Battle of The Christmas Movies 2: Elf vs The Grinch, Which is better?

[smahala1991]

I like them both, but in my opinion, I like Elf better. Elf has a childlike innocence to it. The Grinch is a good Take on the 60's Dr. Seuss story, however, rather than making The Grinch the villain it turns him into a more sympathetic character after suffering abuse from the Whoville mayor.

Elf

The Grinch

[Logorithim]

I liked the Grinch more. My kids have, for some strange reason, nicknamed me "Grinch", probably because they know I like the story having read it to them many times. I am most definitely not a Grinch!

[Poormanscomedian]

Grinch sucked liked a vac. Jim Carrey was good on TV, but not in the movies. If you have seen one Jim Carrey movie , you have seen all his movies.

[Poormanscomedian]

Well , i must be fair to Carrey, He did play one serious movie role and played a real life person. Other than that , his movies have been the same, goofy.

[smahala1991]

In Living Color was his best work. But a lot of others like Jamie Foxx, Jennifer Lopez, and I think Louie Anderson started there, but i'm not for sure about Louie

[ItalianGuyReturns]

Damon Wayans

[naijagurl]

I love the Grinch. I honestly don’t understand all the hype for Elf. I didn’t really like it.

[ItalianGuyReturns]

Elf sucked bad

[mooky06]

Love the grinch

[Jjpayne]

I'm leaning more towards the Grinch, the elf is a little to awkward for me :)

[SirRexington]

Elf! That movie will live on forever and is my favorite Christmas movie!

[Laevateinn]

Of those Elf, but that's only because the live action Seuss movies blow.
Give me the original animated Grinch any day of the week.

[MarketData]

Elf is the best Christmas Movie for some reason although any other time of the year it's crap.

[ChiTown33]

Elf, unless it's the original animated Grinch for sentimental reasons.

[Ecco939]

For me it is Will Ferrell that is the turn off for elf. I love Will Ferrells serious work. But his commdies kinda annoy me.

[SpiderManFan2002]

Hands down, the Grinch. I don't like Elf.

[TacosRAwesome]

Grinch... Elf makes me hate Christmas.

[ItalianGuyReturns]

I agree also Tacos are awesome yes

[ChocolateCheesecake]

I like the Grinch better

[beebella]

I'm going to go with The Grinch on this one.

[adamski24]

Smiling is my favourite

[11110000bbbb]

The Grinch
It's funny lol

[Titanic1912]

Haven’t seen either so I can’t vote.

[ItalianGuyReturns]

They are both horrible

[Iamagoodguy]

Both great

[NovissimumVirorum]

Elf hands down

[SMB2019]

Elf for sure