Community of trusted and anonymous friends where girls and guys help each other.
  • 0/150

  • Feed
    • Popular
    • Questions
    • Help Needed
    • Polls
    • Live Feed
    • myTakes
    • Topics
  • Topics
  • Search
  • Sign Up or Log In
    • Girl's Behavior Girl's Behavior
    • Guy's Behavior Guy's Behavior
    • Flirting Flirting
    • Dating Dating
    • Relationships Relationships
    • Fashion & Beauty Fashion & Beauty
    • Health & Fitness Health & Fitness
    • Marriage & Weddings Marriage & Weddings
    • Shopping & Gifts Shopping & Gifts
    • Technology & Internet Technology & Internet
    • Break Up & Divorce Break Up & Divorce
    • Education & Career Education & Career
    • Entertainment & Arts Entertainment & Arts
    • Family & Friends Family & Friends
    • Food & Beverage Food & Beverage
    • Hobbies & Leisure Hobbies & Leisure
    • Other Other
    • Religion & Spirituality Religion & Spirituality
    • Society & Politics Society & Politics
    • Sports Sports
    • Travel Travel
    • Trending & News Trending & News
    • Manage Topics
  • Marriage & Weddings Shopping & Gifts Technology & Internet Break Up & Divorce Education & Career +15
Society & Politics

What is the natural state of societies: peace or war?

Julie4
Julie4 Follow
Xper 6 Age: 25
Follow
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
02
What is the natural state of societies: peace or war?
What is the natural state of societies: peace or war?
Post Opinion
24 Opinion
Like
Share
Follow
2 likes
What is your opinion?
What is your opinion?
Add Opinion
AI Bot Choice

Superb Opinion

  • nightdrot
    nightdrotInfluencer Follow
    Master Age: 59
    4 mo
    3.4K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    Could not pass this one up. The question hinges on the definition of "natural."

    To oversimplify for sake of space, the "ancients" - think Socrates, Aristotle, Plato - defined the "natural" as the perfection toward which a thing trends. There is no perfection, but every person wants to be the perfection of him or herself. In inanimate objects, the chair you are sitting on is the perfect chair. It is - to borrow an odd formulation - a chair, chairing.

    Then along came the "moderns" who split into two camps. The original "moderns," see also Thomas Hobbes, believed that the natural was wild and uncontrolled. Hence his famous phrase, "Life in the state of nature is nasty, brutish and short." Thus the need for law to impose order and, if possible, to perfect it insofar as imperfect being can perfect something.

    Later came Rousseau, and to a lesser extent Locke. These men argued, again to oversimplify somewhat, that man in the state of nature was perfect but in the interaction of human society the impact of society was to corrupt human nature. Thus the need for an agreed upon social contract which moderates the corrupting influence of society. Locke arguing that this was an accommodation, Rousseau, that with proper engineering, man could be brought back to his essential good nature and be perfected.

    Put me down for Hobbes, (with a touch of the "ancients") recognizing the limiting principle that his solution, in effect, put imperfect beings in charge of running an imperfect state. Thus limits must be put on the power of the - to borrow Hobbes' phrase - "leviathan."

    Man, absent the restraints of laws - both formal (legal) and informal (moral) - is a beast. As can be seen in those places where the rule of law has collapsed. (It being added that the moral is often more important - and prior to - the legal.) In such places there is mayhem, exploitation, and bloodshed.

    In the international arena, the thing that maintains peace is not common morals, but a balance of power. Those seeking to exercise power, though often not without some set of moral principles animating their actions, are restrained in the use of force only by a balance of power.

    International law does exist, but it is not law as it exists within societies where there is general agreement on moral principle. Instead it is law based on a grand quid pro quo - "You don't do it to us, we won't do it to you." Rather, as the American President Theodore Roosevelt put it, "World peace comes not from human kindness or moral restraint, but from balanced power; equilibriums of force restraining the selfish aims of nation-states."

    Thus, a qualified difference. Within societies there is an element of common morals that conduces to a relative stability approximating peace. In the international arena it is war restrained by "equilibriums of force restraining the selfish aims of nation-states."

    1
    0 Reply

Most Helpful Opinions

  • Sixgunsound
    Sixgunsound Follow
    Yoda Age: 36
    4 mo
    1.1K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    Arguably greed fueled violence wherein old rich men send poor young men out to protect their property, then promptly abandon them once their property is no longer in danger. They will give a few medals (but not to everyone who did something, or it would cheapen the effext) to keep the dumber ones inspired, or lie to them all about ptriotism and freedom or that "dulce et decorum est pro patria mori", but the politicians or factoty owners never seem to experience that sweetness for some reason...

