Girl and I started casually seeing each other, and now she is upset that I am talking to other girls?

Anonymous
We started having casual sex a few weeks ago. I said that I didn’t want to lead her on and that I wasn’t looking for anything serious, she said that’s fine and neither was she. She asked me to tell her if I slept with anyone else and asked her to do the same. I knew she was talking to other guys because she was telling me about them.

A few days ago she asked me if I was talking to anyone and I said a couple but nothing has come of it yet. She immediately asked if we should stop, and I said if she wanted to we could. And then proceeded to ask if she wasn’t good enough and asking why I was looking for other girls? I said we aren’t exclusive and that I thought we had an understanding. And she reiterated that she didn’t want to start a serious relationship at all but she doesn’t want to feel like she is being replaced with someone better, which to me basically sounds like a serious relationship without the label.

I am Just so confused because I know she is still talking to guys on dating apps, and she has said “just tell me if you sleep with someone else” and now she doesn’t want to feel like she is being replaced. She said if it’s going that direction she wants a heads up. I feel like no matter what, if I talk to other girls, she is going to feel like I am replacing her, even though we had agreed we aren’t exclusive at all. What should I do?
Girl and I started casually seeing each other, and now she is upset that I am talking to other girls?
3 Opinion