Who comes to mind as the biggest mass murderer in history?

[Anonymous]

I am curious who comes to mind first. Without looking it up guess.

Hitler

Stalin

Mao

Trump

Other - please specify

Updates

1 y

Just a FYI I put Trump in as a joke. So far three people are either voting to go along with the joke OR they really believe Trump is a mass murderer.

I would like to believe the former but I’ve seen so much leftist stupidity over the last years it’s likely the latter.

I will say I’m surprised more people didn’t vote for Hitler. The whole world (rightfully) knows about the Nazi Holocaust. But fewer people know about China’s Great Leap Forward and/or Holodomor.

Updates

1 y

Also I should of titled this as “Mass Murders committed under Modern Dictators”.

Genghis Kahn killed at least 40 million people. But that was a much different comparison. He was more about conquest. This is about regimes.

[MCheetah]

It's Mao Zedong. Killed 50+ million people because he just had to grow the rice too close. No one cares about them though, because they're not Westerners.

Hitler doesn't come close to being one of the most murderous people in history. Genghis Khan and Alexander the Great killed more than him, not that he didn't do a lot of evil. But Hitler is like number ten on the list of mass murderers, if that.

Though I wonder if you put Trump on here to troll the idiots, or if you're one of the idiots yourself.

[Asker]

I put Trump there as a joke. I wanted to see who would vote for him. I wasn’t disappointed; three votes and counting. I just wonder if those people are trolling or they really believe it.

You are dead on about Mao. Funny I seldom heard about his insane crap in grade school and after. I heard all about Hitler. I also heard occasionally about Stalin. But when Stalin was brought up it was usually in regards to the eastern front in WW2. Not once was I ever taught about Holodomor where he intentionally starved 7 million Ukrainians.

[MCheetah]

Thanks for the MHO.

[Avicenna]

It's Mao.

And what idiot sees Trump as a mass murderer? He avoided starting wars and it's Joe Biden whose policies will result in reduced food supply and higher food prices.

[Asker]

I put Trump in as a joke. I wanted to see who would vote that he’s mass murderer. Three morons so far and counting.

I would like to believe they are being facetious trolls. But seriously some people really are dumb enough to believe that.

[Avicenna]

Some are apparently. I do agree that being facetious in a normal world would be appropriate, but, unfortunately, we don't live in one.

[Avicenna]

Thanks for the MHO

[Asker]

Yeah I wasn’t originally planning to put him in as an option when I put together this poll. But then it hit me as an idea/joke.

[Avicenna]

Looks like the Great Leap Forward (1958-62) killed an estimated 45 million people, and Mao is estimated to have killed around 65 million.

[Asker]

And I was never taught that in public school or college.

[Avicenna]

I'm not surprised. I only knew about that history from reading books about Chinese history when I was a kid.

[AviatorTom]

My first guess would be Mao, for the 100 million who died during his brutal reign as a communist state in China. Second would be Stalin, who I believe was responsible for 12 million deaths in the USSR. Third would be Hitler, who was responsible for the Holocaust plus indirectly for other deaths in WWII.

[Asker]

Yep spot on.

Funny thing is the older generations know this. But millennials and especially gen Z’rs are mostly clueless about how horrifying communism was.

[IAteTwoFullHams]

Actual *murderer*, like they did it with their own hands, would probably be Elizabeth Bathory or maybe Uday Hussein.

In terms of "political leader who caused the most slaughter," that would be Genghis Khan.

[Asker]

Yeah I could of worded this better. Should of said “dictator regimes”.

That’s interesting to know about Genghis Kahn though.

[MCheetah]

Elizabeth Bathory (Queen of the Vampires) only killed 600 or so women, though. There have been more prolific mass murderers throughout history. Jack the Ripper and Pedro Lopez killed a little more than that.

[Asker]

@MCheetah those are serial killers. Separate topic. But thanks for your feedback.