    0
    0 Reply
  • purplepoppy
    purplepoppy Follow
    Master Age: 23 , mho 50%
    4 mo
    3.7K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    If you do a wiki search on say wars between France and England you get a very long list going back a long way with only short breaks between them. Plus all the periods of internal conflict. So it seems peace is the oddity.

    0
    0 Reply

What Girls & Guys Said

3

Opinion

18

Opinion

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous
    (36-45)
    4 mo

    “Hereby it is manifest that during the time men live without a common Power to keep them all in awe, they are in that condition which is called War; and such a war as is of every man against every man. In such condition there is no place for Industry, because the fruit thereof is uncertain: and consequently no Culture of the Earth; no Navigation, nor use of the commodities that may be imported by Sea; no commodious Building; no Instruments of moving and removing such things as require much force; no Knowledge of the face of the Earth; no account of Time; no Arts; no Letters; no Society; and which is worst of all, continual Fear, and danger of violent death; And the life of man solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.” -Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan, 1651

    0
    0 Reply
  • Berethor
    Berethor Follow
    Master Age: 35 , mho 38%
    4 mo
    1.9K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    Might makes right trope and pacifism backfire trope, I believe that the new left is suicidal.

    https://www.thereligionofpeace.com/attacks/europe-attacks.aspx

    0
    0 Reply
  • ZackBan
    ZackBan Follow
    Guru Age: 25 , mho 39%
    4 mo
    594 opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    The two put together form the natural state.
    "Peace is the waiting period between two wars"

    Humans have created this illusion that we are so different from the animals and hence can live outside of the laws of the jungle but we can't escape our animalistic instinct.
    Territorial mentality.
    Fight or flight.
    Hunter behavior.
    The need to reproduce.
    Etc...

    All these combined make war an inevitable outcome no matter how "civilized" we become

    0
    0 Reply
  • Chazmatazz269
    Chazmatazz269 Follow
    Yoda Age: 49
    4 mo
    868 opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    It’s both. Most people are peaceful, but there are enough people who can’t or won’t manage their violent impulses AND manage to put themselves in positions of influence, that war is all but inevitable. Add to that the profitability of war, and it becomes absolutely inevitable. Capitalism is king. People will justify literally anything in the name of profits.

    0
    0 Reply
  • RyanEC
    RyanEC Follow
    Guru Age: 32
    4 mo

    I would say there has always been cycles of war.


    Sometimes there is a long period where a generation or two doesn’t see war.
    Like the period between the Napoleonic war in 1815 and the unification wars of Italy and Germany in the 1860s/1870s.

    0
    0 Reply
  • DaveJord
    DaveJord Follow
    Guru Age: 46 , mho 56%
    4 mo
    428 opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    Societies, nations or cultures usually do wants in their best interest with the intent of preserving, promoting or protecting their own society. So that's its natural state, war and peace is just the means in which they do it.

    0
    0 Reply
  • msc545
    msc545 Follow
    Master Age: 35
    4 mo
    5.9K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    This depends on the resources and economic systems and the corruption of each nation. For instance, in the US, there are a moderate amount of recoverable resources and a predatory Capitalist economic system paired with a relatively high level of corruption, leading to a chronic cycle of resource exploitation, manufacturing, war-making, recovery, and back-to-resource exploitation.

    0
    1 Reply
    • msc545
      msc545
      4 mo

      Therefore, in the US at least, everything important is either about war or money or both

      Reply
  • HippieVeganJewslim
    HippieVeganJewslim Follow
    Xper 7 Age: 26
    4 mo
    414 opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    I think most societies are at war with nobody currently. However, it seems always the big countries that are fighting, like Russia attacked Ukraine; Yankeeland attacked Afghanistan, Iraq, Dixie, etc; etc.

    0
    0 Reply
  • exitseven
    exitseven Follow
    Master Age: 51
    4 mo
    8.7K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    It is war. It is baked into our DNA. If we did not fight over nationality we would find something else to fight about.

    0
    0 Reply
  • Andres77
    Andres77 Follow
    Master Age: 45
    4 mo
    1.5K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    War and selfishness. That’s base human nature.

    1
    0 Reply
  • TroyDT2
    TroyDT2 Follow
    Xper 7 Age: 27
    4 mo
    484 opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    The natural state would be peace if greedy and envious and selfish people did not exist.

    0
    0 Reply
  • Snakeyes7
    Snakeyes7 Follow
    Guru Age: 25
    4 mo
    5.4K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    As long as we have people who flip tables over after they lost a board game fair and square, there will always be war.

