I'm actually rather educated on the matter I just disagree in regards to what today's progressive and liberal society describes as gender. Gender and sex have been interchangeable throughout history up untill now. Even the concept (word) transgender is new. Society changes it's philosophy and belifes on what things are, but this doesn't mean they are accurate nor does it mean I have to agree with such construed ideologies. š
So why is it that when we DNA test a bone, we don't say stuff like "we don't know it's gender as it can be identified as a dickless man". Why do scientist say that she was a woman. Sex and gender are same thing.
I'm always skeptical when someone says "scientists say". What exactly did "scientists" say? When? Who?
The reason I'm skeptical is because in my experience, most people have no fucking idea what scientists think about a wide variety of topics - this one most definitely included.
You don't seem so. Especially because you keep mixing the two. But about the "it's a new word" and "same usage" thing. Look I don't know where you're from or how good your education system is. But it's a pretty well known thing that there are new words being invented every day. That's why writing dictionaries is so hard and why they have to update them so often. We get new words/They add meaning to em/Take the meaning away from em to fit the current world. Words evolve with society. In my opinion, your statement there is the dumbest thing I've heard. Was the word "there" present in 2000 bc? Or the word "car" in 4 bc? Every word is made up. For logical reasons. Your excuses for being a horrible human being are pretty weak my friend.
So technically there are only two sex. Okay another scenario, if I say I am a woman and want to go to a female toilet, would you let me just because I say so?
@Twenty2 I think we've already established that fact. And about the toilets. Like many other people suggested, I'd make gender neutral toilets. The problem you are trying to bring up. It's not about which toilet is for what gender, it's about people. Assholes, to be more specific.
Heather E Heying is a biologist. What they say is what I stayed in my argument. When they say it is in a few books they've written and in a discussion called the freethinkers at PSU.
If it's your argument that definitions of words are changing each day, then why is it not possible for my definition to be accurate and the definition progressives present to the table deemed inaccurate.
It's obvious words are made up, and those words are used to help communication between individual. So I I come up to anyone and ask, what's your gender. If it's a woman I expect them to say female. And if it's a man I expect them to say male. Nothing more nothing less. Though because women are females, and men are males. It's not nessesary to ask for gender in the first place. Assuming gender is perfectly fine because gender is associated with biologically identity physical properties. Whether it's a penis a vagina boobs or an Adams apple. Gender is not a abstract construct that can be thrown around. You are female I am male. At least supposedly you are female.
It is not Wong of me nor should you be in anyway, offended or defensive of me saying that gender is misrepresented as the abstract concept many present it as. instead gender should be identified as sex as gender and sex are the same.
I'm simply stating that if anyone feels differently from the gender they are. They should use gender energy to express that. Not the concept of gender as a whole. Feminine, Masculine.
@Korand I'm sorry, I'm not going to sit through a video that's almost two hours long just to try to spot the point at which you think they agree with you. Will you tell us the point in this video at which they agree with what you've said? I ask because what you've said isn't well supported by the scientific community.
I'm not gonna waste my time if you aren't willing to spend yours. Unless you watch the few minutes into the video, to find what she says this discussion is over. @HungLikeAHorsefly
No, @Korand you're being intellectually lazy. It's not my job to make your case for you. If you want to use a YouTube video to support your case, the _very_least_ you can do is point out which part of it you think applies to this conversation. If you really think this video sums up the point you're trying to make, then you should already know what parts of it are relevant and which aren't.
Unless, of course, this video doesn't really support your argument and you're hoping I won't go through it in order to save face.
Did y'all miss the fact that I am not responding anymore? Bye? Go away? Stop commenting under this and try to do something meaningful with your life cuz you're clearly failing. I will ignore further comments (as I've done as of now)/report them for just simply showing up in my feed and bothering me.
@HungLikeAHorsefly Dude you've got better things to do than *argue* with this idiot. He literally couldn't even understand what I was writing. Be back in 3 years when his mental development is at 16 not 13..
It is but shouldn't be. It's wrong to declare that gender is mental not biological. The same way you possibly could be white and I am black. I can't think I'm white, nor could you think your black. You can inculcate black culture. And the same as I. But we will never both truly be the opposite race. That is a biological concept not an abstract one. And anything pertaining to genes is such. Wether it's gender, height, weight, race, etc.
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
27Opinion
Gender to me now is what you are physically sexually and mentally.
Gender is genetic hormone balance and depending on percentage is the gender
I am and have always been 50/50.
Dude you should firstly educate yourself on the difference between sex and gender.
Sex is defined by your genitalia, while gender is fluid.
I'm actually rather educated on the matter I just disagree in regards to what today's progressive and liberal society describes as gender. Gender and sex have been interchangeable throughout history up untill now. Even the concept (word) transgender is new. Society changes it's philosophy and belifes on what things are, but this doesn't mean they are accurate nor does it mean I have to agree with such construed ideologies. š
So why is it that when we DNA test a bone, we don't say stuff like "we don't know it's gender as it can be identified as a dickless man". Why do scientist say that she was a woman. Sex and gender are same thing.