[Alexandrubaschet08]

Stalin, even if i know Mao have more crimes.
For me Stalin and Russia is the country that i asociate whit blood, hunger, death, poverty, cold.

[Asker]

Stalin was a very close second to Mao. But when you account for China’s Great Leap Forward that killed upward of 55 million people Mao takes 1st place.

Now the Great Leap Forward wasn’t setup to intentionally kill people (for the most part). But the fact that Mao and his comrades couldn’t own up to the government mandated cataclysmic mistake makes him very guilty in my opinion.

[Alexandrubaschet08]

i know, Mao whas to stupid to lead the country, but history still allowd

[jshm2]

Leopold II of Belgium - killed around 30 million Blacks

[Asker]

Interesting. Do you have a reference link?

[Harbringer26]

Djinghis Khan comes to mind. He lowered the earth's temperature by one degree from all his slaughter after all. Donald Trump hasn't murdered anyone as far as I know.

[Bluemax]

I believe it's Mao.

[Chazmatazz269]

Followers of Christ. No competition.

[Asker]

Do you have statistics on that?

[Chazmatazz269]

Of course not. I can cite an article that makes a compelling argument, but since Christians did the majority of their pillaging, raping and murdering before mankind was recording births and deaths reliably, and long before we ever considered compiling statistics on crime, there’s very little proof that they’ve ever done anything wrong, ever. It’s also widely understood that history is written by the victors. Since no single group or organization throughout human history has won more than the church of Christianity, any thought that they’ve ever done wrong is borderline ridiculous. Isn’t it?
Ell oh ell!
I’ll try to find that article, if you’d like, but i can’t satisfy any demand for empirical evidence given the historical standards, if that’s what you’re after.

[Asker]

No statistic truly exists for that in aggregate. Sure you can find examples of the Spanish Inquisition and colonizers.

However if want to get into mass murders committed under doctrines (more recent ones too) than I recommend checking this out en.m.wikipedia.org/.../List_of_wars_and_anthropogenic_disasters_by_death_toll

[Asker]

Funny how communist regimes top the list there. Should I blame that all on Karl Marx? I am definitely no fan of Karl Marx. However he did write that violent insurrection would be necessary to upend capitalism. Jesus however NEVER condoned murder in any of his teachings.

Obviously we can go down the rabbit hole here. But really man at 48 you should think twice about blurting out something as stupid and ignorant as “Followers of Christ” are responsible for mass murders. You might sound cool saying that as a 19 year college freshman on a liberal college campus. But you know better now.

Anyway if course there are horrible people in history who identified as “Christian” who committed atrocities. But those people were evil to begin with and just used Christianity as a cover to justify their crimes when it was societally acceptable to do so. Communism and Fascism (hitler was no Christian) only did this crap more overtly and in more recent times.

[Chazmatazz269]

You are mistaken. The earliest mandatory recordings of birth and death records began in 1563. These records were mandatory per the Catholic church. So non-Christians, the targets of the Crusades, didn’t necessarily comply. In addition, the earliest crusades began FOUR HUNDRED YEARS earlier than this mandate. Reliably accurate records weren’t kept in any form for another two and a half centuries. That’s 650 years in which the best we can do is ESTIMATE birth and death tolls based on existing records and mathematical valuations. It’s widely considered that the Christian campaigns to expand mandatory religion has had the most devastating impact on human population of all time. It simply can’t be empirically proven because nobody has been slaughtering people en masse longer or better than Christians. The early bird gets to eat the worm, name it and tell everyone that it tried to kill the bird first. Ell oh ell!

[Asker]

And Genghis Kahn didn’t kill 10% of the worlds population?

Again I don’t deny that false Christians did horrible things in history. But you are acting like the goal of all
missionaries was to kill people.