    0
    1 Reply
    • Snakeyes7
      Snakeyes7
      4 mo

      People start fights over literally anything

      Reply
  • jayhams
    jayhams Follow
    Xper 5 Age: 31
    4 mo

    No such thing as a natural state of societies. Different societies have different cultural norms.

    0
    0 Reply
  • Googlemyahoo
    Googlemyahoo Follow
    Xper 7 Age: 47
    4 mo

    If you want peace prepare for war

    0
    1 Reply
    • Sixgunsound
      Sixgunsound
      3 mo

      The 9mm cartridge is named parabellum in honor of the latin version of that statement.

      Reply
  • Jennz6
    Jennz6 Follow
    Yoda Age: 34
    4 mo
    314 opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    War peace in between

    0
    0 Reply
  • KrakenAttackin
    KrakenAttackin Follow
    Guru Age: 43
    4 mo
    3.3K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    "Only the dead have seen the end of war".

    0
    0 Reply
  • NathanDavis s
    NathanDavis Follow
    Master Age: 33 , mho 35%
    4 mo
    2.5K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    agreeability

    0
    0 Reply
  • CoolCatMar1
    CoolCatMar1 Follow
    Xper 7 Age: 19
    4 mo

    War..

    0
    0 Reply
  • Kelly6
    Kelly6 Follow
    Guru Age: 39
    4 mo
    788 opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    War.

    1
    0 Reply
  • CuriousMufuxka
    CuriousMufuxka Follow
    Guru Age: 44
    4 mo
    2K opinions shared on Society & Politics topic.

    War.

    0
    0 Reply
  • Show More (1)
Click "Show More" for your mentions
Home > Society & Politics > Questions > What is the natural state of societies: peace or war?
Add your reply For "{0}"
Most Helpful Opinion(mho) Rate.
Learn more

Related Questions

Is taking guns away the best idea to stop the killings that are committed with guns? I am a Mexican citizen. Can I open US bank account and transfer money to it if I won US poweball... Why are far right communities always banned on forums? Why is it that some men get upset when women express a desire to be treated with a certain level... In light of the trans shooting, is it time to scale back "wokeness" by enacting tough gun... What do you think of the trans day of vengeance? Is the US government spending too much, too little, or the right amount on?
Cast Your Vote
Do you UNDERSTAND the ECONOMY?
I'm an amateur Economist... it all makes sense to me
I don't understand any of it... leave it to others
Does anyone really understand the economy?
Not to worry... government takes good care of us
Something else - please tell us.
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Please select your age
AviatorTom
AviatorTom
Influencer
Other

Popular Questions

Guys in my college make fun of me for walking like a model? What Do You Think Of People Who Want To Date You After They've Rejected You? What type of skillet do you prefer to use when cooking? Would you say pregnancy is a positive or negative experience for women?
Show All
Popular Questions
  • Girls, What are the Ways for Men to Say They Care About You?
  • My boyfriend follows random girls on Instagram, should I be worried?
  • Girls what does the 😌 emoji mean?
  • How do I ask for a girl's Instagram?
  • "How Do You Feel About Me?" Best Answers to This Situation!
  • Do guys really like girls with thick thighs?
  • Girls, What Makes a Man Fall Deeply in Love With a Woman?
  • What does the date under "Hey there I am using Whatsapp" Status mean?
  • What's a good comeback when someone jokingly calls you old?
  • When a girls says "I'll let you know" what does it mean?
Recent Questions
  • Do you sometimes miss the feeling of being in love?
  • What is the worst pizza topping in your opinion?
  • A good Sweaty workout or a therapist? What would be your choice?
  • I have a date soon and I'm super nervous. Should I cancel?
  • Guys, Why is it when I text a guy he is talkative and open, but when we see each other in person he barely talks to me?
  • Can we control evil doers’ access to guns?
  • Best ways to start up a conversation with a woman at work, without coming off as being too aggressive?
  • I am a single dad dating childless woman but my daughter and my girlfriend dont get along well. What should I do?
  • For those who aren’t straight, could you be in relationship with a partner who isn’t out to their parents yet?
  • I cheated on my several partners many times and never got caught even once. Should I feel guilty?
  • Help
  • Contact
  • Terms Of Use
  • Guidelines
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Featured Questions
  • Topics
Popular Topics
Dating Education & Career Entertainment & Arts Flirting Food & Beverage Girl's Behavior Guy's Behavior Health & Fitness Relationships Technology & Internet
Girls Ask Guys
©2023 GirlsAskGuys ™
Apple Store Google Play
Join with {0}
Loading...