Gym butt vs natural plump one?

For guys that like a reasonably plump (not massive) butt, would you be understanding of a girl who’s butt was a result of working out?

Personally, my natural plump butt is gone and I’ll never get it back. I have to workout quite often to try to make it look semi normal. But working out all the time isn't always possible, especially with my knees hurting, it’ll probably get so bad when im older that I can't work out anymore. And even then, because of the reason my natural butt is gone, even with consistent workouts, the resultes change quite often.

So would you be understanding of my butt being completely flat and saggy one day and then plump a couple days later? It fluctuates quite often.
Gym butt vs natural plump one?
Post Opinion