Lmao, yes.
Anatomy, and physiology determine a person's gender/sex. Not the person's mental state.
I'm always skeptical when someone says "scientists say". What exactly did "scientists" say? When? Who?
The reason I'm skeptical is because in my experience, most people have no fucking idea what scientists think about a wide variety of topics - this one most definitely included.
You don't seem so. Especially because you keep mixing the two.
But about the "it's a new word" and "same usage" thing.
Look I don't know where you're from or how good your education system is. But it's a pretty well known thing that there are new words being invented every day. That's why writing dictionaries is so hard and why they have to update them so often.
We get new words/They add meaning to em/Take the meaning away from em to fit the current world. Words evolve with society.
In my opinion, your statement there is the dumbest thing I've heard.
Was the word "there" present in 2000 bc? Or the word "car" in 4 bc?
Every word is made up. For logical reasons.
Your excuses for being a horrible human being are pretty weak my friend.
@Twenty2 When a situation requires dna testing (of a bone) they're looking for your sex. Since you can't tell the persons gender by a bone lol
When you take DNA test of a trans man to woman! Does it comes out as a man or a woman?
@Twenty2 You'd get his sex.
How are you still confused about this.
So technically there are only two sex. Okay another scenario, if I say I am a woman and want to go to a female toilet, would you let me just because I say so?
@Twenty2 I think we've already established that fact. And about the toilets. Like many other people suggested, I'd make gender neutral toilets.
The problem you are trying to bring up. It's not about which toilet is for what gender, it's about people. Assholes, to be more specific.
They identify themselves as good humans tho!
@HungLikeAHorsefly
Heather E Heying is a biologist. What they say is what I stayed in my argument. When they say it is in a few books they've written and in a discussion called the freethinkers at PSU.
Which can be found here.
https://youtu.be/VCrQ3EU8_PM
@ACupOfFrosting
If it's your argument that definitions of words are changing each day, then why is it not possible for my definition to be accurate and the definition progressives present to the table deemed inaccurate.
It's obvious words are made up, and those words are used to help communication between individual. So I I come up to anyone and ask, what's your gender. If it's a woman I expect them to say female. And if it's a man I expect them to say male. Nothing more nothing less. Though because women are females, and men are males. It's not nessesary to ask for gender in the first place. Assuming gender is perfectly fine because gender is associated with biologically identity physical properties. Whether it's a penis a vagina boobs or an Adams apple. Gender is not a abstract construct that can be thrown around. You are female I am male. At least supposedly you are female.
It is not Wong of me nor should you be in anyway, offended or defensive of me saying that gender is misrepresented as the abstract concept many present it as. instead gender should be identified as sex as gender and sex are the same.
I'm simply stating that if anyone feels differently from the gender they are. They should use gender energy to express that. Not the concept of gender as a whole. Feminine, Masculine.
Not male and female.
Do you Object that a man has a penis and a woman has a Vagina?
@Korand I'm sorry, I'm not going to sit through a video that's almost two hours long just to try to spot the point at which you think they agree with you. Will you tell us the point in this video at which they agree with what you've said? I ask because what you've said isn't well supported by the scientific community.
I'm not gonna waste my time if you aren't willing to spend yours. Unless you watch the few minutes into the video, to find what she says this discussion is over. @HungLikeAHorsefly
No, @Korand you're being intellectually lazy. It's not my job to make your case for you. If you want to use a YouTube video to support your case, the _very_least_ you can do is point out which part of it you think applies to this conversation. If you really think this video sums up the point you're trying to make, then you should already know what parts of it are relevant and which aren't.
Unless, of course, this video doesn't really support your argument and you're hoping I won't go through it in order to save face.
Did y'all miss the fact that I am not responding anymore? Bye? Go away? Stop commenting under this and try to do something meaningful with your life cuz you're clearly failing.
I will ignore further comments (as I've done as of now)/report them for just simply showing up in my feed and bothering me.
@HungLikeAHorsefly Dude you've got better things to do than *argue* with this idiot. He literally couldn't even understand what I was writing. Be back in 3 years when his mental development is at 16 not 13..
Yeah! Guys please stop. Trying to educate dumb b***hes is not gonna work.
There are only two genders. Male and Female.
Gender is used to describe an abstract concept.
It is but shouldn't be. It's wrong to declare that gender is mental not biological. The same way you possibly could be white and I am black. I can't think I'm white, nor could you think your black. You can inculcate black culture. And the same as I. But we will never both truly be the opposite race. That is a biological concept not an abstract one. And anything pertaining to genes is such. Wether it's gender, height, weight, race, etc.
Yeah
Sex is between ya legs. Gender is between ur ears
Gender is the identity of a person
Female
Male and Female
These arenāt real.