Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions
Engagement Ring she is obligated to give back if she ends things, that's considered breach of contract. Engagement Rings signify a Legal Contract. This has been disputed in courts many times. Only time woman loses is if guy was abusive in anyway (which Judges always say why would you want the ring unless to Pawn it or a reminder of type of guy to stay away from).
It also seems like if you buy people gifts to expect them to like you and stick with you even when you don't. It's makes you look bad if you are well off enough to buy a lot of these type of gifts then drop it and move on. If you were broke and doing this then your stupid. Simple.
can you send me private messages? i will say something
You'd have to fallow me first.
Clarification: Engagement Rings are legally classed as "conditional". If you marry, they cease to be "conditional" as the attached obligation was met via marriage.
Although an engagement ring is a grey area. If you made false promises to get the engagement you shouldn’t get the ring back. Otoh if she broke off the engagement & you did nothing wrong she owes it back.
Possession is the Law, gift given no longer the givers property!!! Doesn't matter who has the receipt. Engagement Ring is the only item that is Contractually based on the Relationship. Everything else you better state in writing this is a loan while we are together only!!!
Which you wouldn't give away until you sealed the deal with them. That would be foolish.
People are foolish, people make stupid mistakes like that
I grew up where u don’t show love with hugs or words. If my dad wanted to show affection, he bought me something. So that’s how I am in my relationship. I do hug and say I love u, but gifts are needed.
I grew up dirt poor, where my parents said love you every day and we had lots of family events. So when people get me stuff it is super awkward.