I find this amusing because he sounds exactly like a woman when saying this. What I mean by that is, he is pandering to women who have no understanding of men at all. Men do talk about feelings, women ignore them. Then they talk more and women shout them down. Dr. Warren Farrell had a convention were they were discussing male suicide and Feminists not only protested this event but called in a bomb threat and pulled the fire alarm to prevent men from talking about this. When men point out that hey, they commit suicide at much higher rates, women chime in that it doesn't matter because women make the "attempt"(not really) more then men do.
Then men point out that hey, the laws are so completley skewed in womens favor that during divorce a man has everything taken from him and he has no recourse, his own children are taken from him and used to extort money from him and his life crumbles. Then when men point out that this happens and male suicide rates double after divorce, women tell them that its their fault and that they are clearly unstable and don't deserve to have their children to begin with because they are so emotionally unstable when having their entire life destroyed simply because a woman decided to do so, and having his children taken from him.
Men have pointed out that they are treated like a paycheck by women and women tell them that they are deadbeats if they don't keep shelling out money, hence 80% of domestic spending being done by women despite them being responsible for only about 30% of domestic earnings. Then when men point out that hey, male suicide doubles after retirement because of the work demands placed on them that cause them to be stuck working their entire life away were they don't have friends or hobbies and barely got to see their families because they were expected to provide everything to every one completely selflessly while also being told they don't do nearly enough by women, and women bitch and moan about it.
When men try to express themselves women attack them regularly and if the issue is related to women its even worse where the man will be told he is worhtless, an incel, that he is just bitter and thats why he should allow women to treat him like shit because apparently his only value is in what he can provide women so he better shape the fuck up or she will abandon him.
Now look at suicides and wonder to yourself why male suicides seemed to increase along side feminism. Also ask yourself why women hate men expressing themselves yet demand they express themselves but then turn around and punish them every time they have something to say. This has nothing to do with men bottling up their emotions, this has everything to do with society and especially women forcing them to ignore their feelings because they only see them as things instead of people (hence 80% of suicides being male and 80% of homeless being male and 97% of workplace accidents and deaths being male and 98% of combat deaths both military and civilian being male etc. etc. etc.).
Most Helpful Opinions
No. Not at all. In fact I think that this way of thinking is backwards, and I think that it contributes to the problem more than people realise. I think that the people who say these kinds of things also contradict themselves a lot, don't understand the way men really tick, and don't really think deeply about it at all. They hear other people say these things, it seems logical, so they parrot it and that's all.
People especially seem not to be able to understand real cause and effect.
I think that male suicide is really caused by two things:
1) men being emasculated
2) people not really giving a shit about men
Feminists are all for encouraging women to be strong and independent. They think that women should be badasses. Why? Strong and independent people are more likely to do well in life. Yet they want to encourage the opposite with men.
Today it starts as soon as they begin school, right the way up to adulthood. This encouraging boys/men to abandon traditional ideas of masculinity, labelling that "toxic". They raise weak men as a result. Surprise surprise - weak men are less likely to be able to deal with the challenges of life, overly sensitive men are more likely to feel sorry for themselves, and are therefore more likely to kill themselves.
The strange thing is that people don't seem to see that as we've been teaching boys to abandon traditional masculinity more and more, to be more sensitive, that it's unfair to expect them to be strong and that they don't need to be, the more men have killed themselves. This is what I mean by not understanding cause and effect. If any of this were true, as our society became more liberal over time, we should see less male suicide. Instead, since the 70s the male suicide rate has doubled in comparison to female suicide. In the 70s it was 2:1 male:female, now it's 4:1.
Along with this demonisation of masculinity and this push toward androgyny, we have "female correctness". 'The future is female" right? The way women act is viewed as the "correct" way to act. The way women think is the "correct" way to think. The way women deal with problems is the "correct" way to deal with problems. The idea that if only men were more like women the world would be a better place. But we're not the same, at all. We think differently, we deal with problems differently. Trying to get men to think, act and deal with problems the way women do is a failing strategy. This should be clear from all I just said in the above paragraph.
In fact even the idea that men fake macho bullshit is mostly a bullshit idea. It's based on the idea that men and women are the same but men are holding back. They call masculinity a "mask". It's not a mask. We're just not women.
