Your favorite type of cheese to use in a Grilled cheese sandwich?

Question

If you or someone offered to make you a grilled cheese sandwich, what type of cheese would you want in it?

CommieDearest · Accepted Answer

With just cheese, American.

With meat, depends. There's a place in Chicago called Cheesies that only makes grilled cheese sandwiches and other cheese themed foods. Good God I miss Chicago.

My favorite was "The Caprese" with Tomato, Mozzarella, cracked black pepper, I'd add chicken, and it came with pesto mayo dipping sauce.

I need Cheesies
tastyspot.files.wordpress.com/.../...sies_yelp.jpg

Hidden_P · Accepted Answer

Cheddar.
We don't really have American cheese in this country. It's in stuff like McDonalds but that's about it really.

Cheddar is my favourite - I hate soft cheese and blue cheese. I'll put up with goats cheese in some situations but most goats cheese is horrible too.

Phoenix98 · Accepted Answer

I'm going to mix it up a slice of American and a slice info sharp cheddar on each.  Buttermilk bread for the toast.

kheserthorpe · Accepted Answer

B. Preferably several years old.  A is not cheese. It's a cheese derived product and it's gross.

misscoffeehead · Answer

Mmm I picked Cheddar cheese from your list but I also love this cheese we have here.. It's called Cracker Barrel (which is a strong, vintage cheddar cheese here) Mmm yum yum

BellePepper · Answer

Cheddar with ham. Cheddar with broccoli. Cheddar with mozzarella. Cheddar with Canadian bacon and sautéed mushrooms...

spuitkaas · Answer

Beemster or goat cheese. American cheese tastes like plastic. Cheddar too, but maybe I've only tasted the wrong American cheese.

LauraMarx · Answer

brie, actually :)

Rcjh1987 · Answer

American cheese but none of that nasty Kraft stuff has to be Velveeta! !

Klaatu51 · Answer

tbh i don't like cheese anymore... but i USED TO like blue cheese mostly

kambo_trick3y · Answer

Seriously? No one for Pepper Jack? Jesus Christ it's good.

justbanANNAz · Answer

good lawd, these look so beautiful. i dont even know, cheddar or mozzarella maybe lol

ButterSauce · Answer

White cheddar is good. I have no idea why it's white and why its better but i love it.  And gruyere and gouda :)

springocelot · Answer

For me, nothing beats a classic cheddar cheese. But when I want to go fancy, I choose gruyere :)

smilesarenice · Answer

Gruyere or Gouda. With thin sliced apples and bacon. Yummm

CHARismatic110 · Answer

Omg I think I just had a foodgasm. I love grilled cheese!

Watermelonoma · Answer

what's the difference between American and cheddar? More fat?

AlwaysBelieving · Answer

American please. Could have something to do with the first time I had a grilled cheese sandwich. The others aren't "it."

UberTroll · Answer

White American cheese, not the orange kind.

PessimisticLoon · Answer

Muenster cheese with mustard.

brookeh09 · Answer

American and provolone, usually.

TheEmma · Answer

Edam cheese!

Toadette · Answer

American. Now I'm craving cheese sandwich :(

_Zara_ · Answer

Parmesan..

Your favorite type of cheese to use in a Grilled cheese sandwich?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said