I don’t have anything against her sister and her family but I was planning on it being just us. Am I wrong for that?


No it's not needy.
If this is ongoing, and you want just the two of you every time you do something, then it might be needy.
Also, some people are obviously more social than others. Some people love large groups, while others prefer small groups, or one-on-one. From what I've seen, the people who love large groups are more needy than the ones who prefer small groups. The highly social people very often can't stand to be alone. THAT is needy.
Just talk to her about it and tell her you were hoping it was just the 2 of you spending time together , and to please not make this trip all about her sister and brother in law , I am sure they want alone time as well , so compromise with her , meet up with them for dinner and drinks and then go your separate ways. If your girlfriend loves you she will understand
Once she gets her family in the picture, it'll be difficult for you to beat and deal with that.
Just "go along with the ride" in the meantime.
If you can survive that Cancun trip, you just earned another vacation with her which you can plan just for yourselves.
No, she shouldn't change plans on you.
What kind of a relationship is that when you refuse to spend quality time when your partner asks?
How am I projecting? That answer had nothing to do with my experience I simply answered the comment asking about relationships that don't spend quality time with their partner. My answer stands 100% it's pretty rude to change plans out of the blue when they originally had a couples retreat planned. If she wanted to do a family vacation should have said it from the start and not gotten his hopes up on spending quality time as a couple.
I think the asker can differentiate between my answer to him and my reply to a comment directed towards me
@Peridot25 no worries, all good 👍😊
Aiming to add a sprinkle of insight here! Wanting some alone time, especially on a trip that was initially painted with the brush of romance and togetherness, isn't needy, my friend. It's natural to crave those intimate moments where the world seems to revolve around just the two of you. Maybe you can gently express how much you were looking forward to the magic of Cancun, just the two of you, highlighting your anticipation of deepening your connection without the chorus of daily life and additional company. It's all about balancing togetherness with family time. Perhaps suggest meeting up with them for a part of the trip and then soaking up the sun, just you two, for the rest. Love is about crafting those special memories together, after all. 😉
Opinion
16Opinion
No, absolutely not.
I have no clue what your relationship is like or how close you really are with her but I’d let her know that you want time with only her to build on your relationship with only each other. Quality time.
She should totally understand 💯
Talk to her about it. Explain your thought process. I’m sure she’ll come around if it something you’re hoping to happen and your reasonings why. Just say you really want some quality time with her alone for a turn. And maybe the next one, the relatives can join.
You’re not needy. You wanted to have a quality time just you both.
Have you ask her why she’s bringing family? She probably don’t have a bad intention on bringing them. Instead she wanted them to know you well or just her way welcoming you to her family.
If you plan a couples trip (or anything) and the other half invites people, you absolutely should not be paying. Only pay for yourself. It's a tiny bit needy to want it, but it's a big "fuck you" to invite others to a trip you're paying for.
No, it's not needy.
Does she want to be with them for the entire stay? Or just a day?
Because I would suggest you could compromise and be open to meet up with them for a few hours, or an afternoon or something.
If you go along with that, you will fail a major shit-test. Your girlfriend will lose whatever little respect she has for you. Don't be surprised if they ask you to babysit those kids while the 3 of them go out on the town. Cancel the trip and tell her the 2 of you can go only when you can be alone. If the trip is already paid for and non-transferable, take a different girl.
She shouldn't change plans on you, but it's also totally understandable for her to want to be with her sister.
Just go with a good attitude and enjoy every moment, both with them and alone with your girlfriend.
Its not needy but she may also want to be able to have u around family plus just because u are meeting up with them don't mean u can't have days or evening for just the two of you
It’s not needy, hence why it’s called “couples trip”. Ask your girlfriend if you can chill with the sister and brother in law for one day or less and the rest can be with only you and your girlfriend
I voted No and maybe a timely song is Nico & Vinz is the song Am I Wrong, a pop modern classic ✌🏻😋😎 pumping those tunes 🎵 🔊
If they are paying for it, then yes. If you are paying for it, then no.
You are not wrong but don't cause trouble by trying to be right. You cannot win this one other than by going along with what she has already planned.
No, if you wanted to see all these people you could just stay home.
It is really kind of uncool for her to orchestrate that, as she either knew or told her sister in order to get her family there.
No, and couples' trips are GREAT !!!(I assume you're going to "CANCUN!!!")
You are not on the same page with your needs and goals with this romance.
Not at all, especially if she just surprisingly invited them without say so
Not needy. Quite reasonable.
Why are you with her?
Nope. It’s normal for a couple to have alone time.
It's selfish on her part.
Honestly I'd cancel the trip if I were in your shoes.
Seems selfish on your part.
Tell her you wanted it to be a couples trip
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions