Obviously most of us should want our close friends to have a great personality, but what about looks?
Maybe you care about status, maybe you'll be jealous, maybe you'll feel tempted, maybe you really don't have any preference, but think about it a little. This is your good friend.
Personally, if I really think about it, one doesn't outweigh the other, but I'm wondering if you guys and girls have a stronger opinion than I do.