This is why we have so many of these incels and MGTOW now. Normal women don't want to date men who aren't masculine. Those men have been taught that they shouldn't have to be strong, that they should be okay with being weak, that expectations are unfair. The best thing they could do to stop being where they are would be to improve themselves, that would be the strong thing to do. But instead they feel sorry for themselves and complain that the world is unfair, because that's what they've been taught to do. Women can do that, and it works. Feminism is all about that. It doesn't work for men.
Well if they are sensing emotional pain and holding that in, then yes they should come forward and tell someone how they are feeling. Speaking up about pain, depression, suicidal tendencies is a lot more encouraging than keeping silent about it. Staying silent only hurts you more and doesn't fix the core of the problem. This is why God gave us a tongue/speech, so we can express what our emotions are telling us to others. Lack of communications never helps anyone fix anything cause you can't fix something without acknowledging it.
Yes! Men sometimes think that masculinity is all about hiding their emotions. When it comes to talking about emotions, I think you are "manning up" more if you find the courage to speak about them, even if you think that your friends might ridicule you for it.
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
72Opinion
"Suicide statistics reveal that women are roughly three times more likely to attempt suicide. Compared to their male counterparts, women show higher rates of suicidal thinking, non-fatal suicidal behavior, and suicide attempts."
"When it comes to mental illness, the sexes are different: Women are more likely to be diagnosed with anxiety or depression, while men tend toward substance abuse or antisocial disorders, according to a new study published by the American Psychological Association.
Published online in APA’s Journal of Abnormal Psychology®, the study looked at the prevalence by gender of different types of common mental illnesses. The researchers also found that women with anxiety disorders are more likely to internalize emotions, which typically results in withdrawal, loneliness and depression. Men, on the other hand, are more likely to externalize emotions, which leads to aggressive, impulsive, coercive and noncompliant behavior, according to the study."
"– The most common mental health problem in women is depression. Twice as many women experience depression in their lifetime than men. Approximately 1 in 9 women 18 and older have had at least one major depressive episode in the past year."
"Compared with men, women are twice as likely to experience PTSD. Women are more likely to have hypervigilance, feel depressed, and have trouble feeling emotions; men are more likely to feel angry and have problems with alcohol or drugs."
"Women are twice as likely as men to experience generalized anxiety disorder or panic disorder."
I don't know, should women start showing their vulnerability and stop faking their "strong independent woman" bullshit?the reason why guys suck it up and push through is cos of how we are conditioned while growing up...
I had a not so pleasant childhood... there were many times during my childhood i wished i either died or someone was able to give me the strength to fight back or i could run away... but being drugged up by an abusive mother, having a violently abusive father
both physically and mentally manipulative and abusive to the point where they could convince trained professionals that they were the victims...
i can say from experience that what guys face and what they feel ok with letting out... is very different things...
if we let half of what we had building up a lot of us would break completely... and much of that inside us, we have no idea how to release it as it has become a part of us and how we cope if it's gone we feel so relieved that we do not know how to react...
it wasn't until after my 3 attempts of suicide, obviously failed attempts... i actually got help... odly the partner of almost 15 years who had cheated on me (which at the time i didn't know about)... while i was trying to cope with crap at work and my gran dying... and a world of other issues going on at the time... i shut down... then while talking to a shrink i didn't know what to say, who to trust.. i mean i was so used to my parents manipulating people to make me sound like a liar or to make it sound like something in my head... i didn't know
but after they got me to open up, i broke down... it felt like i had completely broken and i told them i just didn't want to fight anymore...
and yes there's been days where acting like i'm a rock in order to assure others i'm ok but in reality i'm a cat's hair away from dropping... but hold together cos switching off is less damaging to me than breaking down...
the macho shit some guys do though can be a defensive measureThe meme is poorly worded, as is still panders to the "macho" type.
This is a "chicken and the egg" issue, as men will come forward if they actually have a support system. In my experience, it doesn't exist, especially for a severely depressed man, and doubly so if he lacks the (rather significant) funding required for therapy.
Men will begin to come forward once society at large stops villifying them (as I see it). Being called a rapist for being male is significant. Being simply forced to live in an uncomfortable situation and told to "man up" lacks compassion. Men, and social constructs, seem to be devoid of compassion for men.
Some of us will come forward on their own, I especially think the "worthless" and "undesirable" ones do this already, since they often reject the popular definituon of a man. However, they are ridiculed and berated, insults and threats are hurled against them to try shutting them up, and I have seen this from both women and men. The cultural norms need to change in order for men to start being heard.Ever stop to think it was those men who were being vulnerable but spurned for doing so who were pushed further to the edge? Ever consider that the man feeling less than manly, was pushed closer to the edge? Did you consider that this man not feeling macho or whatever, rather, unworthy, is what had him walk off the edge?
