When should you ask someone to be your Valentine?

When is the best time to ask a girl/guy to be your valentine?

And you are? I'm a GirlI'm a Guy

Most Helpful Girl

  • Uh, Valentine's Day, obviously.

    • You don't think getting asked earlier demonstrates decisiveness and real interest?

    • I'd think it was, honestly, kinda creepy and weird, assuming we weren't already dating.

    • Really? I kinda' figured it would be the exact opposite. If you're already dating... it's assumed. But to want someone to be your valentine, even when it's not Valentine's Day, yet... Well, I thought that was more romantic.

      You know, like wanting to give a woman flowers, even when it's not your anniversary, or to buy someone a gift even when it's not her birthday or Christmas?