If native Americans had conflict w New world Americans as Palestine has conflict w Israel?

[Anonymous]

Would liberal Americans be willing to give them back their land? Return to their roots in Europe, Mexico, Africa etc

Our ancestors stole their land, the story isn't much different from Palestine yet so many Americans are protesting against Israel for doing something they did to native Americans? Am I wrong?

Updates

6 mo

Clearly no liberals are reading this question... 🤔

[CupcakeTheDestroyer]

You’re right, Israel and America are similar in that they’re colonized nations. The european population colonized this land after it was so easily done because plague was sweeping through North America. Plymouth Rock settlers were able to settle in an already-made native American camp when they arrived, a ghost town where they put all the infected corpses into a mass grave and then essentially took all their stuff for themselves. The reason that doesn’t happen now is a bit complicated. Part of it was just forcibly annexing the remaining land of surviving tribes over the last century. Trail of tears and all that. Native americans currently make up less than 1% of the total population in the US. They’ve been whittled down to nothing, they have no hope of reclaiming their land and now currently live on reservations with super inflated grocery prices and are lucky to have running, clean water where they can find it. They’re fucked. But we didn’t tell them escape routes and then bomb them, the intention was never genocide as far as I’m aware, just land claims.

[Anonymous]

Israel didn't take anything from Palestinians, "Palestine" was a fiction made up by the British in the 13th century as a way to irritate the Jews and try to drive them out of their land.

Also Spain took the land from Indians, not Americans. Then Mexico took the land from Spain, and Americans took the land from Mexico.

[Avicenna]

The two conflicts are not analogous.

Jews are indigenous to Israel and have lived there for thousands of years. European settlers in the Americas were not. Large numbers of Israeli Jews are descended from Jews the Arabs discriminated against and kicked out.

The Palestinians are Jordanians or came from other areas outside Israel.

The European conquest of the Americas came about because if imported diseases like smallpox, but also because pre-Columbian rulers like the Aztecs were very brutal and their enemies were happy to cooperate with Europeans against them.

Anyone who claims that there was perfect harmony among Muslims and Jews prior to the arrival of Holocaust survivors upon the founding of the State of Israel is attempting to rewrite history. Not only were there pogroms by Muslims against Jews in Arab countries, there are were in what became the State of Israel. And Jews who had to leave Arab countries had their land and other property there confiscated without any compensation.

[madhatters4]

i don't know. i think this is an impossible question to really answer because there are so many conditions

would we be giving back the land their ancestors originally lived on

would we be displacing those who moved there

would LIBERALS be willing to give them the land back? some probably would, some would probably look for an alternative solution, some would not consider it. but that's the nature of it. i think we could put conservatives in same boat. some for, some looking for an alternative and some against it

[madhatters4]

to be clear this isn't really a political ideology issue. we've seen the same hedging on both sides for decades because it isn't a political issue for us. it's a diplomatic issue for us.

[Lliam]

Except Israel was never the "Jewish" homeland. They weren't there first, so they have no claim to it.

Besides, Muslims, Christians and Jews all lived there as friends and neighbors for hundreds of years before the false Jewish Zionists started invading, stealing and terrorizing.

https://www.youtube.com/embed/gIX368TtOJs

[Asker]

So Americans should give back the land to natives?

[YesterdaysChild]

Israel didn't steal anyone's land. It was promised to them by God. The Palestinians are basically squatters. Now, say if you were given a house by your grandfather. But you can't take possession of it currently. Then squatters move in. Are you going to just give them the house or are you going to take it back?

[Potteplante]

There's a difference in between my grandfather and god.
The latter just a friction of imagion - that has resulted in SUFFERING of million and million of people throughout history. If there was a god - I'd never listen to such a vindictive, egocentic, evil being like the Christian God.

[YesterdaysChild]

@Potteplante And you wonder why the world is in such a mess. 🤔🤔🤔

[Potteplante]

@yesterdayschild no I don't wonder why. Christians are a part of what has messed up the world.

[YesterdaysChild]

@Potteplante I guess it depends on who is considered Christian. There are a lot of false religions out there, and through the ages. It will all come out in the end when they are judged.
Matthew 7:21-23

21 “Not everyone who says to Me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ shall enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of My Father in heaven. 22 Many will say to Me in that day, ‘Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in Your name, cast out demons in Your name, and done many wonders in Your name?’ 23 And then I will declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from Me, you who practice lawlessness!’

[Agagagagaga]

@Potteplante “ no I don't wonder why. Christians are a part of what has messed up the world.”

Um... why are you bringing up Christians in a conversation about Jews and Muslims having problems with one another?

Could it be because you’re just a stupid, bigoted Christian hater?

[Anonymous]

Them protesting against Israel, is the same as them protesting against Trump. They can't think for themselves, so the left-wing media Gives them THEIR opinions.

[Anonymous]

Isn't it currently happening in Ukraine? It belongs to Russia but for some reason, the looney left feels one group of terrorists can kill citizens for what they apparently feel is their land but another group of terrorists can't?

[Opinion Owner]

In answer to your question, whoever has the fire power to take land or keep it, has a right to that land. It's not complicated.

[Anonymous]

It’s not just the issue of land though in the West Bank they are still keeping people under military occupation. I live near a reservation and they can all come and go as the please.

[Asker]

It's a what if question... What if the native Americans wanted the land back?

[Anonymous]

Liberals will talk about reparations, open boarders and colonisation but but won't pay reparations from their own pocket, won't open their home to illegals and refugees and won't move back to Europe