Why am I always the second choice?

Anonymous
Without sounding arrogant. I'm very attractive, educated, doing well financially and caring to those who are nice to me. And I've been single for 2 yrs.

I often attract the wrong guy, either they chase me and other girls at the same time and ended up choosing the girl who only has half my quality. Or I would attract guys who are already taken but just chasing me for the thrill, and they would pull back when I show interest (before we get physical)

Some girls I know who are not very attractive and such but have the power to make men leave their partner / wifes for them. Is there something I'm missing? If so what is it?
Why am I always the second choice?
5 Opinion