To easily “masculinity” is defaulted to blame for ever negative in the world. Perhaps it is the lack of self dignity, self worth that pushes these same men over the edge. In other words, their lack of feeling “manly” any further.
Feeling worthless is not a “manly”’trait. It is same trait that makes even women successful and walking off the same edge.
Masculinity is not the problem and Mr Haig would know this if he wasn’t busy trying to stir the world into the division he presently is. Which isn’t masculine either. It is just self serving for his own self promotion to make himself appear better than everyone else... the trait of a lesser man. Equivalent to Adolf who felt lessor and stirred the the world too... and who also offed himself in the end. Pathetic.So what about the REAL MEN, that can show vulnerability, and then, Succeed? The ones that DON'T ACCEPT defeat!!
I grew up with what my dad said, and WTF with suicide? I was taught that I would get knocked down, beaten down, depending, but a REAL MAN, STANDS UP, and faces that, and fights it, and OVERCOMES THAT ADVERSITY!!
Now, it seems that when life gets 'TOUGH' so many just 'Check-out' and that is BULLSHIT!! WHO gave them the idea that just 'checking out' is a solution?
Yeah, I got beaten, and hit, but my dad taught to me FIGHT, and WIN!! There are winners, and Losers, and that is the state of things, and BIOLOGY!!!
I fight for everything I have, and never even consider punking out, and suicide!!I find this question in pore taste.. not cuz I don't support the men's movement... I think a man should be able to open up and v express themselves withought judgment...
What I find in pore taste is how you started with "find true strength" and "stop taking macho bullshit"
It seems obveous that you just want people to agree with your views and your not really asking a question...
If I say I don't agree with you for any reason... it immediately sounds like I'm saying I want men too be week and fake...
So although I agree with men opening up... I think this question is in pore taste cuz your not actually asking anything your forcing your views on others. At least in my opinionNo, I disagree with this sycophant. That sounds eerily similar to Ingsoc’s motto.
What he really means is that men should suppress their masculinity because it’s somehow “harmful” to men. Pure pseudoscientific drivel. How masculine a man chooses to be is none of his business. He’s acting as if masculinity is synonymous with negative traits, when masculinity isn’t synonymous with negative traits (correlation not causation). Even the most masculine men show vulnerability, so what he’s saying is also a false dichotomy.That sounds good on paper and I agree with that statement, however the problem is society and both genders subconsciously see men as rocks and cannot be vulnerable or show emotion when things get tough because then they are seen as weak and will be shunned by both society and their peers.
This is something I struggle with and have been battling since late last year. I have thought about ending it and even came up with a plan for it, but I always remember that I would have ended life without living it to my fullest potential and true end point. And to the very few that care about me, it makes me feel like shit on the damage I would do to them by carrying out that act.I was hiding my feelings and considering disappearing, since no matter what I do things always get worse and it's always a dead-end.
I talked about this with my fiancée and it didn't get better.
She wants to help and won't let me go away, but at the same time it's like I'm under house arrest and can't go anywhere on my own and have to answer regular calls from her.
Talking made everything worse, it basically set back everything I was working towards and killed the remaining leeway I had.
So I'd say that talking and being vulnerable can help but only with some kind of people.Really? Suicide is the thing that's killing most men under 50? I find that hard to believe.
And I don't support this. Like yes if you're suicidal I definitely think you should seek help.
However it almost sounds like he wants men to behave more like girls. I personally think this is what's turning men into soy boys that gets triggered by everything.
I think the idea of toxic masculinity is a bunch of BS. Bottom line is if you're suicidal get help. If you're not then there's no need to be "vulnerable."I always acted how I wanted to in respect to, if I wanted to cry then I do so without regard towards looking less “manly.” I pet and cuddle dogs, but at the same time I love fighting until I’m bloody in the face and dying.
There’s a duality I share.
I think most men are actually the same as me, but somehow we’re led to believe otherwise.
By the way, men die from suicide MORE than women because men actually choose methods that are guaranteed to kill them on the spot.
Women attempt it more, but choose less horrible methods because they want to preserve their looks even when they’re killing them selves.
