One needs the final say on matters that impact both: the executive decision-maker. However, the executive decision-maker should listen to the other person carefully and possibly even go with the other person's ideas at times if they're judged to have the better idea for the family.
For example, say a husband wants to send their kid to private school and the wife wants to send their kid to public school. There's no practical compromise here unless we want to send the kid to both somehow which is probably worse than either option.
Still, whoever is the executive (primary) decision-maker between the two should carefully listen to the other and possibly even go with the other person's idea at the end.
The main responsibility the executive decision-maker has is to take full responsibility for that decision. They should do everything possible to pay the costs and suffer any negative consequences of that decision. That's the responsibility they have in exchange for the final authority.
Most Helpful Opinions
I think ultimately it sound be the man. That sound a real man will absolutely take his wife's feelings and opinions into consideration but there's never actually a true 50/50. It doesn't work. Someone in the end has to make the decisions and it's proven for thousands of years that men are better more sound decision makers for the most part.
A patriarchal society/household is a good thing. Before angry feminists attack me, yes there are exceptions as always and no I'm not saying places like Iran do it correctly. That is an extreme
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
28Opinion
Marriage is a partnership, and partnerships work together, including making decisions.
I think your update said it best. Sure, a couple is "team" in a sense, but it's not 50/50. I can tell you that I've seen many instances where (husbands typically) have the wrong idea that they need their wife's input on everything and because of that decisions are dragged out and reversed and changed indefinitely because women are very much typically emotional thinkers who have a difficult time making decisions except in certain matters. Women do have valuable input and perspectives on some things but 9 times out of 10 men need to nut up and make the decision otherwise nothing gets accomplished.
Well , one needs to lead , I agree it can't be 50/50 that would never work , but it depends on the skillsets too of the individuals involved.
For example , someone like myself , I'm an investment manager this is also my interest ( or one of them ) , I would always run financials , as this is what I'm into , I'd love to discuss that , but in all my time I've never found someone as interested as me , if I did that would be great.
In general , it should be the man , with input from his wife , but someone has to make the final decision or nothing happens , and in this area , things need to be moving forward.
It's a relationship, not a business, you dummy.
If you are in a relationship and "primary decision maker" is talked about. You done fucked up, and you best get your weak ass outta there before it ends up black and blue and waiting for a restraining order.
A relationship is only a relationship when there is communication, commitment and responsibilities. You cannot make any sort of decision without at least two of the three anyway. Hence you need to establish the platform before getting into any relationship.
This is why most "marriages" and "cohabit" relationships don't last. Everyone wants to be key decision maker, without knowing what the fuck a relationship is actually about.
This is dependent on the couple. I only have experience with 2 relationships and neither led to marriage.
In my first relationship, she was the more level-headed one who could see the big picture better. We never really discussed "who is in charge". We just naturally deferred to her judgement.
The opposite was the case in my second relationship. Again, we never really discussed "who is in charge". It was more that, when under pressure, she would crack and I had to step in or else the issue would drag out too long. She did not like this because she felt like I undermined her, but I only ever did so when time was of the essence and there was no reasonable expectation she could clear her head in time. If time allowed, I simply told her we will discuss the issue when we can clear our heads (mostly me meaning her to clear her head).
Someone has to be able to take the lead. Ideally it shouldn't be a matter of dominance, but there will always be situations when one person has to make the decision.
Sorry ladies, but 99% of the time that's going to be the husband simply because 99% of the time he's the one who primarily gets covered when the shit hits the fan...equal say, work it out and work together to solutions. listen. might depend upon personalities and cultures.
What I try to do is get to a place where I can say "yes", most of the time, find agreement. It's not negotiation and it's not business. At least listen to her ideas and desires and understand them and find a way to get to a positive.
There's times I'll say..."not now", like with investment ideas and rarely do I give a hard "no".
equal is like 50 to 50 in u. s. senate. each veto each other. must have a way to tip... but can't go to court for a judge every argument daily.
the only possibility for decision making is one authority. so the solution is the thing i can't write.
It is never going to be a level playing field. Color schemes are typically more important to a wife than the husband. Spending decisions might be more important to the husband.
Rather than some theoretic framework couple decision is a more pragmatic cross product of many factors.
In Illiad (~1200 BC) one of the characters had to ask his wife's permission to give a gift. Couple decision making has never been as centralized as the question implies.
This sort of thing should be 110% determined by what works for the INDIVIDUAL COUPLE. Anyone who says that all couples "SHOULD" work one way or another on this is completely full of shit, should be TOLD they are full of shit, and should be completely disregarded on this point and frankly on most issues.
I'm a firm believer in the woman being the sole decision maker at all times.
No I think most successful marriages the decisions are made together where the knowledge of each is measured and compromise is used in the final decision.
as they please. I prefer partner relationships
Leaving the husband to make all the decisions is a recipe for a total disaster. Men never think things through, they are NOT big thinkers.
First, both must discuss, share their knowledge and experience about the things they have done in the past. Then they should make a decision. It doesn't matter 60/40, 80/20, 50/50 or 💯 % by husband.
Man is the head of his wife is what my Bible says
They should certainly discuss any decisions regarding any major purchases and any decisions that would affect the both of them.
This may be an unpopular opinion, but it is my strongly held belief that men and women are equal and that a marriage relationship should be a partnership.
50/50 Nobody should have more say than the other.
To me it depends on who will benefit or use the decision the most. Say kitchen items or layouts or lawn mowers. Things like vacation homes and trips would entail some mutual agreements.
Learn more
We're glad to see you liked this post.
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions