Well, allowing for the fact that Debray is speaking is speaking in rather abstract terms, what he is saying is not without a certain validity. The contrast is with Europe, a continent where, relatively speaking, people were crowded in together and the actions of one people were apt to have limiting - and sometimes perceived as threatening - impacts another people.
The net result was a a people that tended to think in terms of life's limits, so to speak. Either how to accommodate them or to build ways around them.
Americans, by contrast, developed on a continent that was mostly wide open spaces. Where the limits were apt less to be the difficulties of interacting with other people than of meeting the challenges of life on a frontier. This then lending itself to a less restrictive worldview.
Hence, Americans are known for their optimism. For their sense that "all things are possible," and "space versus time," i. e. the sense that the challenges are more of conquering the frontier - which takes time but is ultimately doable.
Having said all that, Debray's remarks are, as I say, a bit abstract, i. e. ironically, more "image" than "written word." It is easy to see periods in American history where his generalities were not true. This producing swings in America's cultural and political mood. See also the "can-do" spirit of the 1980s versus the agitated social mood in the USA at the moment.
So Debray's observations are not without merit, but are of limited utility. Every people has their own distinct cultural characteristics. Debray captured, in a phrase, a generally valid observation about America's cultural character, a character rooted in both the times and place in which the American people evolved.
However it is only a generally valid of observation. There are both times and places where it is not valid and indeed may be outrightly contradicted. Hence why even Americans teach their children history as the story is more complex in its' detail than in any broad observations.
Most Helpful Opinions
You have people that live in shoe box apartments in major cities or tiny houses just as much as you have people living on broad acreage... Not everything is big in America, culture varies from region to region. The founding fathers obviously knew the power of the printing press and use that power to declare independence from monarchs. The written word is the authority in American culture, not an appointed man like in Europe. Americans look to the words of the constitution and the laws of a republic. Words are the entire foundation of our culture. As the rest of that, capitalism in general has booms and busts. America has had much economic, technological, and political success, but we've also had war, famine, economic depressions, etc. There are stories from the great depression of mothers boiling dogs heads and feeding them to their children and begging people not to tell the children, what's in the soup. America has seen hard times before, it's not all pie in the sky.
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
9Opinion
I can see that.
Space Vs Time I suppose is referring to the fact that we are a large spacious country but we don’t have much history.
Images vs written word comes from the fact we care more about symbols and don’t have as much great Literature.
On the last point I suppose we are more optimistic then other countries that have had more of a rough history like Russia.Americans grow up with freedoms that people in a lot of the world do not have. They also have more personal responsibility that requires self restraint and accountability. Americans are good at innovation and fresh ideas.
Not at all. I wanna know where on earth he came up with that. Those are such broad characteristics that could apply to ANYONE. And it applies more so to specific individuals, bur I've never seen anyone put emphasis on it, as a cultural thing.
It's only made up of how someone "chooses " to live their life. If they are miserable then they will live a miserable life
America is a tragedy. But they do have a lot of space, I will give them that.
Currently, America is one of the most unhappy countries in the world due to Capitalism.
America isn't doing well now
Dumb question
no space, but mass shootings
maybe
Learn more
We're glad to see you liked this post.
You can also add your opinion below!