unhealthy and unattractive, fat acceptance movements won't change this. However they won't normalise being fat either, since it is already normal. Overall I don't think fat acceptance makes any difference in most cases, the severe lack of self discipline and personal responsibility in our society is what we need to challenge.
I probably wouldn't care if others wanted to waste their lives being fat but, since I live in a country with a socialist healthcare system, other people's inability to look after themselves is costing me money, it makes me so angry knowing my money is taken from me to fund other's laziness and stupidity.
I don't think weight should be anything to be bullied about or condemned for. Weight is weight, has nothing to do with who you are as a person.
But calling fat "curvy" and thinness = starvation is simply ignorant.
How about instead of encouraging a certain size, we simply encourage fitness? Everyone looks better when fit and in shape no matter their body shape or size. And lots of thin people are skinnyfat, so that would encourage them to get up and get fit too, not just thicker people.
Most definitely.
I think too many people want to make excuses to be fat and lazy. I've known fat people who've said they've done everything and they've done all these diets and exercises and that but usually they're full of shit, and all they do is make excuses not to exercise then eat pizzas and chips and all sorts of junk food.
I used to think it was full of shit. But it's actually just being misinformed on what is healthy. I agree with you though
It's not just in America, it's everywhere and is extremely harmful to the overall health of the world's population.
Fat acceptance is an absolute disgrace and if your are responible for being fat without having an already existing health problem that causes you to be obese, you should bloody be ashamed of yourself.
I don't know about ashamed but more aware of what they are doing for sure.
Huge health problem... could be the reason of the end of man kind...
I don't think it's right to discriminate anyone by anything, be it size, color, intelligence or whatever, but I also do not condone someone applauding or encouraging something that can be life threatening... It's preposterous on some level. ... Sure if you wanna be fat, so be it, be fat... but why go out and make a "movement" of acceptance worldwide? Seems ridiculous.
I can care less about their opinion. They want to be "accepted" they should become active and stop asking to be in a separate category because they are too lazy or weak willed to get off their asses.
Cowardly peasants if you ask me and society would be better off without.
Note: This has to do with people who feel there should be a "movement" and not for those who are simply overweight be it from injury, pregnancy or the like.
well at least we know there will never be a 1,000,000 fat people march... they couldn't make the trek. Lmao
Hah, nice. That's one way to get them off their asses.
this expresses my thoughts
I dont care. Its their life and who am I to judge anyway? Do i think its gross? Hell yea. But ots not my life neither my health so if theyre happy then whatever. People shouldn't be shamed and put into categories
Would you consider this shaming?
thoughtcatalog.com/.../
I don't know it's funny because a lot of people have the same reaction you have. But then when asked if you would confront a family member about their weight and health issues people (especially fit people) usually say of course.
My point is caring about others shouldn't stop at our families. I know what it's like to walk around afraid to take of my shit, in a bad mood, and unhealthy from head to toe. I would have liked someone to have helped me out with advice back then. We need to act like a community that cares for one another. I am beginning to believe that "let em do what they want" is code for I COULD CARE LESS ABOUT SOMEONE ELSE
We should accept them for who they are and this acceptance movement is a good idea. They deserve to be accepted too. They're also people.
Sure. But first I think it's important to give out the correct information about what health REALLY is. Also important to show how body image distortion is on both ends of the spectrum. The runway models on one and the fat-kini chicks claiming they optimize health and happiness.
The correct information needs to be out there. Now if some fat person says fuck you i'm just fine... Well god bless em
As long as they are healthy than that's fine. Some people can't get thin unless they are extremely sick
Sure I agree. Although, this does not apply to people in America any where near average. If someone looks fat they are most likely unhealthy.
I feel it is giving people justification to be heavy , without discrimination but at the same time I feel they should really make an effort to work out and watch food portion.
D) I really don't care.
If fat people wanna feel good about being fat, let them. They are only harming themselves.
So your child... you wouldn't care?
The difference would be you don't care about others?
Depends on your view. If your looking at from a dating and relationship point of view, then I agree, they should be accepted as people just like everyone else. But from a health and fitness point of view, it shouldn't be tolerated.
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions