Most Helpful Guy
I think you are posting extremes. I have dated too many women to prefer make up over natural. Here are some photos that I think reflect reality;
Most Helpful Girl
Yeah, I've always thought this was ridiculous. Some men say they prefer no makeup but...
1) they will still think the girl with makeup is more attractive, women who wear makeup usually get approached more and receive more male attention.
2) most can't tell the difference between "natural" makeup and legitimately no makeup. I've seen men post pictures of girls who clearly have makeup on and say "see! girls look so much better without it!" Lol
In reality, makeup is designed to enhance beauty, that's the whole point. So naturally, nearly every woman will look better with it. Women who don't wear makeup get told they are unattractive, tired, lazy, etc. but then when they DO wear it, they're "fake" and "lying to men." Haha! We can't win either way so you might as well just do what you want. :)
*Note: not all men are like this, it's mainly a phenomenon I've noticed online. Guys I know in real life don't seem to care whether or not a woman wears makeup.