I clicked DLR but that's a tough one because Dave was the original and an amazing showman but my guy and I saw them a couple years ago and Dave has basically lost his voice. We saw Sammy Hagar in his current band and he still has it. I love them both on the radio or my phone (studio recordings)
I think it's kind of apples and oranges. Roth was the perfect fit when hair bands were a thing. Hagar was the perfect fit in the 90s. The music changed a lot between them. The 1984 album is a rock classic and Jump is still in my top 10 all-time, so I voted Roth, but they put out some really good stuff with Hagar too. I quit following them in the 90s - never heard of Cherone til this post.