4 basic problems with J-wish claim. What are your thoughts text below?

[imran_]

PROBLEM 1. They claim to be the descendants from the tribes of 12 sons of Prophet Yakub, and that the land of Philistine was supposedly theirs.

But there is no proof that the modern day J-ws are the actual descendants of those tribes.

PROBLEM 2. There were other people in the land, besides the 12 tribes. Don't they have their rights too?

PROBLEM 3. There are many Arab MusIims and Christ-ians with J-wish ancestry, including in Saudi Arabia... Apostle ﷺ himself had J-wish companions who became MusIims. What about their rights? Their rights are equally weak, as they too can't prove their ancestry to the 12 tribes.

PROBLEM 4. No one makes such claims but Z! on! sts.

MusIims ruled Spain and lndia. The Greek king Alexander ruled parts of Egypt. Britain ruled America. But no MusIim claims Spain now. Greeks don't claim Egypt. And Britain doesn't claim America. But Z! on! sts think it's right to claim the land their ancestors may have ruled 3000 years ago.

[Anonymous]

*I never fully read questions*

Don't think for a second this site represents an entire world view 🙂It doesn't. It's a tiny, tiny proportion of people mainly coming on here for something to do and to ask dating questions. In the grand scale of things, it represents nothing ok.

People care, the media isn't reporting it and the images of the masses peacefully protesting "No" are being downplayed on an scary scale and that's if they get a mention. Doesn't mean People are not voicing the obvious, it just means you can't hear their cry. People care ok.

You wanna know how I know this? Almost half of the Palestinian population are children. Noone in their right mind can condone atrocities to children, that's how I know in my gut that huge numbers of people are against this war without seeing any facts or figures. It's instinctive in our bones to protect children. This is all the evidence I need to believe that masses of people simply cannot agree.

Eventually, the media is gonna catch up, because the humanitarian protestors are not going anywhere. I know it's frustrating, but keep the faith. Because in times of trouble it's all you can do. Everything has its place and time. Pray for Palestine ✨

[Opinion Owner]

Thanks for the top comment. Keep the faith. I know it's beyond frustrating, but it's the healthiest and most logical thing to do. The more dire things seem, the more you must believe everything's gonna work out 🇵🇸💪✌️

[imran_]

Yes thank you 🍃

[Anonymous]

The muslim Arabs colonised Israel and exiled the Jews all over Europe, the Middle east, Asia and North Africa. These Jews only really married within their own community. Genetic testing with ancient Hebrew graves and sabra Jews, asenkani Jews, Sephardic Jews and Berber Jews find them to be clearly descended from ancient hebrews and genetic comparison to the Samaritians who are also Hebrews of the 12 tribes of Israel who left Egypt in the Exodus with moses, splitting with the Jews after the reign of King Solomon into two separate kingdoms of Samaria (samaritians) & Judea (Jews) show the samaritians to be genetically related to the Jews and ancient hebrews. Eithiopian Jews though African have also been shown to be genetically close to ancient and samaritians though black.

Why can a non-muslim people not self rule themselves in the lands of their ancestors and the lands they live in without persecution from their Muslim overlords? Such as Jews and samaritians in Israel. Coptics in Egypt. Christians, Hindus, Buddhists, seiks, zoastrians in Pakistan and Afghanistan. Kurt's, assyrians, Armenians, zoastrians in Turkey. Christians and Jews in Ethiopia and Somalia?

[boggboss]

Look I don't even have a dog in the race and for the most part disagree with how the Israeli givement operate but ur last point is not relevant here as the difference is that Jews currently own the land they are claiming before they was their the argument might have mattered but at this point its already theirs

[Anonymous]

Well, despite all of that; at least they have a claim that goes back before the 1950s. Unlike the Palestinians. You would think that the Muslims would stop attacking people who have a covenant with God for their protection. An shaa Allah, He is willing Israel to exist; best not to go against His people.

[imran_]

The irony is the book you are talking about can't prove its authenticity. So how do you know what's written from God or from those people who Corrupted their book with their own hand for little exchange.

[Opinion Owner]

I am not talking about any books.

[Dargil]

I am strictly pro-Israel. No exceptions. No whatabouts.

[KostasKouvalis]

1 biggest problem with Muslims' claims. They claim to be peaceful and tollarant people who are victims, when the exact opposite is true

[Anonymous]

'You can't even write the word Jew, even the actual Nazis has that much respect' genuinely a quote from one of my Jewish associates