What concerns me more are the ideologies that have killed tens of millions of people in the 20th century. We now live in a modern supposedly civilized world. Yet mass murder and genocide is still happening in recent times. Of course everybody immediately thinks of the Nazi Holocaust when it comes to 20th century genocide (and we should be educated about that). But funny I was never taught about Holodomor in public school where the Soviet Union intentionally starved 7 million Ukrainians to death.

Now why is that? Oh I just for the record I did have a history teacher in HS tell the classroom that “Christianity kills” one time. Your sentiment is not unfamiliar or unheard of.

[MCheetah]

@Chazmatazz269
Dude... I hate most religions myself, and even I think that answer is some lame edgelord 2009 atheist BS. Come on.

[Chazmatazz269]

I’m not an atheist, and i’m not acting like anything. I literally never said that every missionary was killing people. I never said anything about missionaries at all! Ell oh ell! You’re trying to change my words to suit YOUR argument. That’s called a “straw man” argument. You don’t have to like what i have to offer, but it is widely enough accepted that there are academic debates on the subject. Again, i have offered an article that you still haven’t accepted multiple times. This plainly suggests you’re not interested in challenging your own biases. I knew better than to respond to one of these chicken shit anonymous posts. Don’t bother to respond. I have no use for the willfully ignorant.

[Asker]

Send me the link. I didn’t downvote you by the way despite not liking your response.

Just a fyi I go anon on virtually all questions I post (ideologically charged or not) unless I want to be seen. That way I get more honest responses from both people I like and dislike.

If they already know my viewpoints then it will color their thinking in their responses. My friends will be nicer if they disagree or cheer me on even more if they like what I post. People I don’t like will just double down or hesitate to say something positive if they coincidentally agree.

But I want to see what people are really thinking.

[FunkyMonkee]

How many people did Trump have killed?

[Asker]

I put that up as a joke. But I really wanted to see who is dumb enough to vote for it. I would like to believe the three people who voted Trump so far are just trolls. But something tells me there are people dumb enough out there to believe he’s a mass murderer.

[FunkyMonkee]

I KNOW there are!! Three guys that used to be associated with my band still think he's the 2nd coming of Hitler!! How fucking stupid can ANYONE be to even CONSIDER thinking that?

[Asker]

Pure derangement. Obama had more people killed than Trump when it comes down to it.

I was expecting lots of people to vote Hitler. I wouldn’t blame them because there was a time I believed that too.

Truth is Hitler is number 3 in modern history. It actually goes Mao > Stalin > Hitler.

[Exterminatore]

@Funky

Less than Hillary did.

[Exterminatore]

@both

What I think it is, is that left wing types do not like strict following of rules and laws. They do not like anything that sounds like traditionalism. They seem to view an orderly society as much too constrictive and therefore equate anyone who is in favor of law and order instead of a free for all as a fascist. Anyone who uses a drone to kill and Iranian general is a fascist and deadly warmonger, never mind that general helped plot attacks on American bases that killed Americans. It’s more important to hold hands and sing kum by ya.

Anyone who thinks citizens should not compete against foreign nationals for jobs is certainly a racist. Anyone should just be able to come at any time. No questions asked.

These types of things scare the crap out of feeling oriented soft and sensitive leftist types. They see these things as being Nazism and cannot bear some of these concepts in their soft and sensitive girly little hearts. The slightest call for law and order and slimmest measures to curtail degeneracy are simply unbearable to them. It’s because they are weak and cowards.

The rest of us however understand reality and try to be objective.

[FunkyMonkee]

@Exterminatore Nearest I know, his count is ZERO!! I have no idea how many hundreds she had killed/suicided, or how many she ended up eating!

[Asker]

@Exterminatore pretty close to the truth there. Their Marxist semantics are incredible like calling “speech as violence” or giving puberty blockers to children is “saving lives” (that is the most disgusting thing I’ve ever heard in my life).

[Rangers]

Joe Biden

[Asker]

Well he is good at murdering economies. No doubt about that.

[Exterminatore]

Chairman Mao.