Which is the most logical Abrahamic religion?

[Anonymous]

Judaism

Christianity

Islam

Baháʼí Faith

[jennifer_bloom]

I converted to Christianity at age 14 and became interested in Judaism briefly in from 23-28 and again from 34-37 and what I like about Judaism is how simple and direct and untainted the original ideas are, I view Judaism as the religion of compassion and dignity. Christianity is a combination of spiritual intimacy and spiritual inclusion but a lot of sacrifice hides behind that joyous image, and Islam is too culturally orthodox to appeal to my mental desire for new knowledge.

[Effably]

I think logic and belief are inherently different things. Belief is after all the conviction that something is real despite there being no true way to verify it.

If I had to choose one I'd go with Judaism for the simple reason that it came first. Any subsequent Abrahamistic religion basing itself on Judaism still has to acknowledge most of it.

Of course the inverse argument is possible too. That the more modern the religion the more it has to adhere to present day standards of scrutiny and so it will be more logical to stand up to it. In which case I guess the Baha'i would win among these. Although I am admitttedly not very well read on it.

[NamerOfStars]

I can see excluding the Yazidi, but no love for the Druze? You do know they're pretty much the only religion out there that doesn't have an "I" in its name, right?

More the point, however, religion isn't ABOUT logic: it's a matter of faith, not fact.

[Anemone978]

Islam is pretty on point if you don't consider the hadith...

[QuietRunner]

I've always thought this also. If the Quran is complete, why do I need the hadith

[Anemone978]

@QuietRunner Yeah most peoples argument on the hadith is because it tells you how to actually pray and what to do... but the Quran says it is one book and complete so I don't get it, because it was written after Mohamad died so how is it trust worthy lol

[Bricealan]

In my studies of religion in college, I find none that are 'logical' per se, but I do favor Buddhism over any other religious teaching.

[LiamJHayden]

Both Judaism and Christianity are internally logical; that is no A and not A at the same time and in the same relationship. Islam is not. Cannot speak to Baháʼí.

[genericname85]

logic and religion are like water and oil. they don't mix.

[Petr87]

When it comes to religion, logic is nowhere to be found.

[Hispanic-Cool-Guy]

The glorious gospel of the lord Jesus Christ. All other world religions are pure BS.

[Paul09]

Why? Because plenty of Latinos are called Jesus? Lol It's all b. s created by man , to put fear into people's lives, so they can be controlled.

[strateguy632]

christ and we won

[Agape93]

Judaism, as that was the first abrahamic religion.

[Paul09]

Logics and make believe do not go together.

[CateM]

None

[AngelLily]

Christianity