A friend of mine said that recently. That cuddling or having sex with a bit thicker woman feels better. Not obese obviously, but a bit bigger than would be considered ideal. He said like plus size model robyn lawley link or marilyn monroe link
But Victoria's secret thin, just looks better linklink
Would you agree? And if so what would be more important to you? Obviously you can't have both
Thicker >> Thinner. Your friend makes a valid observation. Thicker girls have more cushion for the pushin' and more ass to grasp. Skinny girls do look better because most clothes are made for them and their bodies generally have excess fat which can change their features.
Something in the middle has the best of both worlds though. So here link it would be one middle, 2 right, 3 left for me
Thin, Thick , these are subjective terms. How long is a long piece of rope? Boob: C cup to DD. DDD is too much. Hips: round, curvy even full are good terms. If your arm pits to your ankles is a strait line this is bad. Booty: round, full and bubble are good. Blade type, flat or flabby = bad. Also, The breast should stick out further than the stomach. These are all my opinion, but most men will agree with me on almost everything I have said.
If by "thick" you mean girls with those figures, then they feel better AND look better than very thin women. But many girls really mean this: link when they describe themselves as thick. In that case, thin would be better. But a woman blessed with a shape like Marilyn Monroe or Kim K is very lucky. A small waist and big hips is the best of both worlds and will be attractive to a majority of men.