I want to date this guy but there's another guy in the picture?

Ok so this other guy (I'll call him Jake) has liked me for almost 5 years straight and I've liked him too, like a lot, and I kinda implied that I wanted to date him in the future. But anyways, I later found out that I didn't want to date him due to moral and religious difference, the main one being that he is homophobic and transphobic and I am bisexual and genderfluid. But I'm afraid to tell him because I still have to go to the same church as him ( my parents make me) and I'm afraid that he's going to tell people and my parents will find out that I'm party of the LGBTQ+ community. Anyways it would ask not be a problem if I didn't like this other guy ( I'll call him ducky) ducky is just absolutely perfect for me, and he likes me too, like, a lot. And I really like him too. I want to date him so bad, but I can't until I figure this out. What do I do? I can't just tell Jake that I like someone else and move on with it, it'll break his heart and I'll have to see him every Sunday and sometimes Wednesdays. Uggghhhh 😩😩😩 I really need help, please.

I want to date this guy but there's another guy in the picture?
Post Opinion