I'd be okay with 1-5 and 8. The 0 isn't healthy, and some 1's may not be healthy (if they dieted to that size), while other girls are a one naturally, and that's fine with me. I've dated a girl who was about a 5.5 on that chart, but that's about as far as I'd go. 6 & 7 are too big, and 9 is gross and masculine to me.
Heightwise? I probably wouldn't deny any girl outright based on her height, but I generally prefer to be taller than she is (I'm 5' 10", so I'm taller than most women anyway), and I have a bit of a preference for petite girls, though most of my GFs have been around average height (5'2"-5'6").
I'm fairly small. I'm only 5'5" and weigh only 120-150 (it seems to fluctuate between those extremes. If she were to ever "be on top", I wouldn't want to feel like I was being crushed, since I have a small frame...so, please, nothing more than me (so no 200 lb girls, or even 150). When it comes to height I prefer her to be taller than me with heels on, but shorter, when they're off. I realize there are different height heels, but as long as she's at least one or 2" taller than me with them on, I'm golden :)
Between normal on the thin side and normal on the larger side.
Average or tall.
I would like that because that's closely related to me.
Average height chubby girl is what I mainly go for.
What Girls Said 2
any and all shapes if your asking everyone here.
lol at any of the guys putting thin or small being downvoted and chubby girls preference being upvoted only, OP or other user obviously can't handle that guys have different preferences and overweight isn't the only right answer