Men don’t care for such things when they’re killing themselvesdoes he mention how people treat us after we show our vulnerability?
if you say 'awww what a lovely kitten' some idiot came up and call you fag. so you stop showing that you love kittens..
or when you cry.. people do mock you..
when you do those things.. you end up having more problems then you winge about.
its not in our best interest to show weakness. because whenever people see man having hard time.. they just mock.. or doesn't even care..
only woman have that privilage. when some girl cries on the street.. there will be some couple guys go on and try to solve what ever she has as problem..
if you do that as a man.. people will just walk pass you while taking video of you to mock later..
well there you have another reason for suicideNow this question is interesting. It essentially assumes a correlation between forced to be macho and male suicide. However, in this day and age gender fluidity is at an all time high for acceptance so if anything I think there's a reverse correlation. Social media and other new inventions have revolutionized social hierarchies and I think that they have actually been found to increase depression and suicide not just in men.
The Meyers-Briggs personality test has 16 personality types and 8 of them have the feeling trait. Their studies have found that men and women can have all 16 of these personalities equally. Essentially what that means is for the feeling vs thinking trait specifically men are just as likely to be feeling as women are to be thinking.Why would I intentionally show weakness? So she can use it against me if I piss her off? So she can lose her attraction & respect for me?
Hard pass.
Everytime I have tried to be vulnerable it has bit me in the ass, not even just in sexual relationships.
"The more you cry, the less I care" = my "loved ones" when I was young.
Fine, I won't at all! I'll just deal with any troubles in private, because nobody *actually* cares about *MY* feelings. I live or die mentally by my own strength of will.
And you know what? I've grown to like it. I feel a lot less than I used to and thus have a lot less emotional turmoil. Other people who know me irl just see graceful calm almost all the time.Yes, as long as you don't try to pressure people into being someone they don't want to be. Some men don't want to express their emotions for no other reason than just not finding it productive. That's the way I feel at least. It has nothing to do with "faking macho bullshit" or being afraid of looking weak, I just don't see the point in doing so. If something is making me sad, I don't want to talk about how it makes me feel, I want to talk about how to fix the problem! Otherwise, it's just a waste of time. The problem is still gonna be there after I've talked about my feelings. It's just pointless to me.
No, because it's women's demand that men show vulnerability which made men fall into it. A lot of masculinity is overcoming or minimizing hardship's emotional toll and women like it -- which makes men happy in turn and they are less likely to off themselves. When women mistakenly ask for vulnerability, men open themselves up to it and bear in in front of women, which leads to rejection, depression, and offing yourself. The whole problem is that they're *not* toughing it out anymore. It would be wonderful if women were interested in true emotionality and vulnerability in men, but they aren't, it makes them uncomfortable. They mistake the level of vulnerability they want to see for "true" vulnerability. But true vulnerability, is desperation, weakness, hopelessness, fury, anguish. They don't want to see that shit. They want a sprinkling of vulnerability to taste -- not the full dose.
I know that some men pretend to be extra tough but those people are idiots. That being said, those aren't the guys who are committing suicide.
Men commit suicide for other reasons, mostly work or finance related, other times love and relationship issues. These are the usual causes of mental pain for men.
I don't see how being soft and showing weakness wills solve the problem? what so that more people have the chance to hurt you? WHat a load of bollocks. Who comes up with this bs anyway, when a man shows emotions he just gets attacked or ignored. No one cares. Women lose attraction for you. Other people think of you as a burden instead of someone reliable. Anyone who says otherwise is a liar and doesn't live in the real world. If you have good friends then you can share your problems with them, same if you have supportive parents. But expecting comfort from society at large is laughable. We do not have p**sy privilege we need to understand that.- u
Yet go anywhere on that same site and u will find many that claim this but also use it as a weapon on others male and female even when it just comes to relationships I got so lucky finding a women that I could open upto but this is something many of my friends don't have the luxury
There was a lot less suicides when men were even more masculine in the past. Opening up never helped anyone. Every time I opened up or made myself vulnerable it back fired on me big time. Men are supposed to be stoic.
Men need to Man Up and realize they can take control of their destiny, by working hard, making the right choices, and not listening to women about feelings and such.Yes, this is one of the biggest problems in our society and I'm so glad someone brought it up. Women are always told it's okay to cry, but men get teased and made fun of for sharing their emotions, we have shit too ladies. We are forced to bottle that up and keep it in and it kills us inside, and that's a societal stigma that needs to change. Talking shit out is absolutely needed and we aren't allowed to do that according to society. Its ridiculous, and we need to acknowledge that and fix it.
Learn more
We're glad to see you liked this post.
You can also add your opinion below!